War and Intervention Textbook Chapter notes GVPT 241 - 12/2/25
Introduction to the Ethics of War
War is identified as one of the most morally challenging issues in human existence.
Leads to killing and maiming on a large scale.
Results in the destruction of social infrastructure, political systems, and cultural sites.
Causes catastrophic environmental damage.
Despite rising international human rights discourse, war remains prevalent.
Notable conflicts include:
Kosovo
The Falklands
Iraq
Afghanistan
Ongoing civil conflicts: Chechnya, Syria, Libya, Sierra Leone.
Ethical Considerations Following 9/11 Attacks
Increased academic and public interest in the ethics of war post-September 11, 2001.
War often highlights political and philosophical issues related to ethics in governance and individual responsibility.
Emphasis on the global political landscape involving humanitarian intervention versus sovereignty.
Duty to recognize and fulfill universal human rights in contexts of humanitarian intervention.
Just War Theory
Common Misinterpretations
Misleading notion of a singular 'just war theory.'
Reality: Many competing theories exist regarding what constitutes a just war.
Consensus on criteria like proportionality exists, but interpretations vary.
Historical Roots of Just War Theory
Originates from Catholic theologians such as Augustine and Aquinas.
Augustine's views on just causes for war include:
Defense against aggression.
Restoration of stolen property.
Punishment of wrongdoing.
Emphasis on organized Christianity's necessity for peace and morality.
Doctrine of Double Effect (DDE)
Originated from Aquinas' works on self-defense.
DDE Definition: Permissible to cause harm as a side effect of pursuing a good end, as long as the harm is not intended.
E.g., Harm to an attacker is permissible if the intention is solely self-defense.
DDE's significance in just war thinking despite skepticism from some philosophers.
Just War Theory vs. International Law
Law of Armed Conflict (LOAC)
Developed through customary law and formal treaties (e.g., Geneva Conventions).
Disagreement remains over morality versus legality in warfare.
Just war theory has branches defined by distinct criteria:
Jus ad Bellum: Justice before war.
Jus in Bello: Justice during war.
Jus post Bellum: Justice after war.
Recent Developments in Just War Theory
Growing interest in Jus post Bellum due to Iraq and Afghanistan wars.
Importance of post-war outcomes linked to the just cause of war.
Understanding Just War Theory's Principles
Just Cause: Refers to reasons behind a war, primarily the self-defense of rights.
Legitimate Authority: Only recognized leaders or bodies can declare war.
Last Resort: War must be the final option after exploring all alternatives.
Proportionality: The good achieved must outweigh the harm caused by war.
Reasonable Prospect of Success: Wars fought with minuscule chances of success are deemed unjust.
Right Intention: War must be declared and fought for just motivations.
Public Declaration: Maintaining transparency about intentions to achieve legitimacy.
Critiques of Just War Theory
Alternatives to Just War Theory
Pacifism: Rejects the moral permissibility of all forms of violence.
Realism: Views war as a political tool devoid of moral consideration.
Contingent Pacifism: Considers the potential for a just war but rejects current military methods as inadequate.
Theoretical Approaches to the Ethics of War
Collectivism in Just War Theory
Dominated by thinkers like Michael Walzer.
War is defined as a collective action between states, not individuals.
Morality of war cannot be judged by individual standards.
Domestic Analogy: Comparing state aggression to crime in personal life.
A state's right to defend its citizens being prioritized over individual actions.
Individualism in Just War Theory
Criticism of collectivist perspectives emphasizes individual moral accountability.
Jeff McMahon argues against collective permissions in acts of war.
Morality of warfare should reflect ordinary moral principles governing individual conduct.
Conditions of Jus ad Bellum
Legitimate authority, just cause, last resort, proportionality, right intention, public declaration, reasonable prospect of success are crucial criteria for just war declaration.
Definition of Just Cause
Typically includes self-defense against aggression or collective defense.
Preemptive Wars: Actions taken based on perceived threats; legally acceptable as self-defense.
Differentiate from Preventive Wars, which act absent immediate threats to disable a potential future aggressor.
Conditions of Jus in Bello
Key Moral Principles
Discrimination Principle: Distinction between combatants (competence) and non-combatants (nonconfidence).
Proportionality in Warfare: Military actions taken must not intentionally harm noncombatants excessively.
Military Necessity: Harmful actions must be necessary for achieving legitimate military aims.
Jus post Bellum
Traditionally neglected; recently revitalized interest focuses on obligations incurred by victors and the need for reparations, punishment, and rebuilding.
Minimalist versus maximalist accounts of justice after wartime; balancing the responsibilities of victors against the necessity to support the innocent affected by war.
Conclusion
Just war theory continues to evolve amidst modern ethical challenges raised by global conflicts and the shifts in representation of war.
The continued emphasis on individual responsibility within warfare reflects changes in democratic accountability and human rights awareness.