War and Intervention Textbook Chapter notes GVPT 241 - 12/2/25

Introduction to the Ethics of War

  • War is identified as one of the most morally challenging issues in human existence.

    • Leads to killing and maiming on a large scale.

    • Results in the destruction of social infrastructure, political systems, and cultural sites.

    • Causes catastrophic environmental damage.

    • Despite rising international human rights discourse, war remains prevalent.

    • Notable conflicts include:

    • Kosovo

    • The Falklands

    • Iraq

    • Afghanistan

    • Ongoing civil conflicts: Chechnya, Syria, Libya, Sierra Leone.

Ethical Considerations Following 9/11 Attacks

  • Increased academic and public interest in the ethics of war post-September 11, 2001.

  • War often highlights political and philosophical issues related to ethics in governance and individual responsibility.

  • Emphasis on the global political landscape involving humanitarian intervention versus sovereignty.

  • Duty to recognize and fulfill universal human rights in contexts of humanitarian intervention.

Just War Theory

Common Misinterpretations

  • Misleading notion of a singular 'just war theory.'

    • Reality: Many competing theories exist regarding what constitutes a just war.

    • Consensus on criteria like proportionality exists, but interpretations vary.

Historical Roots of Just War Theory

  • Originates from Catholic theologians such as Augustine and Aquinas.

    • Augustine's views on just causes for war include:

    • Defense against aggression.

    • Restoration of stolen property.

    • Punishment of wrongdoing.

    • Emphasis on organized Christianity's necessity for peace and morality.

Doctrine of Double Effect (DDE)

  • Originated from Aquinas' works on self-defense.

    • DDE Definition: Permissible to cause harm as a side effect of pursuing a good end, as long as the harm is not intended.

    • E.g., Harm to an attacker is permissible if the intention is solely self-defense.

  • DDE's significance in just war thinking despite skepticism from some philosophers.

Just War Theory vs. International Law

Law of Armed Conflict (LOAC)

  • Developed through customary law and formal treaties (e.g., Geneva Conventions).

    • Disagreement remains over morality versus legality in warfare.

    • Just war theory has branches defined by distinct criteria:

    • Jus ad Bellum: Justice before war.

    • Jus in Bello: Justice during war.

    • Jus post Bellum: Justice after war.

Recent Developments in Just War Theory

  • Growing interest in Jus post Bellum due to Iraq and Afghanistan wars.

    • Importance of post-war outcomes linked to the just cause of war.

Understanding Just War Theory's Principles

  • Just Cause: Refers to reasons behind a war, primarily the self-defense of rights.

  • Legitimate Authority: Only recognized leaders or bodies can declare war.

  • Last Resort: War must be the final option after exploring all alternatives.

  • Proportionality: The good achieved must outweigh the harm caused by war.

  • Reasonable Prospect of Success: Wars fought with minuscule chances of success are deemed unjust.

  • Right Intention: War must be declared and fought for just motivations.

  • Public Declaration: Maintaining transparency about intentions to achieve legitimacy.

Critiques of Just War Theory

Alternatives to Just War Theory

  1. Pacifism: Rejects the moral permissibility of all forms of violence.

  2. Realism: Views war as a political tool devoid of moral consideration.

  3. Contingent Pacifism: Considers the potential for a just war but rejects current military methods as inadequate.

Theoretical Approaches to the Ethics of War

Collectivism in Just War Theory

  • Dominated by thinkers like Michael Walzer.

    • War is defined as a collective action between states, not individuals.

    • Morality of war cannot be judged by individual standards.

  • Domestic Analogy: Comparing state aggression to crime in personal life.

    • A state's right to defend its citizens being prioritized over individual actions.

Individualism in Just War Theory

  • Criticism of collectivist perspectives emphasizes individual moral accountability.

    • Jeff McMahon argues against collective permissions in acts of war.

    • Morality of warfare should reflect ordinary moral principles governing individual conduct.

Conditions of Jus ad Bellum

  • Legitimate authority, just cause, last resort, proportionality, right intention, public declaration, reasonable prospect of success are crucial criteria for just war declaration.

Definition of Just Cause

  • Typically includes self-defense against aggression or collective defense.

  • Preemptive Wars: Actions taken based on perceived threats; legally acceptable as self-defense.

  • Differentiate from Preventive Wars, which act absent immediate threats to disable a potential future aggressor.

Conditions of Jus in Bello

Key Moral Principles

  • Discrimination Principle: Distinction between combatants (competence) and non-combatants (nonconfidence).

  • Proportionality in Warfare: Military actions taken must not intentionally harm noncombatants excessively.

  • Military Necessity: Harmful actions must be necessary for achieving legitimate military aims.

Jus post Bellum

  • Traditionally neglected; recently revitalized interest focuses on obligations incurred by victors and the need for reparations, punishment, and rebuilding.

  • Minimalist versus maximalist accounts of justice after wartime; balancing the responsibilities of victors against the necessity to support the innocent affected by war.

Conclusion

  • Just war theory continues to evolve amidst modern ethical challenges raised by global conflicts and the shifts in representation of war.

  • The continued emphasis on individual responsibility within warfare reflects changes in democratic accountability and human rights awareness.