Ethics and the Rough Ground of the Everyday in Postinvasion Iraq

Concept of the "Rough Ground" of Everyday Ethics

  • Philosophical Basis: Draws on Ludwig Wittgenstein's directive to return to the "rough ground" of everyday language and life, opposing abstract moral ideals unmoored from daily context.

  • Definition of Everyday Ethics: Ethics is understood as an intercorporeal experience generated within the mundane encounters, entanglements, and relations of daily life rather than through formal institutional codes, self-cultivation, or rigid social structures (such as tribalism or sectarianism).

  • Relational Care: Lines of care, empathy, joy, and concern emerge, are sustained, or fray through living-in-action and openness to the lives and suffering of others.

Socio-Political Context of Postinvasion Iraq

  • Beyond Social Breakdown: Conventional accounts of post-2003 Iraq emphasize state collapse, militia violence, and looting (al-hawasim); however, everyday life consists of complex "ravelings"—connections and gestures that enable survival amid destruction.

  • Integration of Event and Everyday: The everyday is not separate from violent events; rather, moments of kindness and shared vulnerability form the foundational ground through which Iraqis navigate ongoing instability.

Key Ethnographic Vignettes in Basra

  • Abu-Hibba and Interconnectedness: Illustrates how shared past lives create enduring bonds (marboot), prompting deep personal care, protection, and shared obligations without requiring formal gratitude.

  • Rent Relief for Abu-Sabar: Abu-Hibba anonymously paid three months of rent for a former coworker facing eviction, driven by empathetic self-recognition ("we all saw ourselves in their position") rather than religious piety or close kinship.

  • Support for the Street Vendor: Basran locals regularly buy produce from an irritable female vendor supporting her brain-damaged father and street orphans, using routine purchases as an informal, collective buffer against her hardship and harassment.

Intercorporeality and Navigating Everyday Trajectories

  • Prereflexive Bodily Ethics: Building on Edward Casey's ethics of the glance and Erving Goffman's pedestrian analyses, ethical life is expressed through bodily dispositions, adjustments in gait, and implicit movements that allow others to pass.

  • Intercorporeal Sociality: Social relations are embodied rather than strictly intersubjective; making physical space for others on the street is a fundamental ethical recognition of their trajectory and right to exist in shared spaces.

Summary
  • This note explores the concept of an "ethics of the rough ground" in postinvasion Iraq, drawing from Ludwig Wittgenstein's philosophy and ethnographic fieldwork in Basra by Hayder Al-Mohammad and Daniela Peluso.

  • Moving beyond dominant narratives of state collapse, sectarian division, and social unraveling, it emphasizes how everyday mundane interactions, intercorporeal care, and shared vulnerability allow Iraqis to survive and sustain meaningful social existence amid ongoing instability.

Core Ideas
  • Ethics of the Rough Ground: Ethics is grounded in the friction and encounters of daily life rather than abstract moral ideals, formal codes, or rigid institutional frameworks (e.g., tribalism, sectarianism, or self-cultivation).

  • Ravelings Amid Unraveling: While macro-level accounts highlight destruction and violence, social life is remade through "ravelings"—small, subtle gestures, acts of care, and shared responsibility.

  • Relational and Intercorporeal Care: Ethical life is embodied and relational; lives are deeply connected (marboot), and small bodily adjustments or practical acts protect and validate others' trajectories.

  • Integration of Event and Everyday: Violent events and ordinary life are not separate; routine daily encounters serve as an informal, collective buffer against ongoing hardship.

Important Definitions
  • Rough Ground of Everyday Ethics: An ethical framework derived from Wittgenstein's critique of abstract language, asserting that ethics originates from bodily presence, daily encounters, and context-dependent care rather than formal moral systems.

  • Marboot (Interconnectedness): An Iraqi conceptualization of lives being tied or bound together through shared history, past experiences, and mutual survival, creating deep obligation and care without requiring formal gratitude or institutional backing.

  • Al-Hawasim: A term originally meaning "the final war" (used by Saddam Hussein), which colloquially evolved to describe looted goods, illicitly occupied lands, and opportunistic looters following the 2003 invasion.

  • Intercorporeality: A phenomenological concept indicating that social and ethical relations are experienced through bodily dispositions, physical presence, and pre-reflexive adjustments (e.g., gait, yielding space) rather than purely cognitive or intersubjective reflection.

Concept of the "Rough Ground" of Everyday Ethics
  • Philosophical Basis: Draws on Ludwig Wittgenstein's directive to return to the "rough ground" of everyday language and life, opposing abstract moral ideals unmoored from daily context.

  • Definition of Everyday Ethics: Ethics is understood as an intercorporeal experience generated within the mundane encounters, entanglements, and relations of daily life rather than through formal institutional codes, self-cultivation, or rigid social structures (such as tribalism or sectarianism).

  • Relational Care: Lines of care, empathy, joy, and concern emerge, are sustained, or fray through living-in-action and openness to the lives and suffering of others.

Socio-Political Context of Postinvasion Iraq
  • Beyond Social Breakdown: Conventional accounts of post-2003 Iraq emphasize state collapse, militia violence, and looting (al-hawasim); however, everyday life consists of complex "ravelings"—connections and gestures that enable survival amid destruction.

  • Integration of Event and Everyday: The everyday is not separate from violent events; rather, moments of kindness and shared vulnerability form the foundational ground through which Iraqis navigate ongoing instability.

Key Ethnographic Vignettes in Basra
  • Abu-Hibba and Interconnectedness: Illustrates how shared past lives create enduring bonds (marboot), prompting deep personal care, protection, and shared obligations without requiring formal gratitude.

  • Rent Relief for Abu-Sabar: Abu-Hibba anonymously paid three months of rent for a former coworker facing eviction, driven by empathetic self-recognition ("we all saw ourselves in their position") rather than religious piety or close kinship.

  • Support for the Street Vendor: Basran locals regularly buy produce from an irritable female vendor supporting her brain-damaged father and street orphans, using routine purchases as an informal, collective buffer against her hardship and harassment.

Intercorporeality and Navigating Everyday Trajectories
  • Prereflexive Bodily Ethics: Building on Edward Casey's ethics of the glance and Erving Goffman's pedestrian analyses, ethical life is expressed through bodily dispositions, adjustments in gait, and implicit movements that allow others to pass.

  • Intercorporeal Sociality: Social relations are embodied rather than strictly intersubjective; making physical space for others on the street is a fundamental ethical recognition of their trajectory and right to exist in shared spaces.