Comprehensive Study Guide on In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) and Ethical Considerations

Overview and Medical Procedure of In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF)

  • Definition and Terminology:

    • IVF stands for 'in vitro fertilisation'.
    • The phrase 'in vitro' literally translates to 'in glass'.
  • Step-by-Step Medical Procedure:

    • The procedure involves doctors bringing a human egg and sperm together in a test tube or petri dish.
    • If fertilisation is successful, doctors place the resulting embryo into the woman's uterus, where it continues to grow and develop in the usual way.
    • Because the IVF procedure is not always successful, doctors will fertilise more than one egg so that the healthiest embryo can be selected for implantation.

Ethical Concerns Regarding Embryos

  • Creation and Fate of 'Spare' Embryos:

    • Fertilising more eggs than are needed for immediate implantation leads to the creation of 'spare' embryos.
    • Significant ethical debates surround what should happen to these extra embryos: whether it is morally acceptable to use them for research, or whether these 'spare' (or 'doomed') embryos should simply be destroyed.
  • Christian Perspectives on Embryo Destruction:

    • Many Christians view the destruction of spare embryos as committing murder.
    • This perspective is based on the belief that human life begins at conception, meaning that every embryo is a potential person.
    • Under Christian doctrine, all human life is sacred because human beings are created in the 'image of God'.
  • Embryo Freezing:

    • Not all spare embryos are destroyed or used for scientific research; some may be frozen for later use if the couple decides to try for more children through IVF at a later date.
    • Freezing human embryos raises moral concerns about whether it can be right to create a human life and subsequently freeze it indefinitely.
  • Multiple Embryo Implantation and Selective Abortion:

    • When an embryo is placed in the woman's uterus, there is no guarantee that it will successfully implant.
    • It can be standard practice to place more than one embryo into the uterus simultaneously to increase the likelihood of success.
    • If subsequent ultrasound scans reveal that multiple embryos have successfully implanted, the healthiest embryo is chosen to remain, while the 'extra' embryos are removed through a selective abortion.
    • For many Christians, undergoing selective abortion in an IVF context is just as morally unacceptable as having an abortion for an unwanted pregnancy.

Social, Philosophical, and Personal Implications

  • Use of Donated Gametes and Adultery Concerns:

    • IVF procedures do not always use sperm and eggs provided by the couple wishing to have a child.
    • It is sometimes necessary to use donated sperm and eggs, which are usually obtained from an anonymous donor.
    • Some people view the involvement of donor gametes as a form of adultery, grounded in the view that a 'third party' is being brought in to assist in the creation of new life.
  • Psychological Impact on Children:

    • Concerns exist regarding the long-term emotional and psychological impact of IVF on children when they grow up.
    • It can be distressing for a child to discover that they have no genetic connection to one or both of their parents due to the use of anonymous donors, which can cause significant identity issues.
  • Eligibility Criteria and NHS Funding:

    • Controversy exists over who should be permitted to receive IVF treatment.
    • Some people contend that treatment should only be available to heterosexual married couples, particularly when the medical treatment is provided on the National Health Service (NHS).
  • Non-Traditional Family Structures:

    • IVF treatment enables single individuals and same-sex couples to have children, occasionally utilizing a surrogate mother.
    • Some Christians express concern that these non-traditional arrangements go against Bible teaching regarding family relationships and are not what God intended.
  • Success Rates, Financial Costs, and Psychological Strain:

    • IVF treatment can have a low success rate.
    • The process can be extremely expensive, placing a financial burden either on the couple themselves or on the NHS.
    • Facing a series of unsuccessful IVF treatments can cause a great deal of strain on the couple involved.