Midterm Essay Writing and Citation Guidelines
Midterm Essay Assignment Guidelines
Word Count and Scope: The essay requires approximately 1,200 words (roughly five pages), synthesizing roughly 100 years of Middle Eastern history across multiple countries and colonies up through recent course material.
Core Sources: Analysis must draw comprehensively upon assigned materials, specifically Cleveland and Bunham (Cleveland and Button), Galvin, Provence, and the instructor's chapter (with the Ledge article and Palestine materials optional if relevant).
Core Objective: Produce a succinct, comprehensive argument demonstrating deep understanding rather than vague factual summaries or isolated case studies.
Extra Credit Opportunity: Viewing a campus Middle East film screening (screened during a trip to Malone, New York) and submitting a one-paragraph reflection on a compelling theme.
Essay Structure and Composition
Overall Architecture: A seven to eight paragraph essay comprising an introduction, approximately five body paragraphs, and a conclusion.
Sectional Organization: Two to four thematic or chronological subsections (each spanning two to three paragraphs), separated by colorful, creative subheadings.
Introductory Paragraph: Must remain succinct (ideally 60 to 70 words) and contain two core elements:
Hook: A clever, concise device to engage the reader, such as a counterintuitive historical fact or a focused quotation.
Thesis: A single overarching argument directly answering the prompt, avoiding mere laundry-list summaries.
Body Paragraphs: Average five to six sentences in length. Each functions as an independent mini-essay starting with an argumentative topic sentence (not a raw fact) preceded by a transition.
Coherence Test: Assembling the thesis together with every topic sentence into a continuous paragraph must produce a logical, self-contained summary of the entire argument.
Citation and Quotation Standards
Citation Format: Chicago style footnotes are mandatory. Initial citations require full bibliographical details; subsequent citations require author surname and page number.
Footnote Frequency and Page Numbers: Expect approximately 15 to 20 footnotes across the paper (roughly two to three per body paragraph). Exact page numbers are mandatory; omitting them is treated as academic dishonesty.
Mandatory Citation Rule: Footnotes are required for all non-original ideas, data, and paraphrasing, with two exceptions: information presented directly in lecture and general common knowledge (e.g., the capital of Jordan being Amman).
Strategic Use of Quotations: Direct quotations are optional literary devices used sparingly (approximately two to three in the paper), primarily to:
Unpack an author's unique terminology or newly coined concepts.
Contrast opposing scholarly viewpoints or disagree with a text.
Provide primary source evidence (e.g., Midhad Vasha).
Invoke scholarly authority.
Questions and Discussion
Permissible Sources (Steven): Inquiry regarding required texts. Response affirmed the core four readings (Cleveland and Bunham, Galvin, Provence, and the book chapter), while noting modern materials and the Ledge article are acceptable only if directly applicable.
Citation Mechanics: Inquiry regarding in-text citations versus footnotes. Response clarified that Chicago style strictly requires footnotes.
Hook Brainstorming:
Jack suggested opening with Mark Twain's quotation, "History never repeats itself, but it often does rhyme." Critique noted broad quotations require excessive work to connect back to a specific thesis.
A student proposed quoting texts on identity (religion versus nationality) to define nationalism before the thesis.
Instructor suggested counterintuitive historical statements, such as post-World War I Palestinians seeking inclusion in a Syrian state.
Cultural Writing Norms (Clarice): Discussion contrasting the French method (introducing a problematic question at the outset and revealing the thesis answer at the end) with the required thesis-first Anglo-American academic model.
Quotation Limits: Inquiry on acceptable limits for direct quotes. Response emphasized that academic papers should prioritize synthesized paraphrasing with heavy footnoting, rather than excessive direct quotations.