PRINTED / TEST READY Lecture 1/15/26


Political Development, Presidential Power, and Background to the Founding

🧨 1. The Insurrection Act & Presidential Power

Student question: Can the president use the Insurrection Act to stop protests?
Professor’s answer: “I don’t know… the constitutionality or legality is unclear.”

Why unclear?

  • The Constitution does not explicitly grant this power.

  • Article II only says the president is Commander in Chief of the armed forces.

  • Article II is vague, unlike Article I (Congress), which is very detailed.

Three Interpretations of Presidential Power

These are major test concepts.

1. Constitutional / Strict Construction
  • President only has powers explicitly listed in the Constitution.

  • Associated with Jefferson (even though he violated it with the Louisiana Purchase).

  • Quote: “If it’s not a power that’s been listed then it’s not a power the president has.”

2. Stewardship Theory
  • President can do anything not prohibited by law or the Constitution.

  • Associated with Teddy Roosevelt, Andrew Jackson, Lincoln.

  • Expands presidential power without breaking explicit rules.

3. Prerogative Power
  • President may take any action necessary to protect the nation, even if not authorized.

  • Associated with Nixon.

  • Nixon quote: “If the president does it, it’s not illegal.”

Modern Trend

  • Presidents of both parties have moved toward prerogative power.

  • Courts have increasingly allowed it.

  • Professor: “I have presidential derangement syndrome… it’s all presidents.”

🔥 2. Watergate & Nixon (Used as Example of Prerogative Power)

  • Nixon’s campaign (CREEP) broke into the Democratic HQ at the Watergate Hotel.

  • They planted listening devices.

  • He didn’t need to — he won almost every state in 1972.

  • The cover‑up revealed:

    • Illegal surveillance

    • FBI used against journalists

    • Break‑ins of private offices

    • Secret recordings

    • Foreign policy abuses (Chile, Cambodia, Laos)

Key takeaway: Watergate illustrates the dangers of prerogative power.

đź§­ 3. Political Development (VERY IMPORTANT TERM)

Political development = how history shapes political institutions.

  • Path dependence: once a society starts down a path, it tends to stay on it.

  • Quote: “Where you’ve come from has an influence on where you’re going.”

Example used:
Ancient Roman roads → modern European trade routes still follow them.

đź’° 4. Political Economy

Political + economic power are interconnected.

  • The causal relationship is two‑way (“a horseshoe,” not a straight arrow).

  • Politics shapes economics; economics shapes politics.

📚 5. Political Theory / Philosophy

You will need these for the Founding & Constitution:

  • Republicanism

  • Liberalism

These ideas come from:

  • Aristotle

  • Rome

  • Renaissance rediscovery of classical texts

  • Enlightenment thinkers

🌍 6. Eurocentric Story of Colonization

Professor warns:

  • This is a Eurocentric narrative because that’s what the Civic Literacy exam tests.

  • Indigenous political systems (e.g., Iroquois Confederacy) are important but not tested.

🏰 7. Feudalism (Background Context Only)

You won’t be tested on details, but you need the basic structure:

  • King

  • Nobles

  • Knights

  • Peasants

Based on:

  • Land ownership

  • Divine order (“God said it’s going to be like that”)

  • Harsh punishment for questioning hierarchy (burning, execution)

Feudalism begins breaking down due to:

  1. Rise of cities & guilds

  2. Technological change (printing press)

  3. Contact with the Americas

  4. Protestant Reformation

  5. Renaissance & classical political ideas

đź–¨ 8. Printing Press = Political Revolution

  • Before printing: books were hand‑copied, rare, expensive.

  • After printing: ideas spread rapidly.

  • Quote: “This is the last time a change in communication technology would have a political impact. JK, lol.”

Printing helped:

  • Spread Reformation ideas

  • Spread news of the Americas

  • Spread political philosophy

âśť 9. Protestant Reformation

  • Martin Luther posts 95 Theses.

  • Printing press amplifies dissent.

  • Breaks Catholic Church’s monopoly on authority.

  • Creates new political fragmentation.

🎨 10. Renaissance & Republicanism

  • Renaissance = “rebirth” of classical ideas.

  • Renewed interest in:

    • Ancient Athens

    • Ancient Rome

    • Aristotle’s Politics

  • Leads to revival of republicanism.

Important correction:
When people say “America is a republic, not a democracy,” they usually misunderstand the term.
Founders meant Roman republicanism, not “representative vs. direct democracy.”


The instructor references the Constitution and its interpretations, especially Article II.

  • Article II grants the president powers but does not detail them explicitly, leading to varying interpretations.

  • Length: Approximately 7,000 words, including amendments.

Article II of the Constitution

  • Article II, Section 2, Clause 1: Establishes the president as the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces.

  • Highlights lack of specific directives about military use or presidential power during crises.

  • Discussion on the ambiguity creates disagreement over presidential powers.

Schools of Thought on Presidential Powers

  1. Constitutional School

    • Presidents possess only those powers explicitly listed in the Constitution.

    • Strict Constructionism: Associated with Jefferson's beliefs; implies limited authority.

  2. Presidential Stewardship

    • Presidents may exercise any power not explicitly prohibited by the Constitution or law.

    • Transition from Jeffersonian strictness to more expansive views of presidential authority.

  3. Prerogative Powers

    • Presidents possess all necessary powers to fulfill their responsibilities.

    • Reference to Nixon's administration and the controversial use of power, including the Watergate scandal.

    • Nixon's statement: "If the president does it, it’s not illegal."

Nixon and the Watergate Scandal

  • Nixon’s illegal activities: spying on Democrats, using executive power against journalists.

  • The Watergate scandal was compounded by a cover-up and abuse of power.

  • Discussion of the implications of power retention and overreach in future presidencies.

Political Trends and Concerns

  • Reflection on contemporary political discourse and increasing presidential authority under various administrations.

  • Comparison of political executive powers across different presidencies, noting a trajectory towards expanded authority.

  • Uncertainty regarding the present and future trajectory of U.S. presidential power.

Historical Context: Colonization of the Americas

  • Upcoming class discussion will tell a historical story focused on colonization.

  • This narrative will examine U.S. founding and the Constitution through a political science lens, specifically political development.

Concepts in Political Science

  • Political Development: The relationship between historical events and political systems.

  • Path Dependence: Historical developments influence contemporary political outcomes.

Political Economy

  • Definition: Interconnectedness of political and economic systems.

  • The causal relationship between politics and economics is bidirectional.

Political Theory

  • Focus on the shaping of politics through ideas, particularly republicanism and liberalism.

  • Engagement with philosophical concepts that underpin the U.S. Constitution.

Euro-Centric Narrative of Colonization

  • The story primarily focuses on European perspectives, ignoring indigenous narratives to align with exam expectations.

  • Acknowledges the presence and contributions of indigenous people while focusing on European colonization.

Feudal Europe Context

  • Description of feudalism as a system of social hierarchies (king, nobility, knights, peasants).

  • Rise of cities and changes in technology began challenging feudal structures.

    • Introduction of the printing press in the 1400s drastically changed dissemination of ideas.

Historical Events Leading to Change

  • Press coverage of the 1492 Columbus voyages misrepresented the complexities and consequences of European exploration.

  • Protestant Reformation and technological advancements significantly shifted paradigms.

The Renaissance and Political Interest

  • Revival of classical ideas during the Renaissance period influenced political thought.

  • Emerging interest in republicanism as a governing concept.

Republicanism versus Democracy

  • Distinction between republicanism (government of representation) and democracy (direct rule of the many).

  • Misunderstanding of republicanism often conflated with modern party politics.

Definitions of Regimes by Aristotle

  • Regimes categorized into three forms: rule by one (monarchy), rule by a few (aristocracy), and rule by many (democracy).

    • Ideal and practical considerations highlighted; self-interested rule often leads to tyranny or oligarchy.

The Concept of the Republic
  • Republic defined as a system that blends elements of various regimes.

  • The public good outcomes depend on cooperation between diverse interests within society.

Historical Examples of Governance Structures

  • The Roman Republic as a comparative model showcasing checks and balances through senate and tribunes.

  • Link to the U.S. government structure with separate powers.

Liberalism as a Foundational Idea

  • Liberalism emerged in response to religious conflicts; focuses on individual rights and liberties.

  • Social contract theory emphasizes collective agreement to form governments for mutual protection of rights.

  • Principle: “No taxation without representation.”

Conclusion
  • A combination of republicanism and liberalism influenced the U.S. Constitution, rooted in historical contexts of rights and representation.

  • The importance of historical perspectives in understanding the functionality and evolution of political systems.