PRINTED / TEST READY Lecture 1/15/26
Political Development, Presidential Power, and Background to the Founding
🧨 1. The Insurrection Act & Presidential Power
Student question: Can the president use the Insurrection Act to stop protests?
Professor’s answer: “I don’t know… the constitutionality or legality is unclear.”
Why unclear?
The Constitution does not explicitly grant this power.
Article II only says the president is Commander in Chief of the armed forces.
Article II is vague, unlike Article I (Congress), which is very detailed.
Three Interpretations of Presidential Power
These are major test concepts.
1. Constitutional / Strict Construction
President only has powers explicitly listed in the Constitution.
Associated with Jefferson (even though he violated it with the Louisiana Purchase).
Quote: “If it’s not a power that’s been listed then it’s not a power the president has.”
2. Stewardship Theory
President can do anything not prohibited by law or the Constitution.
Associated with Teddy Roosevelt, Andrew Jackson, Lincoln.
Expands presidential power without breaking explicit rules.
3. Prerogative Power
President may take any action necessary to protect the nation, even if not authorized.
Associated with Nixon.
Nixon quote: “If the president does it, it’s not illegal.”
Modern Trend
Presidents of both parties have moved toward prerogative power.
Courts have increasingly allowed it.
Professor: “I have presidential derangement syndrome… it’s all presidents.”
🔥 2. Watergate & Nixon (Used as Example of Prerogative Power)
Nixon’s campaign (CREEP) broke into the Democratic HQ at the Watergate Hotel.
They planted listening devices.
He didn’t need to — he won almost every state in 1972.
The cover‑up revealed:
Illegal surveillance
FBI used against journalists
Break‑ins of private offices
Secret recordings
Foreign policy abuses (Chile, Cambodia, Laos)
Key takeaway: Watergate illustrates the dangers of prerogative power.
đź§ 3. Political Development (VERY IMPORTANT TERM)
Political development = how history shapes political institutions.
Path dependence: once a society starts down a path, it tends to stay on it.
Quote: “Where you’ve come from has an influence on where you’re going.”
Example used:
Ancient Roman roads → modern European trade routes still follow them.
đź’° 4. Political Economy
Political + economic power are interconnected.
The causal relationship is two‑way (“a horseshoe,” not a straight arrow).
Politics shapes economics; economics shapes politics.
📚 5. Political Theory / Philosophy
You will need these for the Founding & Constitution:
Republicanism
Liberalism
These ideas come from:
Aristotle
Rome
Renaissance rediscovery of classical texts
Enlightenment thinkers
🌍 6. Eurocentric Story of Colonization
Professor warns:
This is a Eurocentric narrative because that’s what the Civic Literacy exam tests.
Indigenous political systems (e.g., Iroquois Confederacy) are important but not tested.
🏰 7. Feudalism (Background Context Only)
You won’t be tested on details, but you need the basic structure:
King
Nobles
Knights
Peasants
Based on:
Land ownership
Divine order (“God said it’s going to be like that”)
Harsh punishment for questioning hierarchy (burning, execution)
Feudalism begins breaking down due to:
Rise of cities & guilds
Technological change (printing press)
Contact with the Americas
Protestant Reformation
Renaissance & classical political ideas
đź–¨ 8. Printing Press = Political Revolution
Before printing: books were hand‑copied, rare, expensive.
After printing: ideas spread rapidly.
Quote: “This is the last time a change in communication technology would have a political impact. JK, lol.”
Printing helped:
Spread Reformation ideas
Spread news of the Americas
Spread political philosophy
âśť 9. Protestant Reformation
Martin Luther posts 95 Theses.
Printing press amplifies dissent.
Breaks Catholic Church’s monopoly on authority.
Creates new political fragmentation.
🎨 10. Renaissance & Republicanism
Renaissance = “rebirth” of classical ideas.
Renewed interest in:
Ancient Athens
Ancient Rome
Aristotle’s Politics
Leads to revival of republicanism.
Important correction:
When people say “America is a republic, not a democracy,” they usually misunderstand the term.
Founders meant Roman republicanism, not “representative vs. direct democracy.”
The instructor references the Constitution and its interpretations, especially Article II.
Article II grants the president powers but does not detail them explicitly, leading to varying interpretations.
Length: Approximately 7,000 words, including amendments.
Article II of the Constitution
Article II, Section 2, Clause 1: Establishes the president as the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces.
Highlights lack of specific directives about military use or presidential power during crises.
Discussion on the ambiguity creates disagreement over presidential powers.
Schools of Thought on Presidential Powers
Constitutional School
Presidents possess only those powers explicitly listed in the Constitution.
Strict Constructionism: Associated with Jefferson's beliefs; implies limited authority.
Presidential Stewardship
Presidents may exercise any power not explicitly prohibited by the Constitution or law.
Transition from Jeffersonian strictness to more expansive views of presidential authority.
Prerogative Powers
Presidents possess all necessary powers to fulfill their responsibilities.
Reference to Nixon's administration and the controversial use of power, including the Watergate scandal.
Nixon's statement: "If the president does it, it’s not illegal."
Nixon and the Watergate Scandal
Nixon’s illegal activities: spying on Democrats, using executive power against journalists.
The Watergate scandal was compounded by a cover-up and abuse of power.
Discussion of the implications of power retention and overreach in future presidencies.
Political Trends and Concerns
Reflection on contemporary political discourse and increasing presidential authority under various administrations.
Comparison of political executive powers across different presidencies, noting a trajectory towards expanded authority.
Uncertainty regarding the present and future trajectory of U.S. presidential power.
Historical Context: Colonization of the Americas
Upcoming class discussion will tell a historical story focused on colonization.
This narrative will examine U.S. founding and the Constitution through a political science lens, specifically political development.
Concepts in Political Science
Political Development: The relationship between historical events and political systems.
Path Dependence: Historical developments influence contemporary political outcomes.
Political Economy
Definition: Interconnectedness of political and economic systems.
The causal relationship between politics and economics is bidirectional.
Political Theory
Focus on the shaping of politics through ideas, particularly republicanism and liberalism.
Engagement with philosophical concepts that underpin the U.S. Constitution.
Euro-Centric Narrative of Colonization
The story primarily focuses on European perspectives, ignoring indigenous narratives to align with exam expectations.
Acknowledges the presence and contributions of indigenous people while focusing on European colonization.
Feudal Europe Context
Description of feudalism as a system of social hierarchies (king, nobility, knights, peasants).
Rise of cities and changes in technology began challenging feudal structures.
Introduction of the printing press in the 1400s drastically changed dissemination of ideas.
Historical Events Leading to Change
Press coverage of the 1492 Columbus voyages misrepresented the complexities and consequences of European exploration.
Protestant Reformation and technological advancements significantly shifted paradigms.
The Renaissance and Political Interest
Revival of classical ideas during the Renaissance period influenced political thought.
Emerging interest in republicanism as a governing concept.
Republicanism versus Democracy
Distinction between republicanism (government of representation) and democracy (direct rule of the many).
Misunderstanding of republicanism often conflated with modern party politics.
Definitions of Regimes by Aristotle
Regimes categorized into three forms: rule by one (monarchy), rule by a few (aristocracy), and rule by many (democracy).
Ideal and practical considerations highlighted; self-interested rule often leads to tyranny or oligarchy.
The Concept of the Republic
Republic defined as a system that blends elements of various regimes.
The public good outcomes depend on cooperation between diverse interests within society.
Historical Examples of Governance Structures
The Roman Republic as a comparative model showcasing checks and balances through senate and tribunes.
Link to the U.S. government structure with separate powers.
Liberalism as a Foundational Idea
Liberalism emerged in response to religious conflicts; focuses on individual rights and liberties.
Social contract theory emphasizes collective agreement to form governments for mutual protection of rights.
Principle: “No taxation without representation.”
Conclusion
A combination of republicanism and liberalism influenced the U.S. Constitution, rooted in historical contexts of rights and representation.
The importance of historical perspectives in understanding the functionality and evolution of political systems.