Critical Theories in International Relations: Marxism and Postcolonialism
Questions & Discussion
- Inquiry on Theoretical Proliferation:
- Question: There are eight theoretical families within International Relations explored, and many more beyond. Why are so many theories needed?
- Response: As the global system has grown in complexity, the family of theories that International Relations offers in response has grown in number. No single framework captures every dynamic of world politics. While realism and liberalism established the foundational debates, and the English school and constructivism opened up middle-ground alternatives, the post-Cold War era highlighted deep structural injustices that traditional approaches downplay or ignore. Multiple theories are required to provide an elastic "toolkit" capable of examining alternative ways of ordering the world and uncovering previously marginalized variables such as class, gender, race, and power.
The Evolution of International Relations Theory
Historical Trajectory of the Discipline:
- A central debate between realism and liberalism has animated International Relations since the foundation of the academic discipline.
- The English school subsequently emerged to carve out a theoretical middle ground between the two sparring traditions of realism and liberalism.
- Constructivism emerged later in the twentieth century, expanding this middle ground by emphasizing social structures, shared ideas, and identity.
- While these traditional and middle-ground perspectives dominated scholarly discourse for most of the twentieth century, growing dissatisfaction arose regarding the limited range of analytical possibilities they offered.
- The formal conclusion of the Cold War in 1991, coupled with profound transformations in the international order, catalyzed the rise of alternative frameworks critical of the journey International Relations had taken.
Core Purpose of Critical Frameworks:
- The unifying thread linking critical approaches is the shared objective to explore alternative ways of ordering the world.
- Critical theories explicitly uncover and interrogate fundamental factors that traditional frameworks choose to downplay, dismiss, or ignore.
- Critical approaches are inherently "revolutionary" in varying degrees, as their primary goal is to achieve concrete, material changes to the global status quo rather than merely observing or preserving it.
- Four of the most prominent critical theories in International Relations include:
- Marxism
- Feminism
- Postcolonialism
- Poststructuralism
- The theoretical "toolkit" approach provides analytical elasticity: diverse theories can be applied to the exact same case studies and empirical examples, with each theory yielding distinct insights.
Scientific Revolutions and Paradigm Shifts
Kuhn's Theoretical Framework:
- Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962) provides the foundational model for understanding how and why specific theories gain legitimacy, achieve widespread acceptance, and eventually lose relevance.
- Kuhn outlines the systematic process that unfolds when dominant frameworks fail to explain observed phenomena, prompting the emergence of competing explanations.
- A prominent historical parallel is the widespread human conviction that the Earth was flat: as technological and scientific capabilities advanced, empirical discoveries forced the abandonment of that belief.
- When an established worldview is overturned and superseded by an entirely new mode of thinking, a "paradigm shift" occurs.
Application to International Relations:
- Evolutions within International Relations theory are rarely as absolute or dramatic as the discovery of the spherical Earth, but the discipline undergoes significant conceptual shifts.
- Theoretical paradigms rise and evolve across different historical periods and personal contexts, meaning that specific frameworks resonate more effectively depending on the global environment being analyzed.
Typology of International Relations Theories: Traditional, Middle Ground, and Critical
Traditional Theories (Realism and Liberalism):
- Characterized by an analytical focus that takes the world "as it is" for granted.
- Built on observing existing realities rather than envisioning images of the world "as it ought to be."
- Overly restrictive because they limit the agency and analytical importance of the individual.
- Treat the nation-state as an inevitable, permanent given, which removes incentives to interrogate the state's coercive nature or its negative structural consequences.
Middle Ground Theories (English School and Constructivism):
- Aim to achieve compromise, bridge theoretical divides, or unify conflicting traditional approaches.
- Do not go far enough on their own to rectify entrenched flaws and pervasive injustices within the global system.
- Fail to provide an adequate voice to marginalized populations, particularly women and individuals from the Global South.
Critical Theories (Marxism, Poststructuralism, Postcolonialism, Feminism):
- Reject traditional, commonly held assumptions that have governed the discipline since its inception.
- Refuse to take the contemporary global architecture for granted, aiming directly to transform the world.
- Organize investigations around specific analytical focal points:
- Marxism: Focuses on class conflict, economic exploitation, and structural inequality.
- Poststructuralism: Focuses on the operation, discourse, and diffusion of power.
- Postcolonialism: Focuses on race, imperial legacies, and regional inequalities.
- Feminism: Focuses on gender hierarchies and patriarchal structures.
- Critical theories frequently borrow concepts from one another and hybridize, behaving more like an overlapping Venn diagram than rigid, isolated silos.
- Critical approaches regularly incorporate and expand upon analytical insights developed within constructivism.
Epistemological and Methodological Foundations: Positivism, Postpositivism, and Interpretivism
Rejection of Positivism:
- Critical theories generally reject positivism, which assumes that a scholar can examine the social world as a completely detached, objective, and neutral observer.
Postpositivism:
- Denies that a researcher can be detached from the social environment they analyze.
- Asserts that a researcher's identity, personal values, and theoretical assumptions actively shape what they observe and influence the conclusions they draw.
- Seeks objective answers by consciously identifying, acknowledging, and working within the reality of researcher bias in theory construction.
Interpretivism (Anti-Positivism):
- Takes postpositivism a step further by arguing that true objectivity is unattainable in social inquiry.
- Focuses on generating subjective knowledge through deep, nuanced observation and analysis of individuals or small groups.
- Primarily employs qualitative analysis, which seeks rich, deep datasets gathered from smaller sample sizes (such as semi-structured, detailed qualitative interviews).
- Directly contrasts with quantitative analysis, the methodology favored by positivism, which collects massive datasets from wide sample populations (such as standardized polls of hundreds or thousands of individuals with rigid yes/no/maybe answer selections) to identify broad statistical correlations.
Marxism: Core Tenets, Historical Development, and the Critique of the State
Foundational Tenets:
- Marxism is an unapologetically revolutionary theoretical tradition unified by the conviction that the contemporary global system must be dismantled and replaced.
- It is the only theoretical tradition within International Relations named directly after a single thinker.
- Karl Marx (1818–1883) was a German intellectual who formulated his economic and political critique during the height of the European Industrial Revolution.
- Rooted in Marx's dictum that while philosophical texts historically only interpret the world, the real imperative is to change it.
- Focuses on understanding historical processes to critique how the global architecture concentrates wealth and authority among the elite ("the 1 per cent") while subjugating everyday workers ("the 99 per cent").
- Rejects the notion that human beings are born free under capitalism; true emancipation requires raising revolutionary class consciousness to expose systemic injustice.
Class Architecture of Capitalist Society:
- Society is structurally divided into two adversarial classes:
- Bourgeoisie: The capitalist class of owners who monopolize the means of production, control wage levels, and dictate the working class's standard of living.
- Proletariat: The working class, who own no means of production and remain at the economic mercy of the bourgeoisie.
- Marx advocated for the total overthrow of the bourgeoisie by the proletariat through communist revolution to eliminate class hierarchy.
Communism as a Socioeconomic Model:
- Conceived in principle as an egalitarian society devoid of private ownership, rival political parties, and hierarchical social stratification.
- Relied on an all-powerful state to guarantee that all citizens receive equal outcomes, directly countering capitalist wealth concentration.
- The world's first successful communist revolution occurred in 1917, establishing the Soviet Union.
- Over the course of the twentieth century, variants of communism were implemented across approximately twenty-five states; every single one of these experiments gradually disintegrated due to economic failure and systemic political corruption (documented in Courtois et al. 1997 and dramatized in the 2019 Chernobyl television miniseries).
- The handful of self-identified communist states remaining today, including China and Vietnam, are communist in name only; they operate hybrid political economies that embrace capitalism and private property rights while maintaining authoritarian one-party rule and strict censorship of information.
- While the Cold War contrasted Western liberal states as the "free world" (due to multi-party democracy and a free press) against authoritarian communist regimes, contemporary Marxists argue that globalized capitalism and the nation-state alienate and divide everyday workers across national lines rather than allowing them to realize their shared status as a global proletariat.
- Although historical practice muted communism as a viable governing system, it did not diminish the theoretical vitality of Marx's scholarship as an enduring critique of the unequal global distribution of power.
The Marxist Critique of the Nation-State and Global Institutions
Deconstructing the Central Unit of International Relations:
- Traditional theories accept the nation-state as a natural, unchangeable feature of world politics, avoiding critical examination of the state's inherently coercive and violent functions.
- The state possesses an absolute monopoly on legitimate violence, exercising unilateral power to declare wars, annex territory, and kill foreign populations.
- The state maintains the exclusive legal authority to levy taxes, dictate the rule of law, and compel domestic allegiance through punitive measures that include financial fines, imprisonment, and execution.
- States actively participate in and legitimize globalized capitalist trade systems, driving deepening inequalities where the wealthy enrich themselves while the bulk of humanity is exploited.
- Marxists maintain that genuine human emancipation requires the ultimate dissolution of states from the world map to break the chains of inequality and domination.
Critique of International Organizations and Global Governance:
- The twentieth-century rise of intergovernmental bodies, such as the United Nations, compounded the structural flaws of the global system.
- Marxists view the globalization project initiated in the 1990s as a mechanism that validated and institutionalized the very patterns of inequality exposed by Marx over a century earlier.
- The United Nations and affiliated institutions represent state governments and political elites rather than the human beings who reside within them.
- Broad multilateral initiatives organized through the United Nations—including the formal codification of universal human rights—are viewed by Marxists as mere superficial "band aids" covering an all-encompassing, deeply corrupt global structure.
- Contemporary Marxism lacks a single, uniform vision of what a stateless global order would look like in practice, particularly following the twentieth-century collapse of state-led communist experiments.
Postcolonialism: Origins, Imperial Legacies, and Neocolonial Power Structures
Core Focus and Theoretical Distinctions:
- Unlike Marxism, which centers its critique on class struggle, postcolonialism directs its analytical focus toward systemic inequalities between states and geographic regions.
- Asserts that the consequences of historical colonialism persist across many parts of the world, leaving local populations to manage continuous challenges inherited from former colonial rulers.
- Traces its intellectual and political roots to the Cold War era, when international politics was characterized by anti-colonial movements dedicated to undoing European imperialist structures.
- Reflects the sentiment of twentieth-century independence struggles across the Global South, which Kwame Nkrumah articulated (1963, p. ix) as an active rebellion "against the false belief that providence created some to be menials of others."
Continuity of Colonial Ideology and Neocolonialism:
- Prejudices, cultural biases, and intellectual frameworks that justified imperial conquest did not disappear when former colonies were granted formal political independence.
- European empires spent centuries operating under the racist presumption that they were uniquely qualified to govern the globe.
- Although Western powers abandoned direct territorial occupation, they consistently fail to treat former colonies as equal sovereign partners, disregarding the formal principle of sovereign equality.
- Postcolonialism provides analytical tools to expose "neocolonial" practices—informal economic, cultural, and political mechanisms that continuously recreate global disparities.
Discursive Distortions and Material Extraction:
- Postcolonial scholars demonstrate how Western discourse projects a distorted image of formerly colonized areas, such as framing the African continent as an impoverished territory, a moral burden, and a drain on global aid.
- This framing conceals the reality that Africa is an exceptionally wealthy continent whose immense material resources have been systematically extracted and expropriated by external powers for centuries.
- Despite the absence of formal territorial control by foreign empires, two-thirds of the world's impoverished population live within states that were formerly subjected to colonial rule.