Skepticism Notes

Skepticism

  • The word "Skepticism" originates from a Greek word signifying "to reflect on," "consider," or "examine." It is associated with doubting or suspending judgment.
  • Skepticism is a philosophical approach that questions the validity of knowledge, truth, understanding of the world, and reality.
  • Skeptics argue that our knowledge is always uncertain, and we should be cautious in accepting knowledge claims.

Pyrrhonism

  • Pyrrho of Elis (360-270 BC): Founder of Greek Skepticism.
  • Pyrrho's skepticism was influenced by the Sophists, who believed that all knowledge is subjective and relative, implying there is no absolute or common knowledge.
  • Gorgias of Leontini (c. 483-375 BC): A Sophist who articulated skepticism through three theses:
    • (i) Nothing exists.
    • (ii) If something did exist, we could never know it.
    • (iii) If we could know it, we could never express it.
  • Pyrrho and his followers taught that nothing whatsoever is certain; therefore, the wise person will suspend judgment on all matters.

Types of Skepticism

  • (1) Global Skepticism:
    • Argues that we can know nothing.
  • (2) Local or Mitigated Skepticism:
    • Questions the possibility of knowledge only in particular areas of study.
    • Example: One can be a local skeptic about moral knowledge or scientific knowledge.

Important Features of Skepticism

  • The following are key features of skepticism:
    • (i) Doubt
    • (ii) Uncertainty
    • (iii) Critical Thinking
    • Fallibilism: Our knowledge can be mistaken.