Goldstein- Anthro

Kinship and Family Structures

Introduction to Kinship

  • Kinship is a foundational social structure that provides support and connections between individuals.

  • It encompasses various relationships, from joy and love to significant events like weddings and funerals.

  • Kinship allows individuals to envision their lineage and legacy, connecting with both living relatives and those yet to be born.

  • Human activity significantly influences kinship and family connections, reflecting changes in habitats and relationships across cultures.

Polyandry in Nepal: A Closer Look

  • Definition of Polyandry: A marital system where a woman has multiple husbands, often brothers.

  • Melvyn Goldstein's Research: Studies fraternal polyandry particularly in Tibetan society, noting its historical significance.

    • Kinship can be organized by genealogical descent (blood relations) or through marriage (non-blood relations).

  • Forms of Marriage: While marriage exists in every culture, its practice varies including forms such as monogamy, polygyny, and polyandry.

The Mechanics of Fraternal Polyandry

Social Structure

  • Tibetan Example: Dorje, Pema, and Sonam, brothers in Limi, Nepal, marry one woman, showcasing fraternal polyandry.

  • Cultural Background: Traditionally, this form of marriage represents an ideal familial structure, providing economic and social stability.

    • Brothers share responsibilities, labor, and household duties, thus ensuring unity and resource sharing.

Treatment of Offspring

  • Children regard all brothers as father figures, with no favoritism shown by the wife.

  • The eldest brother is often viewed as the principal father, while younger brothers' roles may vary based on familial dynamics.

Economic Rationale

  • Materialistic Motivations: Prevents land fragmentation and helps maintain family resources, thereby enhancing living standards.

  • Women in such marriages engage with multiple husbands, allowing for shared labor and economic benefits.

    • This structure can lead to a higher economic standard compared to a traditional monogamous setup.

Challenges and Family Dynamics

  • Conflict Potential: Marital tensions can arise due to sexual access divides amongst brothers and differing age dynamics between spouses.

  • Sexual Dynamics: The wife is expected to maintain equal affection for all husbands, but personal preferences can lead to unequal treatment, leading to familial discord.

Cultural and Demographic Factors

Population Control

  • Polyandry serves as a demographic strategy to control population growth amidst resource constraints.

  • Historical patterns of female infanticide and socioeconomic pressures contribute to the prevalence of polyandry in certain regions of Tibet.

Modern-Day Impact

  • With globalization and shifts in economic structures, traditional practices are declining.

  • Contemporary elements like tourism and government employment present new dynamics for the younger generations, questioning old marriage systems.

Conclusion

  • The ethnographic studies of marriage practices such as fraternal polyandry challenge ethnocentric views of marriage around the world.

  • Understanding diverse kinship practices enhances appreciation for the complexities of human relationships shaped by cultural, economic, and social factors.