Consciousness

Consciousness and Cognitive Processes - Study Notes

Introduction

  • Course: Cognitive Psychology PS21820

  • Date: 14th November 2025

  • Instructor: Dr. Ioana Mihai

  • Contact: iom7@aber.ac.uk

  • Location: Room 1.29, P5

Today's Lecture Overview

  • Main topics discussed:

    • Definitions of consciousness

    • Functions and roles of consciousness

    • Assessment methods and issues related to consciousness

    • Impact of brain damage on consciousness

    • Theories regarding consciousness and its relationship to the brain

    • Intersection of consciousness with perception

    • Relationship of consciousness with attention

    • Concept of preconsciousness

Definitions of Consciousness

  • Definition:

    • Consciousness is the sense of being alert and aware of thoughts and surroundings.

    • It encompasses the subjective quality of experience.

  • Key Distinctions:

    • Conscious Content: Relates to the information we are aware of.

    • Conscious Level: Refers to the degree of awareness, which can change.

  • Key Characteristics:

    • Consciousness covers various aspects: information, perception, feelings, thoughts, and self-awareness.

    • It is not monodimensional; it presents both behavioral and neural evidence.

Consciousness - Content Types

  • Access Consciousness:

    • Information that is available for cognitive processes and can be communicated to others.

  • Phenomenal Consciousness:

    • Raw experience that is difficult to assess or articulate.

    • Considered much richer than access consciousness.

    • Differentiates between basic forms of experience and higher-level understanding (Baumeister).

Functions and Roles of Consciousness

  • Integral Functions:

    • Consciousness is transversal to many cognitive processes. For example:

    • Categorization and Detection of Stimuli

    • Information Integration

    • Access to Internal States and Memories

    • Behavior Control

  • Problem of Consciousness:

    • Differentiates between primary and self-consciousness.

    • Qualia: Refers to individual instances of subjective experience, highlighting the difference between personal perception and objective reality.

    • Easy vs. Hard Problem:

    • Easy problem: explain functions, dynamics, and contents of consciousness.

    • Hard problem: explain why certain neural mechanisms correlate with consciousness.

    • Consciousness may constitute more than a sum of experiences, also playing a role in forming a sense of self and engaging in self-processing.

Functions and Role - Further Elaboration

  • Perception and Social Communication:

    • Involves body self-consciousness and interaction. The controversy includes debates about the reality of conscious influence— does it entail subliminal information and impact attention or perception.

    • Controversial Viewpoints:

    • Some assert consciousness cannot impact cognitive processes, leading to questions about overinterpretation of conscious experience.

  • Thoughts and Actions:

    • The relationship between consciousness and free will is debated. Concepts include:

    • Principle of Priority, Consistency, Exclusivity: How prior influences manifest in behavioral choices.

    • Sense of Agency: Awareness regarding control over actions or decisions.

    • Libet Study (1983):

    • Highlights the complex interaction between conscious and unconscious processes in decision making through experimental manipulations.

Assessment of Consciousness

  • Methods of Assessment:

    • Behavioral Methods: Verbal reports, yes/no decisions. Challenges exist since conscious experience is richer than mere reports.

    • Different methods yield varying results highlighting issues like under-reporting of conscious experience.

    • Change Blindness: People often overestimate their ability to detect change in their surroundings.

    • Top-down Processes: Influence how gaps in perception are filled cognitively.

Consciousness and Brain Damage

  • Stages of Degraded Consciousness:

    • Understanding of consciousness affected by damage can occur in three stages

    1. Coma

    2. Vegetative State

    3. Minimally Conscious State

  • Connection from Brainstem to Cortical Areas:

    • Both behavioral and neuroimaging measures aid in assessing consciousness post-damage.

Theories of Consciousness

  • Global Workspace Theory:

    • Proposed by Baars (1988) and expanded by Dehaene & Changeux (2011).

    • Theatre Metaphor: Various unconscious processes work in the background but synchronize with central events to make information available to the global workspace.

    • Involvement of the cortex and thalamus in conscious experience is emphasized.

  • Integrated Information Theory (Tononi, 2016):

    • Argues that conscious experience correlates with the integrated activation within large brain networks.

    • Key properties include:

    • Accessible only to oneself

    • Specificity

    • Complexity

    • Unity

Consciousness and Perception

  • Challenges in identifying overlap between brain regions associated with conscious experience and other cognitive processes.

  • Psychophysics: Study of physical stimuli and interactions with sensory systems.

  • Research Examples: Kim & Blake (2005) and Breitmeyer (2015) provide evidence of different methodologies assessing levels of unconscious processing.

Key Concepts of Perception
  • Blindsight: Ability to respond to stimuli without conscious awareness of it.

  • Subliminal Perception: Stimulus presented under the perceptive threshold, can influence behavior or sleep patterns.

  • Backward Masking: Disrupts the processing of stimuli through interruption of visual processing streams.

  • Bistable Perception: Ability to alternate between two different percepts.

  • Binocular Rivalry: Competition between two eyes presenting different images.

Consciousness and Attention

  • Attention and consciousness have overlapping sets but can be experimentally disentangled.

  • Attentional Paradigms:

    • Variations of focus greatly influence perceptual and cognitive responses.

    • Key distinctions made between attended and unattended stimuli in experiments (Reference: Koch & Tsuchiya, 2007).

Observations on Attention
  • Change Blindness and Inattentional Blindness: Highlight issues and limitations in visual awareness and attentional capacity.

  • Natural Scene Perception: Gist perception with rapid scene rendering to evaluate attentional capacities using RSVP paradigms.

Preconsciousness

  • The state where information is available for processing but remains outside conscious awareness.

  • Priming: Activation of memory traces that influence future behavior or thought.

  • Tip of the Tongue Phenomenon: Experience of inability to retrieve a memory despite feeling of knowing.

  • Automatic Actions: Actions performed without conscious awareness due to storage mechanisms of memories.

Conclusions on Consciousness

  • Although difficult to define, consciousness underpins numerous cognitive functions.

  • Functions include:

    • Social communication

    • Sense of agency

    • Action control

    • Planning and thoughts

  • Consciousness is complex, can be altered, and its assessment relies heavily on language capabilities.

  • Current theories emphasize the global workspace and integrated information theories but highlight the intricacy of consciousness regarding overlap with attention and perception.