First-time Mothers’ Understanding and Use of a Pregnancy and Parenting Mobile App (The Baby Buddy App): Qualitative Study Using Appreciative Inquiry
Digital Health Interventions and Pregnancy Applications Landscape
Global Smartphone Proliferation:
In 2021, the estimated global number of smartphone users reached (), representing a increase from 2016.
Projections indicated that by 2023, more than half of the world's population would own a smartphone.
OFCOM (2016) defined mobile applications as tools presenting information in a "streamlined way that allowed them to access details they needed quickly."
Current Landscape of Pregnancy Applications:
In 2020, an evaluation identified pregnancy applications in the Apple App Store and in the Google Play Store.
Evaluations of design, content, and application demonstrate wide variations in quality and usability across pregnancy applications, alongside inconsistent approaches and outcome measures for evaluating impact.
Functionality in most available pregnancy apps is shallow, with a heavy reliance on static information framed primarily toward a medicalized view of pregnancy care.
Five distinct content categories in pregnancy applications identified by Peyton and Wisniewski (2020):
Reference encyclopedias
Timeline-based guides or daily information feeds
Tracker logs or countdown features
Heads-up dashboards
Text or photograph journal features
Identified gap: Self-care, psychosocial peer support, and partner/spouse support are largely absent from conventional pregnancy apps, leaving the social and emotional context of pregnancy under-addressed.
Maternal Information-Seeking Behaviors:
Pregnant women adopt a "mix and match" strategy across digital tools, friends, family, and health care professionals (HCPs).
Information-seeking involves a fine balance between gaining situational awareness and active searching, which carries a risk of inducing anxiety or confusion if unguided.
Digital resource access is used primarily to understand normality, verify whether physical experiences or symptoms are expected, determine necessary actions, and empower conversations with clinical providers.
Background and Development of the Baby Buddy Application
Application Origins and Purpose:
Launched in November 2014 by Best Beginnings, a UK national child health and well-being charity.
Formally categorized as an "electronically delivered health intervention" designed to guide and support women throughout pregnancy (antenatal period) and the first of the child's life (postnatal period).
Fully embedded across National Health Service (NHS) maternity services in the United Kingdom.
Design Principles and Accessibility:
Developed using a universal proportionalism approach to support young families across all sociodemographic backgrounds and maternal age groups.
Co-designed with expectant mothers and developed in close collaboration with healthcare professionals to ensure all content is strictly evidence-based.
Content readability is calibrated for a reading age threshold of , accompanied by a built-in "read aloud" feature.
Made freely downloadable on both the Apple App Store and Google Play Store for compatible smartphones.
Core Functionality and Dynamic Content:
Combines the five conventional content types with professional and peer-voiced video content addressing medical, social, and emotional aspects of pregnancy and early parenthood.
High degree of personalization at setup, including entry of partner or supporter names.
Interactive personalized avatars (customizable in skin tone, hair, clothing, and body shape) navigate users through the app content.
Research Methodology and Appreciative Inquiry Framework
Appreciative Inquiry (AI) Approach:
Research methodology grounded in action research and organizational change theories (Cooperrider & Whitney, 1999).
Focuses systematically on positive discovery—identifying what operates effectively before exploring areas for potential improvement and refinement.
Study Governance and Ethics:
Qualitative arm of the Bumps and BaBies Longitudinal Study (BaBBLeS), an independent, longitudinal, mixed-methods evaluation funded by the Big Lottery, UK.
Ethics approval granted by West Midlands - South Birmingham research ethics committee (Reference: 16/WM/002) via the Integrated Research Application System.
Additional ethics approval granted by the Faculty of Health and Life Sciences Research Ethics Committee at Coventry University (Reference: P45795).
International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-10.1017/S1463423618000294.
Publication reference: JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2022;10(11):e32757; DOI: 10.2196/32757.
Data Collection and Processing:
Method: Semistructured individual telephone interviews and an interactive focus group conducted during the postnatal period ( to postbirth, representing to ).
Focus group design: duration, held in a baby-friendly environment featuring a sensory playroom. Used AI tools including comment cards, sticky notes, colored pens, laminated app screenshots, and test devices running the app.
Qualitative data recorded, anonymized using unique identification numbers, and transcribed verbatim.
Data analyzed via inductive thematic analysis following Braun and Clarke's (2006) framework, with independent transcript review and code cross-checking by two researchers.
Participant Sample and Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:
Maternal age
Nulliparous (no previous live child)
Gestational age between and
Exclusion Criteria:
Maternal age
Already having
Gestational age before or after
Sample Distribution Across NHS Study Sites:
Participant recruitment drawn from 3 NHS maternity unit sites in England (Northwest, Midlands, and Southeast).
Overall recruitment cohort: first-time mothers agreed to contact across sites. Total qualitative sample size: ( participation rate).
Northwest Site:
Agreed to contact: ( of total cohort)
Focus group attendees: ( of total cohort)
Telephone interviewees: ( of total cohort)
Refusals / Non-contactable: (
Total site participation: (
Midlands Site:
Agreed to contact: ( of total cohort)
Focus group attendees: ( of total cohort)
Telephone interviewees: ( of total cohort)
Refusals / Non-contactable: (
Total site participation: (
Southeast Site:
Agreed to contact: ( of total cohort)
Focus group attendees: (
Telephone interviewees: ( of total cohort)
Refusals / Non-contactable: (
Total site participation: (
Overall Summary:
Total focus group participants: ( of total cohort; of qualitative sample)
Total telephone interview participants: ( of total cohort; of qualitative sample)
Total non-participants / refusals: ( of total cohort)
Qualitative Findings: Benefits and Positive Interventions
Theme 1: New Information Acquisition:
Concise, digestible information provided at appropriate developmental milestones.
Clarified medical terminology used during clinical appointments with midwives and GPs:
"So sometimes my midwife would say certain things, and I would like, if it was something medical, go and look at what was going on, and what words meant, and also like for areas, like GPs and different…I’d go and look for information there…" [P33]
Postnatal notification continuity extending up to one month postbirth maintained user engagement.
Practical breastfeeding advice provided functional solutions, such as learning that milk supply can be restarted or leaning back during feeding to slow milk flow for babies taking milk too quickly:
"Gosh there’s loads, I think I learned that you can restart your milk supply, and different ways of feeding her so, I struggled a little bit at first because she was taking too much too quickly, but I read that if I leant back a little bit it would slow the flow down." [P102]
"From the community, the community one helped quite a lot, when the baby was first born I was told to look at it for like breast feeding bits and stuff, by my midwife and the breast feeding team…that was useful." [P103]
Information on fetal size and growth milestones (e.g., eye and mouth movements at gestation) created excitement and control in first-time mothers:
"I like the information about what size it was and what to think about in terms of my health, and how the baby was growing and getting ready." [P6]
"How much is your baby, for example at 36, you see a picture and your baby, what is doing your baby, with the eyes, the mouth. For vomiting, it tells you when your vomiting will stop, or what you feel when your baby is coming in the last few months." [P104]
"Probably more about the fetus’s growth, yes what it was actually doing at certain points, as opposed to the birth…Which is really exciting to know especially in a first pregnancy isn’t it." [P105]
Theme 2: Reliability and Professional Trust:
Midwife endorsement and clinical vetting produced high trust compared to general search engines (e.g., Google) or non-certified applications:
"And I think that the Baby Buddy one because you know that it’s been tried and tested by midwives it’s not just generic information, every day you’re getting something to think about." [P58]
"Yes, because you feel confident knowing that it's tried and tested by midwives, in the videos you have the Midwives perspective, I liked that." [P66]
Reassurance provided by weekly measurement updates and video clips featuring real mothers helped normalize symptoms and reduce panic:
"…And at the end of the week it would say the measurements of the child and what kinds of things you should be going through, so it really helped you in the pregnancy just to know what was happening, instead of like panicking about things, so like that’s normal…" [P4]
"Thinking about it I did watch some of the films with the mums talking, about their experiences…it’s nice to see, with other mums." [P14]
Practical administrative and functional tools: Built-in appointment logging for clinical visits and pelvic floor exercise reminders:
"You could use it to remind yourself to do things, like your pelvic floor exercises." [P29]
"Yes, and if you have appointment for my baby or my appointment, so I go to the application and I know." [P30]
Theme 3: Accessibility and User Experience:
Daily notifications and pop-ups delivered concise, non-intrusive updates without overwhelming users:
"…The updates would come, and they didn’t like override, some apps pregnancy things coming all the time, this one just gave you one simple answer a day, so nice and easy and not too much…" [P26]
Functioned as a foundational platform for early topic exploration (e.g., pain relief options prior to gestation), allowing mothers to formulate questions before attending live antenatal classes:
"…Because you’re getting information every day, it will provide you with links, the app was the foundational platform for looking up more stuff…so that when I did go to my antenatal classes where they teach you about that stuff I kind of had an idea and then you knew you could ask more questions." [P36]
Visual demonstrations via video clips (such as breastfeeding latch techniques) proved superior to verbal explanations alone:
"[Talking about breastfeeding and latching] Yes, people can tell you how to do it, but actually seeing on the video it being done was much clearer." [P65]
Provided guidance during unexpected medical complications, such as a premature delivery at gestation ( early) due to pre-eclampsia:
"…The videos I watched were mostly to do with pregnancy, it was actually like really helpful, cos I ended up really ill with the pregnancy…he was 5 weeks early, I had pre-eclampsia…yes, so that app did help me, it guided me a little bit." [P3]
"Yes I mean, some of the things that obviously I’m a first time mum, so, no matter how confident you feel going into it, once you’ve given birth its looking for answers to questions that you don’t realize you’re going to have beforehand if you know what I mean?" [P2]
Personalization features: Integrating partner/husband names encouraged co-parent involvement and app recommendations to wider family networks:
"I like the fact that the app allows you to put your husband’s name in, so it says you can talk to [person's name is removed] about this, and he could have downloaded the app, I thought it was really nice." [P59]
"…And it refers about your husband or partner by name if you put that information in, I really like that. I would definitely recommend it to other people, my sister’s just got pregnant and I recommended it to her." [P60]
Theme 4: Increased Confidence and Agency:
Combining app information with parent-craft classes empowered mothers to download NHS birth plan templates, fill them out in pencil, and refine them with midwives:
"I think I used it to make choices, I used it together with parent-craft classes…one of the things I did was I downloaded the NHS birth-plan template and wrote mine out in pencil so that when went to the actual classes, I could ask questions, I could change my plan, it gave you confidence that you weren’t going off to something with nothing." [P37]
Foundational knowledge increased confidence in decision-making and facilitated active discussions with partners and relatives:
"I just thought it was a good platform, because as a new mum you know you’re pregnant but you don’t know what to expect, so it’s always nice to have this foundational knowledge to make you feel confident about decisions that you are making. It wasn’t complicated to use." [P64]
Qualitative Findings: Challenges, Limitations, and Identified Improvements
Theme 1: Support-Seeking Behavior and Preference for Human Interaction:
Strong preference retained for face-to-face consultation with healthcare professionals (doctors, midwives, health visitors) for specific health concerns or reassurance, rather than relying solely on app guidance:
"But if we think we’re doing something wrong then I tend to ring the doctors, or the health visitor…because we’re first-time parents and we don’t want to do anything wrong, and we don’t want to go by the book, like, in case it’s not the right decision, I think it depends on your baby’s development as well I think." [P80]
App interaction declined significantly during late pregnancy once mothers commenced live antenatal classes (e.g., NCT classes), which fulfilled social interaction and peer connection needs that digital applications cannot replicate:
"…Towards the end when I started NCT classes I used it less, but it was definitely very helpful in the first 6 or 7 months I’d say." [P6]
Theme 2: Specific Functional and Content Improvements:
Need for greater depth in week-by-week fetal growth tracking:
"The only things that I would have liked more of was like the week by week update, as they’re growing, the fetus, a bit more detail in it." [P92]
Extension of postnatal tracking beyond the default to cover the complete first year ( / ) postbirth:
"The thing I was sad about with the Baby Buddy app was that it finished…it would be nice if it followed you for one year after you’ve had your baby, because it’s a really useful simple app." [P66]
Feature requests: Integrated contraction counters, labor decision-making aids, and directly accessible birth plan templates.
Language accessibility barrier: App availability was restricted to English, forcing non-native English speakers (e.g., Greek and Polish native speakers) to copy-paste text into external translation tools or seek translation help from bilingual acquaintances:
"If you could put in this application the Greek language, or different languages, you know, because sometimes I can’t read it, I can’t understand it, sometimes I need to copy paste and translate. So put in more languages. I have friends from Poland, and they use this application and they tell me to translate for them, and I may be working or something like that." [P96]
Baseline beliefs and knowledge: Maternal feeding decisions (e.g., breastfeeding intention) were frequently pre-determined; the app served to reinforce existing mindsets rather than alter primary behaviors:
"I always knew that breastfeeding was what I wanted to do, but it set my mind in that mindset, this is what I’m going to do, I was determined to do it." [P97]
Note: In over two-thirds of qualitative interviews, participants stated that no specific improvements were necessary.
Analytical Discussion: Health Literacy, Candidacy, and Clinical Practice
Candidacy and Empowerment in Maternity Care:
Candidacy describes the dynamic process through which individuals identify their eligibility for health services, articulate needs, and negotiate care with healthcare providers (Dixon-Woods et al., 2006; Mackintosh et al., 2021).
Access to trusted digital information enhances health literacy and overcomes clinical time constraints (where physical leaflet discussion is hindered by limited consultation time).
Foundational knowledge builds self-advocacy, enabling mothers to navigate birth choices with partners, families, and clinicians (Nieuwenhuijze & Leahy-Warren, 2019).
Self-Efficacy and Social Dynamics:
According to Bandura's (1977) Self-Efficacy Theory, self-efficacy is driven by mastery experiences and vicarious learning (both supplied by app videos and structured guidance).
Quantitative baseline findings from the main BaBBLeS cohort study indicated high baseline self-efficacy among enrolled participants (measured via the Tool to Measure Parenting Self-Efficacy) (Deave et al., 2019; Ginja et al., 2018).
Partner and social network inclusion directly impacts maternal decision-making and feeding choices (Ogbo et al., 2020).
Digital Health Integration and Post-Pandemic Continuity:
Mothers adopt a "pick and choose" technology usage style across multiple digital applications and websites (Guendelman et al., 2017).
Evaluating virtual antenatal care during the COVID-19 pandemic showed satisfaction with virtual clinics, yet of service users maintained a preference for face-to-face contact (Quinn et al., 2021).
Midwifery Continuity of Carer models (National Maternity Review, 2016) leverage mHealth tools to handle routine information delivery, thereby freeing up clinical face-to-face time for personal relationship building.
Selective Information Avoidance and Mental Well-being:
Selective avoidance occurs when pregnant users intentionally bypass topics perceived as anxiety-inducing (e.g., labor complications or birth trauma).
High anxiety scores on the State Trait Anxiety Index correlate with lower pregnancy app engagement (Daly et al., 2018).
Qualitative evidence highlights the "happiness imperative"—a societal pressure on pregnant women to present a calm, positive demeanor and distance themselves from expressions of distress or depression (Staneva & Wigginton, 2017).
Future app design must integrate moderated peer forums, multi-language support, and sensitive mental health frameworks without triggering distress or digital exclusion.
Authorship, Institutional Affiliations, and Metadata
Authors:
Elizabeth Bailey ( PhD)
Samantha Nightingale ( MRes)
Nicky Thomas ( MSc)
Dawn Coleby ( PhD)
Toity Deave ( PhD)
Trudy Goodenough ( PhD)
Samuel Ginja ( PhD)
Raghu Lingam ( PhD)
Sally Kendall ( PhD)
Crispin Day ( PhD)
Jane Coad ( PhD)
Institutional Affiliations:
Coventry University, Coventry, United Kingdom
Elizabeth Bryan Multiple Births Centre, Centre for Social Care, Health and Related Research, Birmingham City University, Birmingham, United Kingdom
University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust, Coventry, United Kingdom
George Eliot NHS Trust, Nuneaton, United Kingdom
Division of Health Sciences, Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, De Montfort University, Leicester, United Kingdom
School of Health and Social Wellbeing, University of the West of England, Bristol, United Kingdom
School of Psychology, Ulster University, Ulster, United Kingdom
University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia
Centre for Health Services Studies, University of Kent, Canterbury, United Kingdom
Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience, Kings College London, London, United Kingdom
School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine & Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom
Editorial and Publication Details:
Edited by: L Buis
Peer-reviewed by: M Barry, S Wallwiener
Submitted: November 2, 2021 ()
Comments to Author: December 28, 2021 ()
Revised Version Received: March 17, 2022 ()
Accepted: July 26, 2022 ()
Published: November 21, 2022 ()
Journal Citation: JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2022;10(11):e32757
DOI: 10.2196/32757
URL: https://mhealth.jmir.org/2022/11/e32757