Persuasion (lec8)

  • Definition of persuasion:

    • According to the Oxford English Dictionary: ‘To induce (a person) to believe something; to lead to accept a statement, doctrine, fact, etc.; to win to a belief or assurance.’

    • Secondary definition from Smith & Mackie (1999): ‘The process of forming, reinforcing, or changing attitudes by communication.’

  • Key components of persuasive messages:

    • The communicator, or the source (‘who’).

    • This includes the credibility, attractiveness, and knowledge of the speaker or writer.

    • The communication, or the message (‘what’).

    • This can vary in structure and emotional appeal, including logical arguments, emotional triggers, and storytelling elements.

    • The audience (‘to whom’).

    • Understanding the audience's beliefs, values, and demographics is crucial for effective persuasion.

  • Persuasion process steps:

    1. Attention

    2. Comprehension

    3. Acceptance

    4. Retention

    • Must engage the audience and encourage them to remember the message.

  • Learning outcomes for this unit:

    • Explaining attitude change and cognitive dissonance.

    • Explaining the Heuristic-Systematic Model (HSM) and the Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM).

    • Critically evaluating the ELM with reference to evidence regarding its ability to change attitudes, including both supporting and opposing research findings.

Cognitive Dissonance Theory

  • Developed by Festinger (1957), exploring the consequences of individuals acting in accordance with social roles rather than their own attitudes.

    • Focuses on the unpleasant feelings (arousal) associated with having non-consonant cognitions, or a mismatch between cognitions and behavior.

  • Example: A person who smokes while simultaneously knowing that smoking is bad for their health.

    • The internal conflict created drives change in either behavior or belief to reduce discomfort.

  • Cognitive dissonance creates a conflict between belief systems and behavior.

  • Dissonance is typically reduced by:

    • Placing oneself out of risk (avoiding situations that trigger discomfort).

    • Ignoring the message or the conflicting evidence (cognitive avoidance).

Research into Insufficient Justification
  • Festinger & Carlsmith (1959): Induced Compliance Procedure

    • Participants performed a dull task (turning blocks) and were paid to tell the next participant it was interesting.

    • Condition 1: Paid 2020, a sufficient reward.

    • Condition 2: Paid 11, an insufficient reward that led to greater cognitive dissonance.

    • Condition 3 (Control): No incentive or instructions given.

  • Main Findings: Using a smaller reward (11) resulted in a larger attitude change.

    • Participants had to re-evaluate their attitudes toward the task because the small reward was insufficient justification for lying, leading to internal conflict.

  • Zimbardo et al. (1965): Grasshopper Study

    • Participants were asked by an authority figure (either a positive/friendly officer or a negative/hostile officer) to eat grasshoppers.

  • Results: In both negative and positive conditions, those who ate the grasshoppers became more favorable toward the idea, while non-eaters became less favorable.

    • This demonstrated that a degree of self-justification was required to account for the behavior.

    • Crucial Finding: The biggest attitude change occurred in the negative officer condition, as there was no positive social incentive to eat the insect, forcing participants to justify the act by changing their attitude.

Necessary Steps for Dissonance-Induced Attitude Change
  • For cognitive dissonance to result in attitude change, three conditions must be met:

    1. The person must perceive negative consequences of the behavior without sufficient external justification (e.g., small cash rewards) as seen in Festinger & Carlsmith (1959).

    2. Personal responsibility must be taken for the behavior (Linder et al., 1967), which requires freedom of choice.

    • The individual must recognize their role in the situation to feel the dissonance.

    1. The person needs to feel unpleasant arousal and attribute that arousal to the attitude-discrepant behavior (Zanna & Cooper, 1974); they must have some investment in the action.

  • Zanna & Cooper (1974) Study findings:

    • Arousal condition: Resulted in little attitude change because participants attributed their feelings to an external source (e.g., situational factors).

    • Relaxing condition: Participants should feel relaxed but don't as a result of the dissonance; this led to higher attitude change as they resolved the internal tension.

Dual Process Models of Persuasion

  • There are two primary models that assume two distinct ways attitudes can be changed:

    • Central / Systematic Route: Used when an individual is willing and able to process information.

    • Characterized by high involvement and careful evaluation of arguments.

    • Peripheral / Heuristic Route: Used when an individual is unwilling or unable to process information.

    • Characterized by low involvement and reliance on cues such as attractiveness of the communicator or emotional appeals.

The Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM)
  • Proposed by Petty & Cacioppo (1986).

  • Elaboration Definition: Issue-relevant thinking, measured via a "thought listing task" assessing:

    • How many total thoughts were generated?

    • How many were issue-relevant?

    • How many were positive?

  • The Two Routes:

    • Central Route: High elaboration involving systematic processing.

    • Leads to stronger attitudes that are enduring, resistant to change, and predictive of behavior.

    • Peripheral Route: Low elaboration involving heuristic processing.

    • Influenced by cues such as speed of speech, mood, humor, and self-relevance.

    • Leads to weak attitudes that are temporary, susceptible to counter-persuasion, and not predictive of behavior.

The Seven Postulates of ELM (Petty & Cacioppo, 1986)
Postulate 1: Underlying Motivation
  • People have an underlying motivation to hold correct attitudes, though correctness is not necessarily absolute.

    • Functions of attitudes include:

    • Knowledge function (Katz, 1960).

    • Utilitarian function (Smith et al., 1956).

    • Value expressive function (Smith et al., 1956).

    • Allowing individuals to express their values and beliefs through attitudes.

    • Ego defensive function (Katz, 1960).

    • Protecting self-esteem and personal beliefs from threatening information.

Postulate 2: Variations in Elaboration
  • The amount and nature of elaboration vary based on individuals and situations.

  • Factors influencing the nature and extent of elaboration:

    • Motivational Factors:

    • Forewarning (Petty & Cacioppo, 1977).

    • Need for cognition (Chaiken, 1987).

    • Task importance (Maheswaran & Chaiken, 1991).

    • Issue involvement (Petty et al., 1981).

    • Ability (Capacity) Factors:

    • Distraction (Petty et al., 1976).

    • Knowledge / Expertise (Wood, 1982).

    • Repetition (Cacioppo & Petty, 1979).

    • Time pressure (Moore et al., 1986).

    • Higher cognitive load decreases processing ability.

Postulate 3: Three Methods of Influence
  • Variables affect attitude change in three ways:

    1. Serving as arguments: Strong arguments produce more change.

    2. Serving as peripheral cues: A positive or negative cue can produce change regardless of argument strength.

    3. Affecting the extent or direction of elaboration: More elaboration shifts processing toward the central route and away from peripheral cues.

  • Findings: Strong messages produce more change than mixed or weak messages. Positive cues increase change; negative cues reduce it.

Postulate 4: Objective Elaboration
  • Variables affecting motivation or ability can process messages objectively by enhancing or reducing argument scrutiny.

  • Findings:

    • High distraction reduces the difference between strong and weak messages (reduces scrutiny).

    • Low distraction allows for big differences between strong and weak messages.

    • More repetitions and higher issue involvement increase the gap between strong and weak message effectiveness.

    • High Need for Cognition (NFC) individuals show the biggest difference between strong and weak arguments.

    • As the number of evaluators increases, the difference between strong and weak messages decreases.

Postulate 5: Elaboration Versus Cues
  • As motivation and ability to process arguments decrease, peripheral cues become more important determinants of persuasion.

  • Conversely, as argument scrutiny increases, peripheral cues become less important.

  • Both processes can operate simultaneously, but their relative importance is inversely related.

  • Findings: High expertise sources produce more change, but strong arguments still maintain an advantage over weak ones.

Postulate 6: Biased Elaboration
  • Variables can affect message processing in a biased manner, creating a positive (favorable) or negative (unfavorable) bias in issue-relevant thoughts.

  • People may focus on aspects supporting existing views and ignore or refute opposing aspects.

  • Findings: Positive bias increases attitude change; negative bias lowers it.

Postulate 7: Consequences of Elaboration
  • Attitudes formed via the central route (compared to the peripheral route) are:

    • More persistent over time (stay stable).

    • More resistant to change.

    • More predictive of behavior.

Heuristics and the Heuristic-Systematic Model (HSM)

Types of Peripheral Cues
  • Internal Cues:

    • Mood as information (Schwarz & Clore, 1983).

    • Facial feedback and bodily states (Strack et al., 1988).

    • Ease of processing (Wanke et al., 1997).

  • External Cues:

    • Source characteristics: Expertise/credibility (Hovland & Weiss, 1951).

    • Sources perceived as credible tend to result in higher persuasion rates.

    • Likeability (Benson et al., 1976).

    • Communicators who elicit positive feelings are often more persuasive.

    • Physical attractiveness (Chaiken, 1979).

    • Attractiveness can lead to greater persuasive impact through the halo effect.

    • Similarity to self (attitudes, appearance, social categories).

    • Like-mindedness can enhance the effectiveness of persuasive efforts.

HSM Specifics and Research
  • Chaiken (1987) identifies three characteristics of effective heuristics:

    1. Applicable

    2. Accessible

    3. Reliable

  • Findings from Chaiken (1987): A reliable cue results in a bigger difference between likeable and dislikeable communicators. An unreliable cue can reverse these effects.

  • Hovland & Weiss (1951): Message on nuclear submarine safety attributed to either Robert Oppenheimer (scientist) or Pravda (Soviet news agency).

    • Main Findings: The amount of attitude change is ultimately determined by the strength of the message rather than the source. The content of the message is retained, but the source of the message is often forgotten over time (Sleeper Effect).

Critical Evaluation and Reliability

  • The Strack et al. (1988) study on facial feedback and bodily states faces a modern replication crisis.

    • This highlights the importance of ongoing research and verification in psychological studies.

  • Key issues for critical evaluation:

    • Difficulty in replicating findings.

    • Several classic studies have faced challenges when attempts to validate them were made.

    • Generalizability of the results across different contexts and populations.

    • Cultural factors may influence the effectiveness of persuasion techniques, which should be accounted for in research.