POSC 010 lecture 1

What is politics?

  • Seeking agreement on common action despite disagreements (Samuel Kernell)

  • Who gets what, when, and how?” (Harold Lasswell)

    • Who gets welfare, jail, penalties tax companies get, healthcare

    • When - what circumstances

    • How- how are you receiving this? (ex. check)

- Happens wherever people with different preferences must decide together

- Families, friend groups, workplaces, UCR.. scale up 330M


What is poli sci?

  • The systematic study of politics and government

  • Looks for general patterns, not one-off stories

  • Journalism: personalities; Civics (contrast): procedure; History: context (who and abt)

  • Lots of Why is this and why is that

  • Polisci: patterns

  • EX: Civil Rights Act, ACA, New Deal all passed under unified gov

    • Unified gov- all branches are ruled by same party and only congress/legislative (if u got readings u better know)

    • Look to see the civics, history, journalism, AND poli sci perspectives


What poli sci is not?

  • Punditry: CNN, Fox, etc. discussions and views

  • Horserace:  commentator always says who is ahead (polling)

  • Talking heads: 

  • All informed by poli sci but NOT


ASSUMPTION #1: people are rational

  • rationality: people have goals and they take actions to achieve them

    • Ex: Legislators want to benefit constituents, stay in power,

  • Not genius or omniscient, purposeful, on the info they have

  • Anticipate how others will react

  • E.g., a senator votes w her party on a bill she dislikes, why?

    • May be beneficial when comes re-election and is a pro in the future but not a policy they like.. This is them using rationality


ASSUMPTION #2: Institutions shape choices

  • Institutions: rule that affects choices avail. To people, consequences people made, or information

    • Political party counts as an institution and can dictate opinions; prison and laws are institutions that dictate what decisions you make daily like killing or shooting someone; there are papers to simplify bills enacted for the people (info), polling (info)

- formal or informal -norms & social contracts between ppl

- Same people, different rules -> different outcomes

- here, the institution clearly changes the outcome

- E.g., 51 votes vs. 60 votes in the Senate

- Our approach: rational individuals x institutions


Preferences are the problem

  • Preferences = what ppl want

  • If everyone wanted the same thing, no politics

  • Different preferences -> bargaining, compromise strategy

  • Pursuing individual preferences ≠ good collective outcome


Collection action problems

  • Coordination: 535 members

  • Free riding: benefit without contributing

  • E.g., budget deficits, everyone wants restraint, nobody wants to cut their district

    • This tanks ability to pass law


What solves these collective action problems? Institutions to the rescue

  • Institutions help make and enforce collective decisions

  • House, Senate, presidency, courts each manage conflict differently


Big Beautiful Bill

  • Preferences may have diverged, but part unity won (parties are institutions)

  • Votes held open facilitated coordination (rules are an institution)

  • Primary threats undercut free riding (elections are an institution)

  • Budget reconciliation let 50 senators bypass the filibuster (rules are an institution)

  • Recommended CSPAN


Questions asked this quarter

  • What motivates members of Congress?

  • How does the Electoral College shape campaigns?

  • Can the Supreme Court create social change?

  • Why do we have political parties?

  • Is the “deep state” real? - paajroitve thats been thrown to beaucracy thats been thrown by dem party (iron triangle)

  • Why vote?

  • Is polling broken?