PHILOSOPHY-MIDTERMS
Primer to Philosophy
Etymology: The word comes from the Greek words Philia/o (love) and Sophia (wisdom), which means love of wisdom.
Working Definition of Philosophy:
It is a discipline or study that seeks to understand the most fundamental and general things.
It investigates elements, causes, principles, and norms.
It seeks to make connections and study the relationship between two different subjects.
Symbol: 𝚽 It is the 21st first letter in the Greek alphabet, pronounced Phi. It represents the initial letter of the word “Φιλοσοφία,” which means philosophy.
List of Misconceptions:
Philosophy is;
Western
Anti-science
Anti-religion
For priests
ebas/mema/nonsense
Jurassic
Only for the elites (the worst misconception, apparently)
Branches of Philosophy
Epistemology: the study of knowledge and truth.
Its etymology: Ancient Greek epistēmē (knowledge, skill) and logos (the science/discipline of)
Metaphysics: the study of the nature of abstract and reality.
Its etymology: Ancient Greek meta (after) and physika (physics)
Axiology: The study of value.
Its etymology: Ancient Greek Axio (worth or value) and logos (the science/discipline of)
Philosophical Epochs
Ancient (600 B.C - 1000 A.D)
Defined by questions regarding the origins of things it is divided into three periods:
Pre-Socratic
Triumvirate (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle)
Hellenistic (Roman)
Medieval (1000 A.D 1500 A.D)
Defined by the monopoly of religion in matters of knowledge it is divided into three periods:
Early (Neo-Platonism)
High (Scholastics)
Late (Neo-Aristotelean)
Modern (1500 A.D 1900 A.D)
Defined by liberalization and politicization of knowledge discourse it is divided into three periods.
Early
High (Enlightenment)
Late
Contemporary (1900 A.D - present)
Defined by the expansion of philosophical discourses into other disciplines it is divided between:
Analytics (Anglo-Americans)
Continentals
Lesson I: Knowing Philosophy
𝚽 Concepts (By Armando Bonifacio)
Personal: Biases, assumptions, beliefs, and prepositions
Reflective: Objectification, analysis, and deeper study
Systematic: reconstructive and transformative
Before 𝚽, there was;
Phusis or Physis (φύσις): the study of the general nature of things
Mythos (μύθος): stories about deities
𝚽 was coined by Pythagoras.
Thales of Miletus:
Reason > Phusis and Mythos
Everything is WATER due to its ever-changing and ever-present form is water.
𝚽 is revolutionary
It dares to assume that it is within one’s rational ability to explain reality.
It assumes Cosmos (order) is governed by Logos through reason.
𝚽 is MOTHER and PRIME
It is the origin of all disciplines
It is constant
What makes a question 𝚽 (Isaiah Berlin)
Broad and General
Absence of methodology: no definitive answer.
Trivial: Superficial nonsense
𝚽 is 2nd order inquiry. Science is first
𝚽 → constant criticism (cc) + (cq) constant questioning = refinement of thought
𝚽 → Arguments for God’s Existence
Anselm’s Ontology: The greatest possible thing.
The flaw of the argument is that it can be applied to anything.
Aquinas’ Cosmological Arguments/Five Ways:
Unmoved Mover
First Cause
Contingency
Degrees
Intelligent Design
The flaw of the argument is it suffers from the “Begging the Question Fallacy” or the premise assumes the conclusion.
𝚽 is Meta-Discipline
𝚽 is the guardian of Science: when a question is answered, it becomes a science. When it is left unanswered, philosophy will deal with it.
𝚽 is vision (Friedrich Weismann): It provides new perspectives through pondering and examination.
Lesson II: The Beginning of Doing 𝚽
𝚽 blossomed in Greece because:
Constant exposure to other civilizations
Adept at borrowing ideas
No religious censorship (to a point)
Vibrant imaginations
Relax socio-economic structure
Undebated curiosity
Before Thales, the ancient world was dominated by mythos
Pre-Socratic (7th B.C - 4th B.C)
Individuals that preceded Socrates in thought.
Characteristics:
Rational
Natural
Arche (origin of things)
Proto-Scientist
thought was holistic: it was an attempt to give a systematic account of the whole known universe and all its major features.
Milesians: philosophers from Miletus, a village in Asia Minor.
Characteristics:
Non-mythological
Rational and speculative
Tried to coherently explain reality
HYLOZOISTS - believes the universe is alive and material.
Milesian Philosophers
Thales
Father of western philosophy
EVERYTHING IS WATER
1st flat earther
Shrewd businessman
Brought geometry to ancient Greece
Predicted eclipses
Anaximander
Student of Thales
Arche was Aperion (infinite)
Earth was a cylinder and suspended in space.
Tried to draw a map
Anaximenes
Student of Anaximander
Arche was air
Plato raw ang earth (saucer)
Pythagoreans: followed the school of thought of Pythagoras
Characteristics:
Philosophy is a way of life
Religion and Philosophy are connected
Pythagoras
From the island of Samos
Numbers were the arche
Catharsis: purging of emotions
Contemplative life
Coined Philosophia
Coined Logos for Cosmology
Ionians
Philosophers from Ionia
Characteristic:
Mystical nature of philosophy
Heraclitus
From Ephesus
The weeping philosopher
(misanthrope)
The constancy of flux
Arche is fire
Died covered in cow dung
Eleatics: Philosophes from Elea, now modern Naples, Italy
Characteristics:
Universal unity of beings
Logic over sense
Parmenides
Contradicted Heralictus’s idea of change
Arche is being
Treats “reality ” as an indestructible, immovable, complete, unending, absolute, inclusive, ultimate, and comprehensive whole
Zeno
A loyal follower of Parmenides
Promotes interconnectedness of being
First to use dialectic
Used paradoxical arguments against motion
Pluralists: they believe that the Prime Substance is composed of many substances
Characteristic
A combination of the naturalistic approach of the Milesians and the criticisms of the Eleatics
Anaxagoras
From Clazomanae
Believes that reality is composed of many seeds (panspermia)
The infinite divisibility of matter
The first philosopher to formally move to Athens
Contributed to the idea of Nous
Empedocles
Written poems about his love, Pausanias
Believed he was immortal and had magical powers
Argued that reality is made out of four elements
One of the first pluralist
Atomists believed that the Prime Substance is composed of an individual and indivisible substance.
Characteristic
Removes the distinction which the Eleatic school drew between the Absolute, or the only real existence, and the world of change around us
Democritus
from Thrace
student of Leucippus
known as the laughing philosopher
argued that the “fundamental substance” is Atomos
atoms are physically, but not geometrically, indivisible; that between atoms, there lies empty space; that atoms are indestructible, and have always been and always will be in motion; that there is an infinite number of atoms and of kinds of atoms, which differ in shape and size.
WESTERN PHILOSOPHY IS…
The task of satisfying one’s Curiosity
Heavy use of Logic and Categorization
Focuses on parts rather than the Whole
Goes against Tradition
Primacy of REASON
PHILOSOPHY AS A WAY OF LIFE
No Dichotomy between the Objective World and a
Person as a Human Being
Philosophy and Religion are One
The Primacy of Consciousness (Nirvana)
Lesson III: Approaches in Doing 𝚽
Approach 1
by Charlie Dunbar Broad; The main task of philosophy
Analytic (critical)
Speculative (metaphysical)
ANALYTIC PHILOSOPHY
2 Fundamental Task:
Analysis and definition of our fundamental concepts
Clear and Resolute criticism of our beliefs and assumptions
On definition:
We take for granted that we understand what is being said, without realizing the nuances in the meaning of the use of concepts we employ.
A philosophical question is not resolved, it is dissolved
Resolve it piece by piece through constant clarification
On Belief:
We are often stubborn in our beliefs grounded upon preconceived notions about many things around us
Let’s be clear:
“We should not stick to our previous knowledge, especially if it was with us since our childhood days, if we have not subjected such to constant criticism and review”
If so:
“Let us look at our old beliefs and assumptions, continue to rigorously test it, and if it still passes, then might as well hold on to such belief”
ALWAYS SCRUTINIZE AND BE OPEN TO CONSTRUCTIVE CHANGE!
SPECULATIVE PHILOSOPHY
The fundamental task:
-Find the underlying explanation or general principle that could explain reality entirely
-Aims to reach general conclusions as to the nature of the universe and as to our positions and prospects in it.
-Attempt to think SYNOPTICALLY of all the facts
-Quest to abstract and extract a unifying explanation to give a coherent explanation regarding the nature of reality.
Marked the beginning of western philosophy
Approach 2
by Willie Ostreng; Reductionism versus Holism- Contrasting approaches
REDUCTIONIST (properties of the parts)
HOLIST (The relationship between the parts)
REDUCTIONIST PHILOSOPHY
Fundamental task:
Understanding Complex ideas by reducing them to their particular constituents
NEWTONIAN ASSUMPTION
“A complex system is nothing but a sum of its parts and that everything in it can be reduced to individual properties.”
EX; ATOM->MOLECULE->MACROMOLECULE->ORGANELLE->CELL->TISSUE->ORGAN->ORGAN SYSTEM->ORGANISM
THE OG REDUCTIONIST: Rene Descartes; part 5 (Discourse on the method)
DESCARTIAN ASSUMPTION:
“A machine can only be understood if an individual would take its pieces apart and study the individual components before putting it back together to understand the bigger picture”
EX: LIKE TAKING APART THE PARTS OF A CLOCK (with the gears and stuff)
HOLISTIC PHILOSOPHY
Fundamental task:
Ideas cannot be broken down into its components alone, but rather the entire entity decides how such parts can behave
A thing is more than just a sum of its parts, as reality can only be understood as a whole, for if not, an accurate examination is not possible.
ARISTOTELEAN ASSUMTION:
“The whole is more than the sum of its parts”
Comes from the Greek word “holos” meaning All, Whole, or Total.
Holism, as a term, was only introduced in 1926 by JAN SMUTS.
-Goes in contrast with Atomism
-properties of parts contribute to the understanding of the whole only if one has a grasp of the interactions of each part and its dynamic connectedness
-refutes the necessity of dividing functions of separate parts to the overall mechanism of the whole.
SMUTSIAN ASSUMPTION:
“Fundamental factor operative towards the creation of holes in the universe”
Its key characteristic is the concept of a certain fundamental truth of any particular experience.
F. FREGE L. WITTGENSTEIN W. QUINE
EPISTEMOLOGICAL HOLISIM a.k.a. CONFIRMATION HOLISM
Claims that a scientific theory cannot be tested individually since testing such would always depend on other established theories and hypotheses.
THEORY-LADNES - “Dependent on theory”
INSUFFICIENCY OF EVIDENCES
SEMANTIC HOLISM
Every word has meaning only in relation to other words, phrases, sentences, or languages in which it is used
A doctrine in the philosophy of language wherein a certain part or meaning can only be grasped fully when combined with other parts or meanings.
Lesson IV - Methods of Philosophizing
PLATO- student of socrates | teacher of aristotle | placed philo at its pedestal as a discipline | established the first institution of higher education (ACADEMIA)
WORLD OF FORMS = PERFECTION
(ageless, eternal, absolute, unchanging, infallible)
1. Material things
2. Mathematical ideas
3. Abstracts
-we had immediate contact with the world of forms (PERFECT & DIRECT)
WORLD OF MATTER = IMPERFECT (appearances, changing) | COPY OF IDEAL FORMS
-before we were born, we were once a part of the WORLD OF SOUL (we were PERFECT BEFORE)
-we became imperfect because our bodies corrupted our soul (we lost our innocence, we forget who we really are and this body making us forget knowledge)
-CORRUPTION = removal from the perfect union with THE WORLD OF FORMS
-the body itself is EVIL
-RECOGNIZE & REMEMBER = the perfect knowledge we once had
-SOPHIA = WISDOM - constant attempt / trying to remember the good, can regain the knowledge we once had
THE ALLEGORY OF THE CAVE
-word of appearance (our opinions about reality) to the world of real knowledge (the actual reality)
PISTIS = beliefs / conclusions (practical knowledge),
EIKASIA = illusions / imaginations (second-hand information), NOESIS - reason (grasping complete and perfect knowledge), DIANOIA = mathematical / abstract hypothesis (assumption from the physical world while keeping the process ABSTRACT)
-THE EXAMINED LIFE IS NOT WORTH LIVING!
- FIRST STEP FOR US TO PREPARE OURSELVES IN PERFECT KNOWLEDGE IS ACCEPTANCE OF APORIA = ignorance (tanga)
SOCRATES - Gadfly of Athens | Authored NO Texts | Father of the Socratic Method (argumentative method through questions & answers) | accused of corrupting the Youth and Impiety to the Gods | executed via HEMLOCK POISONING
Polarizing Figure
-no claim of his existence
-claimed by plato as his teacher
DIALECTICS = using someone’s statement against them, deduces contradictions in their arguments
*used by zeno & the eleatics, socrates and plato
SOPHISTRY = Socrates doesn’t support this (ired by Socrates’ dialect strategy)
-first professional teachers who exacted MONEY
-claims to teach individual to be WISE
-masters of the ART OF RHETORIC & PERSUASION (magaling mambola / use flowery words)
-believes MORALITY IS RELATIVE
-views WISDOM as TECHNE / SKILLS which can be taught to anyone
Includes: protogas (man is the measure of all) , gorgias (virtue is not one but many) & thrasymachus (justice is in the interest of the strong)
RENE DESCARTES- Father of Reductionism | Author of Meditations on the First Philosophy | Believed that KNOWLEDGE ABOUT REALITY can regained through REASON
-knowledge can proceed from few premises (substances), SUBSTANCES = clear, distinct, certain, self-evidently true
Transcendental faculty of Reason
1.Self
2.Material objects
3.God
4.Knowledge about reality
-DOUBTING EVERYTHING THAT CAN BE DOUBTED, but the ONLY THING that you can’t doubt is that you are DOUBTING
-COGITO (I think), ERGO (therefore), SUM ( I am) !
-”I” and “self” ARE DIFFERENT
CRITICISM - reason is not enough, missing ingredient = EXPERIENCE
1.Presence of Assumption “I”
2.Assumption of difference between THE KNOWER AND THE KNOWN
*Empiricists: SELF = Perception + Experiences (argue against descartes)
SKEPTICISM - mark of the descartian rationalism | truths about reality must always be backed up with adequate EVIDENCES
*alamin muna bago paniwalaan | let us seek knowledge first (level-headedness), before merely believing in anything (gullibleness)
Lesson V - Nature of Knowledge
STAGES IN THE APPREHENSION OF CONCEPTS
PERCEPTION "Activity that does not make us from animals"
- External - Using our five senses
- Internal - Using our Memory and Imagination
ABSTRACTION “Distinguishes man from animals”
- SIMPLE APPREHENSION
1. Perceiving an object intellectually. The intellectual grasping of an object ()
2. Use of Intellect where we grasp what is universal from the different observed particulars. The result of which are CONCEPTS
CONCEPTS ARE THE BUILDING BLOCKS OF KNOWLEDGE
Vague or Precise
Sufficient or Insufficient
Neither True nor False
Judgment “Cement of the Process of acquiring Knowledge”
Concept A + Concept B = Knowledge Claim
(can now have a value, pwede mo na masabi kung TRUE OR FALSE)
SENTENCES (NO TRUTH VALUE)
Declarative - Expresses Statements
Interrogative - Inquires Questions
Imperative - Issues Commands
Expletive - Issues Requests
Exclamatory - Expresses Feelings
A PRIORI STATEMENTS - can be derived by reason alone
(ex. A bachelor is an unmarried man, Every apple is a fruit)
A POSTERIORI STATEMENTS - requires experience as justification
(ex. The cloud is white, Apples are sweet)
EVALUATIVE/NORMATIVE STATEMENTS
Expressions of:
Moral Judgements of the Individual
Norms and Standards
Prescribes and Proscribes
FORMAL KNOWLEDGE
Main concern is the validation of their claims within respective discipline
Focused on the validity of concepts without depending on empirical data.
EMPIRICAL KNOWLEDGE
Main concern is the validation of their claims within experience and sense-perception
Focuses on Probabilities using Induction, resulting from data gathered by experience.
Lesson VI - Knowledge and Truth
• Theories on Truth — Coherence, Correspondence, and Progmatics
• Conherence Theory — suggests that a statement is true if it fits consistently with a larger body of knowledge and experiences, rather than directly mirroring reality.
WELL - FORMED FORMULAS
Mathematics, Logic, Trigonometry, Geometry, or Linguistics - Tautologies
- CONSISTENCY OF TRUTH
One could show a certain proof by using an accepted or well-formed formula for a
Mathematical problem
- CAN SHOW UNACCEPTABILITY
If inconsistencies within the systems adopted are to be found
- FACULTY OF REASON
Assumed as Universal; responsible for the formal types of Knowledge
• Correspondence Theory — states that a statement is true if it accurately reflects or corresponds to a fact in reality.
- SENSE DATA (Ayer)
data are mental representations of sensory experiences, forming the basis of our knowledge of the world.
- LOGICAL ATOMISTS (Russel)
emphasizes analyzing complex ideas into basic elements and posits a world made up of independent entities forming atomic facts.
- SOMETHING GIVEN OUTSIDE
Within the realm of experience to which we perceive as an Objective reality
- EXPERIENCE
Source of Knowledge; basis for our verification process on the world
“Apart from statements that are empirically verifiable, all others are meaningless utterances.” — Thought from Alfred Jules Ayer – Language, Truth, and Logic (1936)
“Grant an idea to be true, what concrete difference will its being true make in anyone’s actual life? - What in short, is the Truth’s cash value in experiential terms.” — Thought from William James – Pragmatism (1907)
• Pragmatic Theory — assesses truth based on practical consequences in the real world, valuing flexibility and usefulness in achieving positive outcomes.
- PRAGMATIC NATURE OF THE WORLD
nature of the world values truth based on practical consequences, emphasizing adaptability and the dynamic, ever-changing nature of reality.
- TRUTH AS NOT A STAGNANT PROPERTY
challenges the notion of fixed truth, emphasizing its dynamic nature that evolves with our experiences and understanding.
“We have to live today by what truth we can get today, and be ready tomorrow to call it falsehood.” — William James
- INDIVIDUALS AS CHOICE-MAKERS
before making a decision, we carefully weigh the potential consequences of each alternative, ensuring we understand the potential outcomes of our choices.
- OPEN TO COUNTLESS INTERPRETATIONS
who should decide and benefit from the practical consequences of our decisions?
• SOURCES OF KNOWLEDGE — Reason, Experience, and Intuition.
• FACULTY OF REASON — analytic faculty — analyzes truth within specific systems, using a coherence framework. It operates in formal sciences, extends beyond the physical realm, and differs from Cartesian reason. Reason has limitations and is not the only source of knowledge.
- FOLLOWS THE COHERENCE FRAMEWORK
emphasizes the logical consistency and interconnectedness of ideas within a system of knowledge.
- DIFFERS FROM DESCARTIAN TRANSCENDENTAL NATURE OF REASON
goes beyond the assumption of a world — contrasts with Cartesian reasoning by emphasizing logical analysis within specific knowledge domains rather than innate ideas and deduction.
• FACULTY OF EXPERIENCE — the usage of the Five Senses and Sensory extending devices.
- FOLLOWS THE CORRESPONDENCE FRAMEWORK
validates claims with empirical evidence from the sciences, emphasizing the real-world connection.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LIMITATIONS
involves recognizing constraints, biases, uncertainties, and incomplete knowledge within a framework.
• FACULTY OF INTUITION — The immediate or direct recognition of self-evident truths.
Proposed by George Edward Moore in Ethics (1903).
- TACIT KNOWLEDGE
implicit, experiential know-how acquired through practice and experience.
- NO ESTABLISHED METHOD OF VERIFICATION
“You know when you know”
• EPISTEMIC OBLIGATION
- SUBJECTING KNOWLEDGE TO SCRUTINY
critical assessment and scientific methodology to establish or debunk theories.
- RECOGNITION OF OUR FALLIBILITY
acknowledging our limitations, embracing humility, and staying open to questioning and self-reflection..
• AVOID DOGMATISM — by staying open-minded, flexible, and critically evaluating diverse perspectives.
“The higher the probability, the nearer we are to the Truth, but we may never reach the truth because there is always the possibility of error. The highest probability is all that we can achieve.” — Thought from Bertrand Russell
• ADOPT HEALTHY SKEPTICISM!
protect us from misinformation, bias, and manipulation by encouraging critical thinking, evidence-based reasoning, and informed decision-making.
Lesson VII- Concept of the Human
USUAL CHARACTERISTICS
Is a bipedal animal
Has a form of communication
Has feelings
Is rational
Is an ever changing entity (innovations)
Is mortal
Is not perfect
ACIENT GREEKS focused on the origin of the cosmos / the discovery of the fundamental element -searching for the “WHAT-NESS”
According to PLATO, a human is essentially his/her soul
The Soul, that which makes up a Human, is trapped in the prison of the Body, since it is within the body that the Soul is corrupted, made to forget the Truths we originally possess, it is the Body that is at fault of our errors, of limiting what we know and what we can do to achieve what is the ideal real.
PLATO’S TRIPARTITE SOUL
LOGISTIKON (REASON)
CASTE: philosopher-kings
DRIVES:truth, wisdom, cosmic order
BODY PART: head
THUMETIKON (SPIRIT)
CASTE: warriors
DRIVES: honor, glory, victory
BODY PART: heart
EPITHUMETIKON (APPETITE)
CASTE: workers
DRIVES:carnal desires, materialism
BODY PART: stomach, genitalia
Society is simply an enlarged body. It must be governed by reason as it knows what is good and can command/control the lower functions.
According to ARISTOTLE, a human is a substance that is formed of two principles.
ARISTOTLE
A human possesses the union of body and soul wherein actuality is in the latter while potentiality is in the former. The soul, then, regardless of its non-material nature. Cannot exist apart from the body
IF ONE DIES, ONE IS NO LONGER A HUMAN BUT RATHER IT TRANSITIONS INTO A NEW FORM- A CORPSE
THE GOODNESS OF SOMETHING IS LINKED WITH ITS FUNCTION- for humans, it is habitual exercise of our highest and distinctive function-our intellect.
In filipino..
When one is in a condition of bare survival, we say: HINDI MAKATAO
When one falls into a coma, we say: GULAY
When one does not have any capacity to reason, we say: HAYOP KA! At NAWALAN NG BAIT
Therefore..
To be HUMAN, existing within the rest of HUMANITY, one must always be HUMANE!
THOMAS AQUINAS
RENE DESCARTES a human who thinks of the “i”
THE PROBLEM OF THE DESCARTIAN “I”
Your life can be anything you want it to be
Lesson VIII- An Embodied Subject
HUMAN PERSON - A being that is individual and self aware
1. Corporeal (Body)
2. Immaterial (Soul) (Reason)
REFLECTIVE ACTIVITY - consequence of a disturbance in the chain of our daily routine.
EXISTENTIAL BREAK - event that shakes us and forces us to pause and think about what had previously happened.
TYPES OF REFLECTION by Gabriel Marcel
PRIMARY
-Occurs when we inquire about things in a Distant and Objective manner.
-The inquirer sets himself apart from the object of his study.
SECONDARY
-Occurs with the involvement of the inquirer into his inquiry.
-One can detach oneself from the question.
MARCEL’S EMBODIMENT
1. Removal of our preference for the Soul and Rationality
2. Argue for the existential importance of the Body (unlike Descartes)
3. Recognition of Operations apart from our body.
4. Claim Ownership of our Body (different from Possession) | Entails certain conditions and responsibilities.
5. To courageously face ourselves in the process of Inquiry.
MARTIN HEIDEGGER
Dasein - “Being there in the world”
We can never dislodge ourselves from my concrete situation which includes the things and people around me, as well as the culture, language, location and every present thing.
HEIDEGGER’S DASEIN
1. Acknowledgement of our relational encounter with things
2. Acknowledgement of our relational encounter with other people.
3. Acknowledgement of our relational encounter with Time and Place.
Lesson IX - Limitations and Transcendence
A.) Limitations by Jean-Paul Satre
1.) FACTILITY: Refers to things in our lives that are already given and beyond our control (ex: Ang tanong na ‘pinili mo bang mabuhay sa mundong ito?’)
2.) FINITUDE: The recognition of our Mortality and accepting that we will soon fade away from Existence. Death is a fact of life, period.
(When we’re young we want the time to be FAST but when we grow older we want to stop the time or make it longer.)
3.) SPATIAL LIMIT: The recognition that we can only be at one place at any given point in time
(ex: Mga OFW, they want to spend their time with their family but wala silang choice dahil nasa ibang bansa sila at kailangan kumayod)
4.) LIMITS OF UNDERSTANDING: The recognition that due to our Spatial-Temporal Limitations, the things we can know is also limited. (May limitasyon lang din ang kakayahan natin pero hindi ibig sabihin non ay hanggang don lang tayo)
5.) Body as Intermediary: The recognition that my own body limits my actions and my view of the world
B.)
Transcending Limitations
Let us be History-making creatures (HISTORICITY)
“We are free to define who we are and who we are to be”
“Our lives are not determined by fate, but by our own CHOICES”
Let us live in the Now (PRESENT-ORIENTEDNESS)
“Value things not because it has yet to come nor due to it being long gone”
“Make the best out of the moments”
3.) Let us be comfortable in our own skins (BODY-ORIENTED EXPERIENCES)
“Be creative in expressing one’s feelings”
“Acknowledge the privilege of your experience”
Lesson X - Environmental Ethics
Morality - dictates what's right or wrong behavior/beliefs, —> our own principles.
The Act of Making Choices
Human Valuation on Things
**Plays a Vital Role in our lives
Ethics - branch of philosophy dealing with systematic questioning and critical examination of the underlying principles of morality.
LAND ETHICS (Aldo Leopold; A Sand Country Almanac, 1949)
Intrinsic Value - The Value is inherent in itself. It is worth pursuing as an end-in-itself.
(Mga bagay na v-value bc of what it is at hindi dahil sa binibigay niya.
(Kunyare, nagkagusto ka sa isang tao, nagkagusto ka bc of who he is at hindi lang dahil gusto mo ng thrill sa buhay. (EXAMPLE LANG PO T-T)
Instrumental Value - The Value is found by being a means towards achieving a certain end.
(So like nag sikap ka mag-aral dahil sa dulo may reward ito na tulad ng may matutunan ka.)
MORAL WORTH - ways of consideration of beings
Preservation - you would not use it — just let it be on how it is.
Conservation - maintaining
Restoration — returning it on its original state
Traditional Anthropocentrism - human centered ng moral consideration
Nature serves man
Man at the height of the evolutionary process
Enlightened Anthropocentrism - humans as environmental guardians
Obligation to future generations
Frugality and equitable allocation of resources
Stewards of beauty
Pathocentrism - Sentient animals are also morally considerable
Intelligent animals feel pain
Intelligent animals possess intrinsic value
Just like us humans may mga nararamdaman ang mga hayop.
They exist bc of what they are
Biocentrism Plants are morally considerable
Teleological Center
Mere Possession of life
Ecocentrism - the ecosystem, as a holistic entity, is morally considerable.
Theories in ECOGOLOGY:
Hallow Ecology - The inutile attempt to fight pollution and depletion of natural Resources
Deep Ecology - assumes all living thing possess equal value and intrinsic with regardless of their utility to other beings
Social Ecology: 1st nature - Biotic, 2nd nature - Human (Utopic)
Political Ecology - dynamics between the interaction of the people and their environment and how it creates power relations.
Ecofeminism - domination and exploitation of nature stems from a male centered view of nature “Superiority justifies subordination”
Historical, Casual Connection (Patriarchal outcome)
Conceptial connection (The use of “or)
Symbolic Connection (Nature of God)
PRIMA FACIE OBLIGATION - protektahan ang environment, specially sa ating sarili
Positive duty - bring aid to environment
Negative Duty - do not cause harm to the environment
Global Initiatives:
Kyoto Protocol (1997) - agreement to reduce carbon dioxide emissions
Montreal Protocol (1987) - agreement to reduce ozone depetion
Basel Convention (1989) - controlling transboundary movements of hazardous wastes
Paris Accords (2015) - agreement on a five-year cycle of ambitious climate action by signatory countries.
“
Unchartered territory
” – The myriad climate impacts seen around the world in 2023—including massive wildfires, large-scale flooding, and prolonged heat waves —and the continued rise of greenhouse gas emissions are cause for much concern. But the clean-energy transition has also gathered momentum in terms of deployment, investment, and policies related to lowering carbon dioxide emissions. –
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists
Key Terms
Traditional Anthropocentrism - human centered.
Enlightened Anthropocentrism - human = moral consideration.
Pathocentrism - animals are morally considerable
Ecocentrism - ecosystem