The Collapse of Communism Study Notes lecture 23

Lecture 23: The Collapse of Communism

Key Themes and Preconditions

  • Shevardnadze Quote

  • Preconditions for Change Inside the USSR

    • Mikhail Gorbachev

    • Became Party General Secretary in March 1985.

    • Embodied a new generation influenced by:

      • Years of Khrushchev's leadership.

      • The de-Stalinization process of the late 1950s-60s.

    • Implemented reforms via

      • Glasnost:

      • Advocated for openness and transparency in government.

      • Perestroika:

      • Called for restructuring of the economy and political system.

    • Introduced a New Thinking in international relations.

    • Impact of the Chernobyl Disaster (April 1986):

    • This catastrophe profoundly affected Gorbachev's policies and public perception.

    • INF Treaty:

    • Signed in December 1987 to reduce intermediate-range nuclear forces.

    • Geneva Accords:

    • Signed in April 1988, aimed at various arms control measures.

    • Repudiation of the Brezhnev Doctrine (July 1989):

    • Gorbachev publicly renounced the doctrine emphasizing Soviet intervention in Eastern Europe.

    • Replaced it with the Sinatra Doctrine, allowing Eastern European nations to determine their own destinies.

Patterns of Communist Collapse

  • Over 18 months after the Sinatra Doctrine announcement, communist regimes were rapidly dismantled across Eastern Europe.

  • Two Basic Patterns of Collapse:

Northern Pattern
  • Observed in countries where communism was imposed externally:

    • Countries: Poland, Hungary, German Democratic Republic (GDR), Czechoslovakia (CZ).

    • Collapse was characterized by

    • A swift transition.

    • Relatively bloodless revolutions.

Balkan Pattern
  • Seen in countries with deeper roots of communism intertwined with nationalism:

    • Countries: Romania, Bulgaria, Albania, Yugoslavia.

    • Revolutions here were more violent and prolonged.

Case Studies of Collapse

Poland and Hungary
  • Polish Roundtable Talks (February-April 1989):

    • Key negotiations between the Communist government and opposition, leading to:

    • Legalization of Solidarity as a political party.

    • June elections where Solidarity won all contested seats.

    • Jaruzelski, as President, appointed Tadeusz Mazowiecki, a Solidarity supporter, as Prime Minister.

    • Free elections in December 1990 led to Lech Wałęsa becoming president.

  • Hungary:

    • Kádár’s NEM (New Economic Mechanism) program became stagnant by 1985.

    • By May 1987, Kádár and his supporters were removed from the Politburo.

    • Hungarian leaders opted for a peaceful transition, leading to free elections in March 1990 and the election of Jozsef Antall as Prime Minister.

German Democratic Republic (GDR) and Czechoslovakia
  • Events in Hungary influenced the atmosphere in GDR.

  • GDR:

    • Erich Honecker rejected reform initiatives but was eventually removed due to mounting protests.

    • Protests erupted nationwide in October, culminating in the fall of the Berlin Wall on November 9.

  • Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution:

    • Following Husak's resignation in 1987, Milos Jakes took control.

    • Organized protests ignited on November 17, especially after police violence.

    • Nationwide protests and a general strike led to the regime's downfall.

    • Vaclav Havel became president on December 29.

Romania and the Balkan Pattern of Revolution
  • Romania, marked by a harsh regime, faced a bloody revolution:

    • Protests in Timisoara erupted on December 17, met with violent repression.

    • On December 21, Ceausescu’s speech was met with public dissent, leading to broader protests.

    • When the army refused to disperse protestors, Ceausescu and his wife attempted to flee but were captured, tried, and executed on December 25, 1989.

    • Despite this, a semi-authoritarian governance persisted after his fall.

Similar Patterns in Albania and Bulgaria
  • Revolutions in these countries mirrored Romania's, characterized by slow progress toward true democracy as old elites held significant power.

Impact Inside the USSR

  • The revolutions in Eastern Europe significantly influenced the USSR, leading to anti-Communist and nationalist movements:

    • Notable movements like the Baltic Way surfaced, highlighting the public's demand for freedom.

    • Overview of the impact inside the USSR point 2:

    • The breakup of the USSR was lushly peaceful with notable exceptions in the Baltic region in January 1991.

    • A standoff persisted between Moscow and nationalist movements until an attempted hardliner coup in August galvanized democratic forces in Russia.

    • In December 1991, Gorbachev resigned as president of a Union that had effectively ceased to exist.