Logarithms, Decibels, and Sound-Media Interaction in Ultrasound Physics

Principles of Logarithms and Logarithmic Scales

Logarithms represent a novel method of rating numbers based on powers of ten. Specifically, the logarithm, or log, of a number represents the number of 10s10s that are multiplied to create the original number. For example, to obtain the number 100100, we multiply 10×1010 \times 10. Since two tens multiplied together equal 100100, the log of 100100 is 22.

The significance of a logarithmic scale is that as the logarithm increases by 11, the actual number increases tenfold. A logarithmic increase of 22 indicates that the signal is 100100 times larger, based on the calculation 10×1010 \times 10. A simple way to determine the logarithm of an even power of ten, such as 1010, 10,00010,000, or 1,000,0001,000,000, is to count the zeroes. For instance, there are six zeroes in a million, so the log of a million is 66. This technique works specifically for even powers of ten (10,100,1000,…10, 100, 1000, \dots).

An everyday example of a logarithmic scale is the Richter scale, which measures the strength of earthquakes. When comparing a magnitude 55 earthquake to a magnitude 77 earthquake, the difference on the scale is 22 points. However, because the scale is logarithmic, each unit increase indicates that the strength of the earthquake is increased tenfold. Therefore, a 22-point difference indicates that the larger earthquake is 100100 times (10×1010 \times 10) stronger than the smaller one.

Decibel Notation in Diagnostic Ultrasound

In diagnostic ultrasound, it is essential to quantify the strength of sound beams as they are created and travel through the body, as well as electrical signal strength and image brightness. The decibel (dBdB) is the common unit used for these measurements. Decibel notation is logarithmic and does not measure absolute numbers; instead, it reports relative changes, such as a signal doubling or reducing to one-tenth of its original value.

Decibels require two intensities: the reference (or starting level) and the actual level at the time of measurement. Decibels are a ratio where the measured level is divided by the starting level. Decibel notation is characterized as a relative measurement, a comparison, a ratio, and logarithmic.

Positive decibels report signals that are increasing in strength. Two relative changes are mathematically significant: when a wave's intensity doubles, the relative change is +3 dB+3\,dB. When intensity increases ten-fold, the relative change is +10 dB+10\,dB.

Negative decibels describe signals that are decreasing in strength. When the intensity is reduced to 12\frac{1}{2} its original value, the relative change is −3 dB-3\,dB. When the intensity is reduced to 110\frac{1}{10} its original value, the relative change is −10 dB-10\,dB. For example, a sound beam that has increased from its initial intensity by a factor of 100100 is described as +20 dB+20\,dB (+10 dB+10\,dB and another +10 dB+10\,dB). Conversely, a beam that has decreased to 1100\frac{1}{100} of its initial intensity is described as −20 dB-20\,dB (−10 dB-10\,dB and another −10 dB-10\,dB).

Physical Principles of Attenuation

Sound waves weaken as they propagate through a medium, experiencing a decrease in intensity, power, and amplitude. This process is called attenuation. Attenuation is determined by two factors: path length and the frequency of sound. The distance sound travels directly affects attenuation; the farther sound travels, the greater the attenuation and the weaker the beam becomes. Distance and attenuation are directly related. Similarly, attenuation in soft tissue depends on frequency. High-frequency sound experiences greater attenuation than lower-frequency sound, making frequency and attenuation directly related.

Attenuation is measured in decibels and reported as a relative change. Often, the negative sign is omitted in reports; for instance, a statement of "10 dB10\,dB of attenuation" implies a weakening of the signal, which mathematically means −10 dB-10\,dB. Higher frequencies result in more attenuation and less penetration, while lower frequencies experience less attenuation and provide more penetration.

Three processes contribute to attenuation: reflection, scattering, and absorption.

Reflection: Specular and Diffuse

As sound strikes a boundary, a portion of the wave's energy may be redirected, or reflected, back to the source. This reflection weakens the portion of the sound wave that continues forward. Reflection is likely when the boundary dimension is large, typically more than a few wavelengths of the sound.

Specular reflection occurs when the boundary is smooth, reflecting the sound in only one direction in an organized manner, similar to a light wave striking a mirror. A limitation of specular reflectors is that if the wave is even slightly off-axis, the reflection does not return to the transducer.

Diffuse reflection, or backscatter, occurs when a wave reflects off an irregular surface, radiating in more than one direction. An advantage of diffuse reflection is that interfaces at suboptimal angles to the sound beam can still produce reflections that return to the transducer. The disadvantage is that backscattered signals have lower strength than specular reflections.

Scattering and Rayleigh Scattering

Scattering is the random redirection of sound in many directions. This occurs when the tissue interface is small, equal to or less than the wavelength of the incident sound beam. Lung tissue scatters sound because the alveoli are filled with air. Scattering is directly related to frequency; higher frequency sound beams scatter much more than lower frequency beams.

Rayleigh scattering is a special, organized form of scattering that occurs when the structure's dimensions are much smaller than the beam's wavelength. It redirects the sound wave equally in all directions (omnidirectional). In clinical imaging, the interaction of ultrasound and red blood cells results in Rayleigh scattering. Rayleigh scattering increases dramatically with frequency, mathematically related to frequency raised to the fourth power:

Rayleigh scattering∝frequency4\text{Rayleigh scattering} \propto \text{frequency}^4

For example, if the frequency doubles, Rayleigh scattering becomes 1616 times greater (2×2×2×2=162 \times 2 \times 2 \times 2 = 16).

Absorption and the Attenuation Coefficient

Absorption is the third and most sizeable component of attenuation, occurring when ultrasonic energy is converted into another energy form, such as heat. Absorption is directly related to frequency. Sound traveling in bone undergoes extensive absorption.

The attenuation coefficient is a term used to simplify the reporting of attenuation, representing the number of decibels of attenuation that occurs when sound travels one centimeter. Its units are dB/cmdB/cm. The advantage of this coefficient is that its value remains constant regardless of distance. To find the total attenuation, the following formula is used:

total attenuation (dB)=attenuation coefficient (dB/cm)×distance (cm)\text{total attenuation (dB)} = \text{attenuation coefficient (dB/cm)} \times \text{distance (cm)}

In soft tissue, the attenuation coefficient and frequency are directly related, specifically with the coefficient being one-half the frequency:

atten. coef. (dB/cm)=frequency (MHz)2\text{atten. coef. (dB/cm)} = \frac{\text{frequency (MHz)}}{2}

atten. coef.=0.5 dB/cm/MHz\text{atten. coef.} = 0.5\,dB/cm/MHz

Attenuation in Various Media

Attenuation varies significantly across different media. Water has extremely low attenuation. Biologic fluids like blood, urine, and amniotic fluid have low attenuation, less than that of soft tissue. Soft tissue is categorized as intermediate. Muscle has higher attenuation, and notably, it attenuates sound twice as much when traveling across the fibers as when traveling along the length of the fibers. Bone and lung have even higher attenuation due to absorption and scattering respectively. Air has extremely high attenuation; sound with frequencies above 1 MHz1\,MHz attenuates entirely in air primarily due to absorption.

Half-Value Layer Thickness

The half-value layer thickness is the distance sound travels in a tissue that reduces the intensity of sound to one-half its original value. This is equivalent to the depth of tissue that results in 3 dB3\,dB of attenuation. The units are centimeters (cmcm) or any unit of length. In clinical imaging, typical values range from 0.250.25 to 1.0 cm1.0\,cm. Synonyms include penetration depth, depth of penetration, and half-boundary layer.

This thickness depends on the medium and the frequency of sound. It is thin for tissues with high attenuation (lung, bone) or high-frequency sound. It is thick for tissues with low attenuation (fluids) or low-frequency sound.

Acoustic Impedance

Acoustic impedance is the acoustic resistance to sound traveling in a medium. It is an important property that influences the amount of reflection at a boundary. Impedance (ZZ) is calculated, not measured, by multiplying the density of a medium by the propagation speed:

impedance (rayls)=density (kg/m3)×prop. speed (m/s)\text{impedance (rayls)} = \text{density (kg/m}^3\text{)} \times \text{prop. speed (m/s)}

Units are rayls, often represented by the letter ZZ. Bio-media values range from 1,250,0001,250,000 to 1,750,000 rayls1,750,000\,rayls (1.251.25 to 1.75 Mrayls1.75\,Mrayls). It is also called characteristic impedance.

Incidence and Angles

The angle at which a sound pulse strikes a boundary determines its behavior. There are three types of angles: acute (less than 90∘90^\circ), right (exactly90∘exactly 90^\circ), and obtuse (greater than 90∘90^\circ). Angles other than 90∘90^\circ (acute and obtuse) are called oblique angles.

Normal incidence means the sound beam strikes the boundary at exactly 90∘90^\circ. Synonyms include perpendicular, orthogonal, right angle, and 90 degrees90\,degrees. Oblique incidence occurs when the beam strikes the boundary at any angle other than 90∘90^\circ.

Intensity Coefficients and Conservation of Energy

When a sound wave strikes a boundary, it may divide into reflected and transmitted parts. Incident intensity is the intensity immediately before striking the boundary. Reflected intensity returns toward the source, and transmitted intensity continues forward. Conservation of energy requires:

incident (starting) intensity=reflected intensity+transmitted intensity\text{incident (starting) intensity} = \text{reflected intensity} + \text{transmitted intensity}

The Intensity Reflection Coefficient (IRCIRC) is the percentage of intensity that bounces back. In clinical imaging, 1%1\% or less is reflected at soft tissue boundaries, while more is reflected at bone or air interfaces. The Intensity Transmission Coefficient (ITCITC) is the percentage that passes forward. Typically, 99%99\% or more is transmitted at soft tissue boundaries. Both coefficients are dimensionless and reported as percentages:

100%=IRC+ITC\text{100\%} = IRC + ITC

Reflection and Transmission with Normal Incidence

With normal incidence (90∘90^\circ), reflection occurs only if the media have different impedances. No reflection occurs if impedances are identical. A small reflection occurs if they are slightly different, and a large reflection occurs if they are substantially different. The IRCIRC can be calculated as:

IRC(%)=[Z2−Z1Z2+Z1]2×100IRC (\%) = \left[ \frac{Z_2 - Z_1}{Z_2 + Z_1} \right]^2 \times 100

For transmission with normal incidence, all sound is transmitted if impedances are the same. The ITCITC is defined as:

ITC(%)=transmitted intensityincident intensity×100=1−intensity reflection coefficientITC (\%) = \frac{\text{transmitted intensity}}{\text{incident intensity}} \times 100 = 1 - \text{intensity reflection coefficient}

Principles of Oblique Incidence

The physics of oblique incidence is complex. We cannot predict reflection or transmission based on impedance alone; reflection may occur even if impedances are identical, or might not occur even if they are different. However, two principles always apply:

  1. Conservation of Energy: The sum of reflected and transmitted intensity must equal the incident intensity (W/cm2W/cm^2).
  2. Reflection Angle = Incident Angle: The direction of the reflected echo is equal and opposite to the incident beam. The angle of incidence is between the incident beam and a line perpendicular to the boundary; the angle of reflection is between the reflected beam and that same perpendicular line.

Refraction and Snell's Law

Refraction is a change in direction of wave propagation when traveling from one medium to another. It is "transmission with a bend." Refraction occurs only if two conditions are met: oblique incidence and different propagation speeds between the two media. If these conditions are met, the sound wave will bend. Bending is minimal at soft tissue interfaces but exaggerated at bone-soft tissue interfaces because bone's speed is nearly three times greater.

Snell's Law quantifies refraction:

sin⁡(transmission angle)sin⁡(incident angle)=speed of Medium 2speed of Medium 1\frac{\sin(\text{transmission angle})}{\sin(\text{incident angle})} = \frac{\text{speed of Medium 2}}{\text{speed of Medium 1}}

Medium 1 is where sound is currently traveling; Medium 2 is where it is entering. If Speed 2 equals Speed 1, no refraction occurs. If Speed 2 is greater than Speed 1, the transmission angle is greater than the incident angle. If Speed 2 is less than Speed 1, the transmission angle is less than the incident angle.

The Range Equation and Time-of-Flight

Ultrasound systems determine reflector depth by measuring the pulse's time-of-flight, also called go-return time. This is the elapsed time from pulse creation to reception. Time-of-flight is directly related to depth:

depth (mm)=1.54 mm/μs×go-return time (μs)2\text{depth (mm)} = \frac{1.54\,mm/\mu s \times \text{go-return time (}\mu s\text{)}}{2}

The 1313-Microsecond Rule applies to soft tissue: for every 13 μs13\,\mu s of go-return time, the object is 1 cm1\,cm deeper in the body. For example, a 26 μs26\,\mu s time-of-flight means a reflector depth of 2 cm2\,cm and a total distance traveled of 4 cm4\,cm. A 39 μs39\,\mu s time-of-flight corresponds to a depth of 3 cm3\,cm and a total distance of 6 cm6\,cm.

PRP, PRF, and Imaging Depth

Pulse Repetition Period (PRPPRP) is the go-return time of a pulse between the transducer and the bottom of the image. The 1313-microsecond rule applies here as well:

PRP(μs)=imaging depth (cm)×13 μs/cmPRP (\mu s) = \text{imaging depth (cm)} \times 13\,\mu s/cm

PRPPRP is directly related to maximum imaging depth. If depth is 10 cm10\,cm, PRPPRP is 130 μs130\,\mu s.

Pulse Repetition Frequency (PRFPRF) is inversely related to maximum imaging depth. In soft tissue, sound can travel to and from a depth of 77,000 cm77,000\,cm in one second:

PRF(Hz)=77,000 cm/simaging depth (cm)PRF (Hz) = \frac{77,000\,cm/s}{\text{imaging depth (cm)}}

If depth is 7.7 cm7.7\,cm, PRFPRF is 10,000 Hz10,000\,Hz. If depth is 15.4 cm15.4\,cm, PRFPRF is 5,000 Hz5,000\,Hz.

Ultrasound Transducer Construction

A transducer converts energy from one form to another. During transmission, electrical energy becomes acoustic; during reception, acoustic energy becomes electrical. Transducers use the piezoelectric effect: the property of materials to create a voltage when mechanically deformed. They also use the reverse piezoelectric effect: materials change shape when voltage is applied.

Piezoelectric materials, also called ferroelectric, include natural quartz and tourmaline, but clinical transducers use synthetic lead zirconate titanate (PZTPZT). Synonyms for PZTPZT include ceramic, active element, or crystal.

A basic transducer has seven components:

  1. Case: Protects internal parts and insulates patients from shock.
  2. Electrical shield: A metallic barrier preventing electrical noise from air.
  3. Acoustic insulator: Cork or rubber isolating internal components from the case to prevent vibrations from creating voltage.
  4. PZT / active element: The crystal itself, 12\frac{1}{2} wavelength thick.
  5. Wire: Electrical connection between the crystal and system.
  6. Matching layer: Increases efficiency of sound transfer and protects the crystal. It is 14\frac{1}{4} wavelength thick.
  7. Backing material (damping element): Bonded to the crystal's back to reduce ringing. Often made of epoxy resin with tungsten filaments.

Matching Layer and Gel Impedance

PZTPZT impedance is about 2020 times greater than skin. Without a matching layer, most sound would reflect and not enter the body. The matching layer has an impedance between the crystal and skin. Gel further bridges the gap. In decreasing order of impedance:

PZT>matching layer>gel>skinPZT > \text{matching layer} > \text{gel} > \text{skin}

Characteristics of Backing Material

Backing material creates short pulses. Without it, the crystal vibrates for a long time, degrading axial resolution. Damping material has a high degree of sound absorption and an impedance similar to PZTPZT.

Three consequences of backing material are:

  1. Decreased Sensitivity: The transducer is less responsive to tiny reflected waves during reception.
  2. Wide Bandwidth: Damping prevents the crystal from vibrating at a single resonant frequency. Instead, it creates a short sound "click" containing many frequencies. Bandwidth is the range between the highest and lowest frequencies in a pulse.
  3. Low Quality Factor (Q−factorQ-factor): A unitless number inversely related to bandwidth:

quality factor=main frequencybandwidth\text{quality factor} = \frac{\text{main frequency}}{\text{bandwidth}}

Imaging probes are "low-Q" because they have wide bandwidth. Non-imaging probes (CW Doppler/therapeutic) have narrow bandwidth and high-Q.

Polarization and Transducer Safety

PZTPZT properties are created via polarization: exposing the material to a strong electrical field while heating it to the Curie temperature (or Curie point). Properties are destroyed if heated above this point (depolarization).

Ultrasound transducers require disinfection, not sterilization. Sterilization kills all microorganisms using extreme heat or chemicals. Disinfection reduces microbial load. Transducers should be disinfected with germicides like Cidex and must not be exposed to extreme heat to avoid depolarization and damage to bonding agents.

Transducer Frequencies

For continuous wave (CWCW) transducers, the acoustic frequency equals the electrical frequency:

electrical frequency=acoustic frequency\text{electrical frequency} = \text{acoustic frequency}

For pulsed wave transducers, frequency depends on the speed of sound in the PZTPZT and the thickness of the PZTPZT. Speed of sound in PZTPZT is typically 44 to 6 mm/μs6\,mm/\mu s.

Frequency and speed are directly related: higher speed in PZTPZT means higher frequency. Frequency and thickness are inversely related: thinner crystals create higher frequencies and shorter wavelengths.

The mathematical relationship is:

\text{frequency (MHz)} = \frac{\text{sound's speed in PZT (mm/\mu s)}}{2 \times \text{thickness (mm)}}

Note: The thickness of the PZTPZT crystal in a pulsed wave transducer equals 12\frac{1}{2} the wavelength of sound in the PZTPZT.

Questions & Discussion

What is an everyday example of a logarithmic scale? The Richter scale for earthquakes is logarithmic, meaning a 22-point difference represents a 100100-fold difference in strength.

What is the log of 1,0001,000 and 10,00010,000? The log of 1,0001,000 is 33 (10×10×1010 \times 10 \times 10). The log of 10,00010,000 is 44.

A sound beam has increased from its initial intensity by a factor of 100100. How is this described in decibel notation?100=10×10100 = 10 \times 10. Since 1010 times is +10 dB+10\,dB, the result is +10 dB+10\,dB and another +10 dB+10\,dB, totaling +20 dB+20\,dB.

What is the meaning of a 6 dB6\,dB change?3 dB3\,dB means 22 times bigger. 6 dB6\,dB is 3 dB+3 dB3\,dB + 3\,dB, so 2×22 \times 2, or 44 times bigger.

Two media A and B have the same densities. The speed of sound in medium A is 10%10\% higher than in medium B. Which medium has the higher acoustic impedance? Medium A's acoustic impedance is higher because impedance equals speed multiplied by density. If speed is 10%10\% higher and density is the same, impedance is 10%10\% higher.

Which is better to use while examining a carotid artery, a 7.57.5 or a 3.0 MHz3.0\,MHz transducer? A 7.5 MHz7.5\,MHz transducer is better because higher frequency produces better images. Since the carotid is superficial, the higher attenuation of the 7.5 MHz7.5\,MHz beam is not a major concern.

Sound is traveling from bone to soft tissue. The impedances differ significantly, and 90%90\% of the intensity is reflected. What percentage is transmitted?10%10\% is transmitted, as energy must be conserved and account for 100%100\%.

If sound travels from Jell-O to whipped cream through an interface at 90 degrees90\,degrees, and their impedances are nearly identical, what percentage of intensity is transmitted? Approximately 99%99\%. Since impedances are nearly identical, very little reflects, and the remainder transmits.**