English Project 2 brainstorm
What are the goals of the discourse community?
What methods of communication that provide information and feedback does your community use
Which genres of writing does your discourse community use to help members meet community goals
What specialized language does your community use
How do new members gain expertise and grow into knowledgeable members? How might they bring new knowledge to the group?
Student
texts
teacher/other students
Purpose is to help finish an assignment
A lot more proper
RFI
Have to be intentional
No personalization at all. No I, you, they he, she, me
Very concise but detailed
Very specific
Formal tone
No unnecessary info
Could be referenced in legal claims or disputes, so you have to be careful
Part of projects documentation
Audience is engineers, owners and architects, subcontractors, and potentially a judge
Internship email
Goal is to get project done efficiently
emails phone calls and teams
Specialized language includes RFIS, submittals, OAC, and QC
Gain expertise through training, asking a lot of questions, and just gaining more experience. We bring in new ideas through meetings or emails
Professional language but allowed to be slightly more casual
Can be personal
Clear purpose
still concise and direct, but does not have to be as much
Audience matters
Conversational
Construction methods and materials class group.
3 different discourse communities
Learn features of discourse community
-
Intro
As people, we subconsciously adapt the way we speak and communicate depending on our environment and the discourse community we are a part of. The three different discourse communities being analyzed are my internship, my construction class group, and school life, specifically my communication with professors. Although I communicate differently in each of these communities, they all require me to change how I speak depending on the audience, goals, and situation.
Body paragraph 1
During this internship, the language used was mostly professional and direct but still personable. The two main methods of communication were RFIs (Requests for Information) and email. An RFI is a formal and documented question to clarify discrepancies, and it becomes part of the project records and could be referenced in legal disputes. Since it can be used in legal disputes, a rfi has to be very direct and concise while also having enough detail. Looking at the example of the rfi attached, it states exactly where in the drawings the discrepancy occurs. This is done because the reader needs to be able to tell exactly what the problem is and where it is happening, with no possibility of a misunderstanding. Another aspect of an RFI is that you can not be personable at all, unlike an email. Can not use any pronouns like he, she, we, they. Not even supposed to call out someone directly by name. The most you could do is speak directly to the architect, engineer, contractor, etc. Looking at that same RFI previously mentioned, it says, “An onsite conversation was had with architect.”
Body paragraph 2
The next form of communication used during my internship was emails. Emails were used for a lot of different reasons. They could be used to set up a meeting, communicate a problem or issue, or even to have a regular conversation with a coworker. So an email could be really formal, personable, or professional depending on the context. The first email I have attached says, “The architect required a revision for the submittal you sent for the Fire Suppression Escutcheon Product Data. You should have just received an email pertaining to it”. This sentence was direct, to the point, professional, while also being conversational. It used language that directly addressed somebody and was written more like a one-on-one conversation. Completely different from an RFI, whereas in that case, a word like you is not even acceptable. In that example, I was talking to a subcontractor who is not affiliated with my company. So if I were sending an email to a coworker, it would be a lot less to the point and a lot more conversational since that is someone I see and talk to almost every day.
Body paragraph 3
The next discourse community I am a part of is my group for my construction methods and materials class. This is a group of 5 people randomly selected by the teacher. We only have one form of communication, and that is our GroupMe group chat. Since nobody knew each other beforehand, the conversations are pretty straightforward and only pertain to schoolwork because, at the end of the day, we all have the same goal of getting a good grade. The GroupMe is made up of only students, so the conversations are laid-back and not professional at all. Looking at the first screenshot of the GroupMe’s messages, one person says, “What do y’all think of the presentation?” This sentence, especially the use of the word “y'all,” shows that there is no type of formality in the language with this group. Looking at the other messages, it also shows how straightforward the conversations are. After one guy asks what they think of the presentation, someone responded with “Looks good”. There is no conversational aspect to that sentence; it is just to the point.
Body paragraph 4.
The last discourse community that I’m going to talk about is my school and classes, more specifically communicating with my professors. The forms of communication usually consist of emails or Canvas messaging. Communicating with my professors will always pertain to grades, classes, or assignments/tests. So when I am communicating with my professors, I try to be very direct, respectful, and somewhat formal. In the email right under this paragraph, I made sure to add “I’ll make sure to catch up on anything I missed today.” This shows how I try to be respectful and formal by providing a legitimate reason for not going to class. That sentence is also a good example of being respectful because I offered to make up anything I missed that day. That lets the professor know that I’m taking responsibility for my absence.
Comparison paragraph
I communicate differently within each discourse community in several ways. When writing an email at my internship or for school, I always try to be formal, but the level of formality depends on who I’m sending that email to. When writing an RFI, it always has to be as formal as possible. On the other hand, it never has to be formal in any way for my construction class group. Another big difference in my communication between the 3 discourse communities is how conversational it is. Writing an RFI is completely direct, with no aspect of being conversational. An email can be very conversational, especially if it's being sent to a coworker or even a professor, depending on the relationship. Communication within my construction group could be conversational, but it is not a common occurrence.
Conclusion
Doing this project, I learned a lot about why I communicate the way I do in each community. Before, I never really thought about how I adapt the way I speak in each discourse community. Having to analyze, I was able to really see why I’m able to speak more casually with my coworkers compared to my professors, or why communication can be conversational in other situations or with other communities, but I have to stay direct and objective when writing an RFI. In conclusion, this project helped me realize that the way we all speak within our different discourse communities is not random, and there is a reason behind the way we communicate in each one