Case Study: Disgust and Phobia of Buttons
BACKGROUND: CLASSICAL CONDITIONING
Classical Conditioning: A learning procedure in which associations are made between two stimuli.
Neutral Stimulus (NS): Initially does not elicit a response.
Unconditioned Stimulus (UCS): Elicits a predictable response without training.
Unconditioned Response (UCR): Automatic or natural reaction to a stimulus without training.
Conditioned Stimulus (CS): Elicits a response due to being paired with an UCS.
Conditioned Response (CR): The learned reaction to a CS.
BACKGROUND: EXPECTANCY LEARNING
Expectancy Learning: Presentation of a previously neutral object/event associated with a negative outcome increases fear of that object/event.
Example: Fear of exams leads to anxiety during classes.
BACKGROUND: EVALUATIVE LEARNING
Evaluative Learning: Individuals come to evaluate a neutral object negatively without being aware of the association with negative outcomes.
Results in feelings of Disgust.
Example: Feeling above lowly tasks, such as exam-taking.
DISGUST AND PHOBIA
Disgust is a distinct emotion from fear and can lead to the evaluation of stimuli as repulsive.
Conditioned experiences can result in irrational phobias combining disgust with fear.
Examples:
Arachibutyrophobia: Fear of peanut butter sticking to the roof of the mouth.
Arithmophobia: Fear of numbers.
Koumpounophobia: Fear of buttons.
TREATING DISGUST
Research by Hepburn and Page (1999): Affirmed addressing disgust can aid in curing hemophobia (fear of blood).
Study by De Jong et al. (1997): Suggested reduction in disgust could ease fear of spiders.
PHOBIA IN DSM-5
Phobias classified under Anxiety Disorders in DSM-5.
Defined as persistent fear or anxiety that is excessively out of proportion to actual danger posed.
Types of phobias:
Specific Phobias: Fear of a specific object or situation.
Social Phobia: Fear of social situations.
Agoraphobia: Fear of being in situations where escape might be difficult.
CAUSES OF PHOBIA
Many phobias may be rooted in evolution, supporting the nature argument in the nature/nurture debate.
Example: Acrophobia (fear of heights) may relate to dangers faced by ancestors.
KOUMPOUNOPHOBIA
Koumpounophobia: Fear and aversion to buttons.
Notable case: Steve Jobs' aversion influenced the rise of touch-screen phones and fashion sense.
Symptoms:
Aversion to sight, sound, or texture of buttons; some unable to tolerate certain button types.
STUDY AIM
Aim: Investigate classical conditioning's role in fear and avoidance of buttons, comparing:
Positive reinforcement therapy
Imagery exposure therapy
RESEARCH METHOD AND SAMPLE
Clinical Case Study:
Focused on one 9-year-old Hispanic-American boy who experiences koumpounophobia since age 5.
Data collected through self-reports at Child Anxiety and Phobia program at Florida International University.
Symptoms measured using a 9-point scale called “Feelings Thermometer.”
INTERVENTION PROCESS
Phobia: Severely impacted daily functioning; boy unable to dress himself.
A hierarchy of feared stimuli was developed through discussions with the boy and mother.
1ST INTERVENTION: POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT
Approach: Awarded for showing less fear; rewards assigned post successful handling of buttons.
Sessions: 4, lasting 20-30 minutes each.
Objective data: Number of buttons touched + self-report distress ratings were measured.
Hierarchy of fear respected, beginning with less feared buttons.
2ND INTERVENTION: IMAGERY EXPOSURE
Sessions 5-11 focused on visualization techniques rather than real buttons.
Included disgust-related exposures and coping strategies.
Exercises involved imagining buttons falling on him and discussing feelings about these images.
RESULTS OF THERAPIES
Positive Reinforcement Results
Initial success in increasing button handling numbers; however, overall feelings of disgust increased with each session.
Imagery Exposure Results
Effective in addressing disgust; showed long-term reduction in distress levels associated with buttons.
From initial distress rating of 8 for button imagery falling on him, ratings decreased to 3 by the end of therapy.
Follow-ups at 6 and 12 months indicated minimal distress; no longer classified as phobic.
CONCLUSIONS
Treatment was deemed successful; cognitive and emotional aspects of disgust crucial for forming new associations with phobias.
Imagery exposure proved beneficial for long-lasting distress reduction.
EVALUATION OF THE STUDY
Assess strengths and weaknesses including:
Generalizability
Reliability
Application to Everyday Life
Validity
Ethics
Quantitative vs. Qualitative Data
Standardization
Experimenter Bias
Demand Characteristics