Lecture 4: Cost Principles and Methods Notes
Foundations of Cost Analysis in Decision Modeling
Primary Objective: Include “resource consumption” + “cost offsets” into healthcare decisions to calculate the Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio:
and = costs of treatments A and B
and = respective health effects of the costs
Two Components:
Resource Consumption: Resources used during or as a result of an intervention
Cost Offset: resources saved/future healthcare costs avoided resulting from healthcare intervention
ICER/Cost-Effectiveness Analyses Purpose: compare the costs & health benefits of one medical treatment or technology vs. another
Cost is typically a measure of resource consumption in decision modeling

Economic Definition of Cost:
Resource Cost: value of what we are willing to give up to acquire a resource
Opportunity Cost: The value of the best alternative foregone to acquire a resource
Conditions: Heterogeneity: different people face different costs when they choose to do the same thing.
Individuals have preferences
Individuals value time differently
Influenced by environment
Market Prices vs. Opportunity Costs: Market prices equal/reflect opportunity costs only under perfect competition.
Perfect Competition Where Market Price = Opportunity Cost
There are many buyers and sellers in the market
Buyers are fully informed about product characteristics
Price is based on agreement between a willing buyer and a willing seller (“transaction”)
Information about prices is widely available

Healthcare markets are imperfect due to:
1) Intermediary agents
2) Price information unavailable
3) Minimal price negotiation
4) Price subsidies to buyers
Perfect Competition: market prices (value assigned to goods/services in trade) = opportunity costs
AKA: prices are set entirely by supply and demand without any artificial distortions (price opacity, subsidy, taxes…).
Cost Evaluation Criteria:
Objectives: reliability (precision in estimating costs), reproducibility (others can follow approach), and validity (credibility of findings).
Cost Estimation Steps: *Before Estimating Costs: Decide on a Perspective”
Identification: Define relevant consumed resources
Quantification: Measure resource quantities
Valuation: Assign monetary values to quantified resources
Cost Evaluation Perspectives
Patient
Payer
Health System
Society
Analytical Perspectives and Reference Cases
Perspective Selection: Determines which cost types are included based on the decision-maker (e.g., patient, third-party payer, health system, society). Context of the research question (and data) informs perspective choice.
Second Panel Recommendations: The Second Panel on Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine (2016) recommends reporting two reference case perspectives:
Healthcare Sector Perspective: Captures all formal healthcare sector costs regardless of who pays.
Societal Perspective: Captures formal healthcare, informal healthcare, and non-healthcare sector costs.

IMPORTANT, Cost Categorization:
Formal Health Care Sector: Third-party payer costs (ex: insurance) and patient out-of-pocket costs.
Informal Health Care Sector: Patient time, unpaid caregiver time, and transportation costs.
Non-Health Care Sector: Productivity losses (lost wages), consumption changes, social services, legal/criminal justice, education, housing, and environmental impacts.
Cost Measurement and Valuation Methods
Resource Identification: Via clinical pathway look at everything that happens to a patient during their healthcare journey, and identify what costs might arise at each stage.
Assign Resource Category to each event in pathway

Cost Precision Levels:

Micro-Costing: Highly precise; itemizes individual resource components (personnel time, supplies, equipment, overhead). Suitable when interventions alter care delivery processes or when specific components drive overall costs.
Macro-Costing (Gross Costing): Aggregates resource categories into generalized cost units (e.g., DRG payments, per diem rates, hospital stay averages). Less resource-intensive and commonly derived from national databases.
Valuation Principles:
Charges vs. Payments: Billed charges represent list prices and differ from actual payments made by insurers/patients due to contractual discounts.
Standard Medical Coding Frameworks:
CPT/HCPCS: Procedure and service codes (e.g., for an established outpatient visit).
ICD-10: Diagnostic codes for diseases (e.g., for influenza).
DRG: Inpatient prospective payment classification groups (e.g., DRG for pneumonia).
National Data Sources: Includes HCUPnet, Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (CMS), Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS), Red Book, Federal Supply Schedule, and claims databases.
Adjusting Costs for Time: Inflation and Discounting
Inflation Adjustment: Converts historical cost measurements to a baseline comparison year.
Personal Health Care (PHC) Expenditure Deflator: Recommended by the Second Panel over general Consumer Price Index (CPI) for healthcare service cost adjustments:
Discounting: Converts future costs to present value (PV) to account for time preference and opportunity costs.
Recommended Discount Rate: annually (reflecting long-term real yield on risk-free government bonds).
Present Value Formula: where is the discount rate and is the year in the future.
Cancer Screening Case Study Results
Decision Tree Model Analysis Parameters:
Comparison: Usual Care vs. New Screening Test.
Perspective: Healthcare Sector Perspective.
Model Results:
Usual Care: Expected health outcome = life-years; Expected cost = .
New Screening Test: Expected health outcome = life-years; Expected cost = .
Incremental Difference: life-years per person; per person ( life-years and per individuals).
Second Panel on Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine: Helps with Perspective Building
Perspectives
Micro-costing (detailed costing)
Calculates the cost of every individual resource used.
Includes staff time, supplies, equipment and overheads.
More precise, but takes more time and effort.
Best when you need to know exactly where the costs come from or how a treatment changes the way care is delivered.
Example: Adding up the cost of the doctor's time, medication, tests and equipment used to treat one patient.
Macro-costing (overall costing)
Calculates costs using overall averages or combined costs rather than pricing every resource individually.
Uses figures such as the average cost per hospital stay or the cost per day in hospital.
Quicker and easier, often using existing databases.
Less detailed, so it may not show exactly what resources caused the costs.