midterm lock in
Chakravarti: neutrality vs. impartiality; jury selection for the Derek Chauvin trial
Who should serve on jury & what does an “impartial juror” mean?
Jury selection process took two weeks → questionnaire asked about previous exposure to the George Floyd case → answers showed if jurors wanted police reform or they liked it the way it is
Precedent cases say it is unconstitutional to dismiss jurors on basis of race
Jurors should have civic awareness
Jury’s job is to tell how laws are enforced in lives of normal citizens & hold law enforcement accountable
Impartiality contradicts human nature → no one can be truly impartial when asked to judge emotional and physical violence
Neutrality not possible due to scale of case → juror is legally "impartial" if they can understand constitutional safeguards like presumption of innocence and beyond reasonable doubt
Agrees with plurality of perspective bc impartiality comes in when they include a variety of jurors
Lorde: The master’s tools; the treatment of differences within the feminist movement
Women are used as tokens of diversity in a pool of white people
Not talking about the difference of race, sex, age, etc. weakens feminist discussions
Conference she’s speaking at only has one panel where input of Black and lesbian women is repped → this assumes that these women have nothing to say about power or theory
Difference should not merely be tolerated, it is necessary polarity that can spark creativity
Personal visions lay the groundwork for political action
The master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house = You cannot dismantle an unfair system using the same methods (division, hierarchy, tokenism) that were made to build that system
Using the same framework might win you a temporary seat at the table, but it will never build a truly equal society
Agrees with plurality of perspective
Arendt:
Our understanding of justice lies within the perspectives of common people
Doxa is not merely subjective compared to the "Truth," but a person’s unique way of seeing and appearing in the world
Socrates does not impose his beliefs on those he meets, but instead questions their assumptions and helps them find truth within their answers
“The role of the philosopher.. is not to rule the city but to be its ‘gadfly,’ not to tell philosophical truths but to make citizens more truthful” (Arendt 434).
Open-ended discussion allows for political freedom (citizens help shape govt & participate)
Aristotle: habituation; golden mean; moral virtue; telos; eudaimonia; who is a citizen; who
should rule the city
True citizen is one who holds public office and shares in administration of justice
A good man possesses absolute and moral virtue but definition of a good man depends on specific constitution (politea) under which they live
An excellent citizen has the capacity both to rule and be ruled
Manual laborers, women, children, and the elderly are excluded from true citizenship
Politea is the supreme govt that aims at common good of all citizens
3 Correct Forms of Govt:
Monarchy (rule by one)
Aristocracy (rule by best few)
Polity (Rule by many & mixed regime that is stabilized by a middle class) **Aristotle’s primary choice
What is merit? → Virtue and an individual's capacity to contribute to common good
Someone who is superior should be absolute king
Is it better to be ruled by law or man? → Law is better bc it operates without desire or emotional bias (no appetite)
Hidden curriculum: DOs and DONTs that aren’t written down and not explained by anyone, but insiders know
Eudaimonia: Not just happiness, but also fulfilling all desires and living by moral virtue
Aristotle critiques Plato by saying that absolute standards (The Forms) are too general & irrelevant to people’s everyday lives
What is happiness? → Life being desirable and lacking nothing; chosen for itself not for the sake of something else
Happiness is acquired through habituation (learning & effort) rather than by chance; Moral virtues actualized through repeated practice
2 Types of Virtues:
Intellectual (wisdom)
Ethical/moral (habit and practice, like courage and temperance)
Virtues and vices are how good/bad we stand with relation to passions (anger, envy, joy, etc.)
All human activities aim at some good
Purpose of talking to people is to rule in the Good
Telos: an end and ultimate good
Golden Mean: moral virtue is the proper middle ground between two extremes
Actions must avoid extremes (excess or deficit)
Not everything has a mean (theft, murder, adultery)
Younger people are less capable of political judgement given their lack of life experience
Agrees with plurality of perspective bc “dweller of a house has important knowledge of the house, even if he didn’t build it”
Machiavelli: fortuna; fortresses; hereditary rule; the dedicatory letter; virtù vs. virtue; morality in politics; economy of violence; imitating historical examples
Virtue vs virtu:
Virtue: Moral excellence
Virtu: doing moral act to secure stability of the state
Aspects of Virtu:
Controls experiences
Adapts to changing circumstances
Flexible character
Fortuna: Randomness and luck (50% of governance is just fortuna)
Hereditary rule (rule of those belonging to the present ruler’s family) is easier to hold than new states because the subjects are accustomed to the traditions
Hereditary rule is also easier to conquer bc one disgruntled noble can revolt with enemy
Morality should be between you and should not guide political decision-making
There are no high moral standards to guide our actions → The Prince has advisors’ perspectives and historical examples as references
Actions cannot be virtuous → it’s a way to power, not glory
Principality = state ruled by one person (the prince)
Mixed Principalities: new territories added to an existing state
👆are unstable bc new subjects rebel in the false hope of improving their condition, old subjects resent the new rule, and the prince struggles to satisfy both
Economy of Violence:
Must be done in the beginning of rule so ppl forget about it over time
Must be done in one fell swoop
Acceptable if used to maintain order
The Prince should be feared (not hated) bc it is bound by a dread of punishment
Delegate harsh measures to officials, while leaving all the good personal favors for himself
Act like a fox to detect traps and act like a lion to frighten enemies
Should have no other objective than warfare
Fortresses:
Best fortress is avoiding hatred of the public, if not, then they act as refuge for enemy during revolt
Building internal fortresses shows distrust and fear toward own citizens, so DON’T
Fortresses can be useful, but only if ruler fears his own people than foreign armies
Dedicatory Letter:
Written to His Magnificence Lorenzo de Medici
Mach offers the greatest thing he possesses: a deep understanding of the behavior of great leaders (subtly seeking employment from the Medici family)
Agrees with plurality of perspective bc prince standing on the mountaintop cannot see the valleys clearly, while a commoner in the valley cannot see the summit, one must constantly shift perspectives between the rulers and the ruled
Plato: Theoria; philosopher-kings; the cave allegory; the ship of state; the expulsion of the
poets; the myth of the metals; the noble lie; the myth about Gyges; Plato’s theory of forms;
the city-soul analogy; doxai
Opening of Republic poses the Q: Who’s an insider/outsider? (who has the right to speak?)
Theoria: contemplation of the Forms (Form of Good) by the philosopher-king (ex. journey to a place away from home, in the purpose of witnessing certain foreign and unfamiliar spectacles that would challenge one’s own worldview)
People value justice for its consequences rather than its own sake
Myth of Gyges:
Gyges finds a golden ring that can make him invisible, uses this power to sneak into the palace, seduce the queen, murder the king, and seize control of the kingdom
Both an unjust/just person would commit the act if they knew they would never get caught
BUT committing unjust acts leaves a person unhappy, even if no one ever discovers the crime
Myth of Metals:
All citizens were born from the earth itself and are related to each other with a shared responsibility to protect the state
Rulers (reason) = gold, Auxiliaries (spirit) = silver, Common People (appetites) = bronze
AKA Noble Lie told to unify state
Plato’s theory is that there is one true perspective (The Truth), but it cannot be seen through everyday life → through Forms in Heavens → Form of Justice gives reality to the manifestations on Earth (legislation, cases, rules)
We should not look for definition of justice in Kallipolis, it’s only in Forms and understood by experts
Visible World: Images/Shadows that provide the tool (ex. sight, physical presence), Intelligible World: Truth and Ideas that need capacity to understand
Allegory of the Cave:
People who are not experts are the cave-dwellers
The shadows on the wall is Plato’s metaphor for politics (normal people can’t understand what’s actually there)
The shadows are doxai and it’s only the philosopher who can step out of the cave and see reality
Philosopher-Kings
Until philosophers rule as kings in their cities, cities will have no rest from evil
Philosophers should rule bc they have mastered what pertains to the craft
City-Soul (Kallipolis)
3 Classes
Guardians (Philosopher-Kings)
Auxiliaries (Soldiers)
Producers (Manual Laborers)
Justice in the city is when each class sticks to its own job and does not meddle in the affairs of others
Justice in the soul is when reason rules over the soul, supported by spirit, while appetite stays under control
Ship of State:
Ship captain is the true navigator while sailors are mindless who view true skill as useless
Expulsion of Poets:
Poetry is imitation (mimesis), making it three steps removed from the ultimate reality of the Forms
Poetry speaks to the appetitive parts of the human psyche rather than the rational part (Doesn’t like Homer)
They pretend to hold wisdom about human life and virtue without actually knowing it
Disagrees with plurality of perspective bc he doesn’t agree with doxai & common people are stupid
Hobbes: the state of nature; fear in Hobbes; the dangers of disagreement; justice
Justice for one can be cruel to another
State of Nature
Constant fear → human natural condition is when everyone is at war bc everyone wants to preserve their life by any means necessary
All humans are equal → no one is strong enough to be safe from others
3 Types of Conflict:
Competition
Distrust
Glory (fight for rep)
No common govt → no law → no injustice → force and fraud become cardinal virtues
Life without social order is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short," leaving no room for industry, agriculture, science, or culture
Humans are always in a “war of all against all”
War is not just fighting, but the readiness to do so when there is no assurance to the contrary
Fear and Liberty can coexist → fear compels one to willingly do something → subjects fear established laws even though they’re at liberty to break them
Fear of Death leads people to civil obedience
Dangers of Disagreement (that all lead to war)
When people try to define justice, society loses a common standard
When people take up arms to be independent
Religious authority is not ↑ than civil power
Justice does not exist in the state of nature and is instead created only when people form a social contract under the sovereign
Covenant is mutual agreement where people leave state of nature by transferring rights to ruling power in exchange for peace
Injustice is simply the breach of a covenant
Covenant allows people to create civil society (commonwealth)
Disagrees with plurality of perspective bc = civil war