10.4 Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
Sex Assigned at Birth
- Refers to classification based on anatomy, physiology, hormones, and genetics.
Gender Identity
- A person's understanding of their own gender.
- Can align or contrast with sex assigned at birth (male, female, intersex).
Sexual Orientation
- Defined as an enduring pattern of romantic or sexual attraction to members of the same gender, the opposite gender, or multiple genders.
- Categories include:
- Heterosexuality: Attraction to the opposite sex.
- Definition: "An enduring pattern of emotional, romantic, and/or sexual attractions to persons of the opposite sex."
- Commonly referred to as 'straight'.
- Homosexuality: Attraction to the same sex.
- Definition: "An enduring pattern of emotional, romantic, and/or sexual attractions to people of the same sex."
- Terms: 'lesbian' (female) and 'gay' (male), with 'gay' also used for both genders.
- Bisexuality: Attraction to both genders.
- Can also refer to attraction to any gender or sex, known as pansexuality.
- Asexuality: Lack of sexual attraction to others, sometimes considered a fourth category.
Challenges in Defining Sexual Orientation
- Definitions can be complicated and socially influenced.
- Majority identify as heterosexual, but sizable populations in the U.S. are homosexual or bisexual.
- Research estimates that 3% to 10% identify as homosexual.
- References include Kinsey et al. (1948), LeVay (1996), and Pillard & Bailey (1995).
Causes of Sexual Orientation
- Historical perspective: early beliefs attributed orientation to socialization and family experiences.
- Research shows similarities in family backgrounds for both heterosexuals and homosexuals.
- Scientific inquiry points towards biological influences:
- Genetic contributions have been evidenced over 25 years of research.
- Studies estimating genes account for at least 50% variability in orientation include Bailey & Pillard (1991), Hamer et al. (1993), Rodriguez-Larralde & Paradisi (2009).
- Brain structure/function differences noted between orientations.
- Key studies include Allen & Gorski (1992), Byne et al. (2001), Hu et al. (2008), and LeVay (1991).
- Changes in basic body structure/function also documented.
- Research by Hall & Kimura (1994) and others from 2000-2008.
Conclusion on Sexual Orientation
- Orientation is not a choice; it is an inherent, stable characteristic.
- Misconceptions persist regarding conversion therapies.
- Research critiques have branded successful gay conversion therapy claims as unreliable.
- Notable recant by Dr. Robert Spitzer in 2012, acknowledging flaws in his earlier research supporting conversion therapy.
- Spitzer's apology: "I now judge the major critiques of the study as largely correct…"
- Legislative actions are ongoing to outlaw conversion therapies deemed damaging, e.g., grounding laws in places like California.
Gender Identity Distinction
- Common misconceptions exist that conflate sexual orientation with gender identity.
- Gender identity is about self-identification as male, female, or otherwise.
- Gender dysphoria is a recognized diagnostic condition characterized by distress due to mismatch between assigned gender and gender identity.
- To be diagnosed, distress must persist for at least six months.
- Children must express desire for a different gender identity verbally.
Terminology
- Cisgender: Identity aligns with birth sex.
- Transgender: Identity does not align with birth sex.
- Approximately 1.4 million U.S. adults (0.6%) are transgender.
Gender Expression and Cultural Considerations
- Gender and its expression is deeply cultural; influenced significantly by sociocultural norms.
- Gender identity can be diverse: includes woman, man, genderqueer identities.
- Gender expression is based on gender norms (clothing, behavior, etc.).
- Recognized as a spectrum rather than a binary concept.
- Vocabulary limitations persist in representing gender diversity.
Cultural Variations in Gender and Sexuality
- Different cultures have distinct attitudes towards gender and sexuality.
- Example: In New Guinea, periods of same-sex interactions are part of male socialization.
- In the U.S., predominant binary classification of gender (male/female).
- Other cultures (e.g., Thailand) recognize additional genders such as kathoey, similar to intersex or transgender classifications elsewhere.