Regression Modeling in Strength and Conditioning
Nonlinear Regression Models
- Simple and multiple linear regression models assume linear relationships, but nonlinear models exist for non-linear relationships.
- Gonzalez Bedillo and Sanchez Madina (2010) used an order polynomial relationship to model the nonlinear relationship between mean propulsive velocity and load.
- The accuracy and shape of the relationship determine the order of the polynomial.
- The goodness of fit (R-squared value) indicates the strength of the relationship; an R-squared of 98% indicates a strong fit.
Assumptions of Regression
- Nonlinear regression shares assumptions with linear regression, notably the independence of observations.
- Including all observations from a single participant violates this assumption due to the correlation between those observations.
Autocorrelation Error
- Including all observations from a participant leads to autocorrelation error, inflating the perceived strength of the relationship.
- Regression models are drawn to closely modeled participant scores, artificially strengthening the relationship.
- Example: Gonzalez, Bodillo, and Sanchez Medina had 120 participants, but more observations due to multiple repetitions per load.
- Including all repetitions artificially strengthens the model of the relationship between mean propulsive velocity and 1RM load.
Issues with Regression Modeling
- Using minimal data points when extrapolating beyond known values is problematic.
- Example: Using barbell velocity to predict 1RM with only two points. This is sometimes called the two-point method.
- One point represents velocity at 40% of 1RM, and another represents 80-90% of 1RM.
- A linear model is constructed using the slope and vertical intercept to estimate 1RM from velocity (X value).
- Using only two points to construct the model is unreliable.
- Furthermore, the actual 1RM velocity is an estimation from a population-wide assumption.
- Predictions of 1RM from velocity are often inaccurate due to small numbers of observations used to build and make predictions.
- Using five data points is common, but more data points leads to more accurate models.
Curvilinear Relationships
- Using linear models for curvilinear relationships is a problem.
- The relationship between independent variable velocity and dependent variable force is curvilinear.
Force-Velocity Relationship
- The force-velocity relationship is curvilinear, as shown by A.B. Hill's data from the 1930s.
- However, linear models are often used to predict and assess the relationship between force and velocity, guiding training decisions.
- The incorrect assumption of linearity causes issues with guidance and inferences drawn from these models.
Conclusion
- Regression is useful for describing relationships between variables and predicting performance with sufficient data.
- Caution is needed in strength and conditioning when applying models built on specific, small populations to the larger population.
- Extrapolating models beyond their original sample or population is problematic due to small sample sizes and issues with underlying assumptions.
- Be cautious about the use and application of regression modeling in strength and conditioning.