Business Studies: Creative Thinking and Problem Solving Techniques Guide

Problem Solving Steps and Application

  • Systematic Process for Problem Solving:

    • Identify the problem.
    • Define the problem.
    • Identify possible solutions to the problem.
    • Select the most appropriate alternative.
    • Develop an action plan.
    • Implement the suggested solution/action plan.
    • Monitor the implementation of the solution/action plan.
    • Evaluate the implemented solution.
  • Detailed Application of Problem Solving Steps:

    • Identify the problem:
    • Identify the exact problem.
    • Acknowledge that there is a problem.
    • Define the problem:
    • The nature of the problem must be precise.
    • Define the possible causes of the problem.
    • Gather as much information as possible to establish the cause of the problem.
    • Identify alternative solutions:
    • Identify all different possible solutions.
    • Decide on the cause.
    • Evaluate alternative solutions:
    • Use critical evaluation and analytical skills to evaluate each solution.
    • Consider the advantages and disadvantages of each alternative solution.
    • Choose the best solution:
    • Set criteria for the best solution, in terms of aspects such as time, cost, or risk involved.
    • Identify which solution will be used.
    • The best solution should match the size and the resources of the business.
    • If the solution is not appropriate, the business should go back to defining the problem.
    • Formulate/Develop an action plan/strategy:
    • Arrange the necessary resources and delegate tasks.
    • Establish a time line for implementation and set deadlines.
    • Implement the action plan:
    • Carry out the planned actions/solution.
    • Communicate delegated tasks/deadlines to employees.
    • Evaluate the solution/action plan:
    • Assess whether the problem has been solved partially or entirely.
    • Monitor/test the solution/action plan/strategy continuously.
    • If problems emerge, they must recognise and re-formulate the problem for improved solutions in the future.

Advantages and Benefits of Creative Thinking in the Workplace

  • Generating Solutions and Strategic Value:

    • Better, unique, and unconventional ideas/solutions are generated.
    • May give the business a competitive advantage if unusual/unique solutions, ideas, or strategies are implemented.
    • Complex business problems may be solved.
    • Productivity increases as management and employees may quickly generate multiple ideas, which utilises time and money more effectively.
  • Organizational and Personal Growth:

    • Managers and employees have more confidence as they can live up to their full potential.
    • Managers will be better leaders as they will be able to handle or manage change(s) positively and creatively.
    • Managers and employees can develop a completely new outlook, which may be applied to any task(s) they may do.
    • Leads to more positive attitudes as managers and employees feel that they have contributed towards problem solving.
    • Improves motivation amongst staff members.
    • Managers and employees have a feeling of great accomplishment and will not resist or obstruct the process once they solved a problem or contributed towards the success of the business.
    • Management and employees may keep up with fast-changing technology.
    • Stimulates initiative from employees and managers, as they are continuously pushed out of their comfort zone.
    • Creativity may lead to new inventions which improves the general standard of living.

Overview of Problem Solving Techniques

  • Key Problem Solving Techniques:
    • Delphi technique
    • Force field analysis
    • Brainstorming
    • Mind mapping
    • Nominal group technique
    • SCAMPER
    • Forced combination
    • Empty chair

Delphi Technique: Application and Impact

  • Application Procedure:

    • Businesses must invite a panel of experts to research the complaints from customers.
    • Experts do not have to be in one place and will be contacted individually.
    • Design a questionnaire consisting of questions on how to improve the quality of their products and distribute it to the panel members/experts.
    • Request the panel to individually respond to the questionnaire/suggest improvements to the products and return it to the business.
    • Summarise the responses from the experts in a feedback report.
    • Send the feedback report and a second set of questions/questionnaire based on the feedback report to the panel members.
    • Request panel members to provide further input/ideas on how to improve the quality of products after they have studied the results/documentation.
    • Distribute a third questionnaire based on previous feedback from the second round.
    • Prepare a final summary/feedback report with all the methods to improve the quality of the business's products.
    • The business should choose the best solution/proposal after reaching consensus.
  • Positives/Advantages:

    • Businesses may use a group of experts without bringing them together.
    • The experts will give the business clear ideas/solutions on how to improve on productivity/profitability.
    • Information received from experts can be used to solve complex business problems.
    • Experts may give honest/credible opinions as they do not have a direct/personal interest in the business.
    • Conflict may be avoided especially if all employees are knowledgeable and well qualified.
    • Dominating employees may not take over the process as they do not form part of the problem solving process.
    • It reduces noise levels in an office environment since there is no group discussion.
  • Negatives/Disadvantages:

    • It is an expensive technique to use due to high administrative costs.
    • May be time consuming/complicated to analyse data received from experts.
    • Not all experts are willing/interested to give feedback/complete questionnaires.
    • Some experts might not have an in-depth knowledge of certain topics.
    • Experts' suggestions may not be considered by some employees so consensus may not be reached.

Force-Field Analysis Technique: Application and Impact

  • Application Procedure:
    • Describe the current situation/problem and the desired situation.
    • List all driving/pros and restraining/cons forces that will support and resist change.
    • Allocate a score to each force using a numerical scale, where 11 is weak and 55 is strong.
    • Weigh up the positives and negatives then decide if the project is viable.
    • Choose the force with the highest score as the solution.
    • If the project is viable, find ways to increase the forces for change.
    • Identify priorities and develop an action plan.

Brainstorming Technique: Application and Impact

  • Application Procedure:

    • State/Define the business problem clearly, so that all participants/stakeholders understand the problem.
    • Members state possible causes of the business problems.
    • Set a time limit for each brainstorming session.
    • Record/Write ideas down, where all participants can see it / Ideas may also be shared online during an E-brainstorming session.
    • Use each suggestion to inspire new thoughts/ideas.
    • Do not judge/criticise/discuss the ideas, so that many ideas could be generated as quickly as possible.
    • All members of the group randomly make suggestions.
    • The group rates ideas according to its usefulness/success/difficulty/cost to implement.
    • The group evaluates all ideas, and combines similar ones/draw up a refined list.
    • Discuss a plan of action on how to implement the best ideas.
  • Negatives/Disadvantages:

    • Fear of criticism may prevent full participation in brainstorming sessions.
    • It may lead to 'group think'/some individuals may not give their opinions.
    • Discussion may result in conflict due to differences in opinion.

Mind Mapping Technique: Impact

  • Positives/Advantages:

    • Easy to generate ideas and enhances memory.
    • Stimulates the brain and makes people focus on the links and relationships between ideas.
    • Easy to remember since the topic texts of mind maps are keywords and short phrases.
    • Helps people to focus and understand the work better.
    • Creates a deeper understanding of the work or topic.
    • Helps people to combine information from different research resources.
    • People are able to think through complex problems.
  • Negatives/Disadvantages:

    • Some people find it messy and chaotic.
    • Can become complicated as mind maps can become too big people are not able to structure keywords.
    • Requires a sound knowledge of the topic.

Nominal-Group Technique: Application and Impact

  • Application Procedure:

    • Encourage group to clearly define the problem/to improve the quality of their products due to various complaints so that all the small groups can work on the same problem.
    • The business must divide the employees into smaller groups.
    • Request each employee to silently brainstorm / generate many ideas on his/her own, on how the quality of their paint can be improved and to write it down.
    • Each employee in the small group has the opportunity to give one of his/her idea/solution with a short explanation.
    • Appoint one employee to write the ideas/solutions on a large sheet of paper / capture solutions electronically on computer for all to see.
    • Allow each employee to give a second solution until all possible solutions have been recorded.
    • Encourage employees to ask clarity seeking questions.
    • Discourage criticism of ideas/solutions as this may prevent others from giving their solutions.
    • The business must eliminate ideas that are duplicated/similar.
  • Positives/Advantages:

    • It provides time to think about the question in silence before responding.
    • Each team member/director has a chance to participate without interference from other team members.
    • Voting on the ideas is anonymous and may be more reliable/honest.
    • Everyone in the group is given an opportunity to contribute to the discussion, while avoiding the likelihood of one person dominating the group process.
    • Enables the group to generate and clarifies a large amount of ideas quickly, and democratically prioritises them.
    • It encourages participants to confront issues through constructive problem solving.
    • Strong technique for preventing conformity to group pressure.
  • Negatives/Disadvantages:

    • It minimises discussion, and thus does not allow the full development of ideas.
    • Ideas/Inputs made by members may not converge and cannot lead to the same solution(s).
    • Suggestions may not be as creative as when a group throws ideas around.
    • It is time consuming, as each member must make a presentation.
    • It is hard to implement it effectively with large groups unless very carefully planned beforehand.
    • Requires extended advance preparation, which means that it cannot be a spontaneous technique.
    • Good ideas can be voted out because its potential cannot be developed further.
    • Small groups limit participation and are pre-selected.

SCAMPER Technique: Impact

  • Positives/Advantages:

    • Encourages people to come up with new and innovative solutions.
    • The processes of re-arranging and combining different components of a business procedure allows participants to examine each step.
    • Frees the participants' minds to look in unexpected places for the answers to their business needs.
    • Can reveal where obstacles and bottlenecks occur in current practices and develop solutions to combat these barriers.
    • Forces people to think differently.
  • Negatives/Disadvantages:

    • Success depends on groups being unconventional.
    • It is time consuming and not suitable for all groups.

Forced Combination Technique: Impact

  • Positives/Advantages:
    • Allows people to think outside the box.
    • Creative and valuable business ideas can be developed.

Empty Chair Technique: Impact

  • Positives/Advantages:

    • Managers are able to get things out in the open and practice dialogues before confronting employees.
    • Justify solutions.
    • Helps a person to become more self-aware, particularly in terms of recognizing and understanding the relationship between your responses and your present situation.
    • The person has the opportunity to put his/her point across and decide to take the position of other imaginary person.
    • Helps in understanding another person's point of view.
  • Negatives/Disadvantages:

    • Limits creativity as the person makes decisions alone.
    • One person's view is applied and this may not always be the best view.