Civil Procedure II Notes

Class Actions

  • Ben-Hur Case:

    • Supreme Court ruling that diversity of citizenship in class actions is only required of the named parties.

  • Smith Case:

    • Proper representation is affirmed when the parties interested are numerous and the suit serves a common object for them all.

    • Key concepts: Numerosity, Commonality.

  • Dukes Case:

    • Class certification under FRCP 23(a)(2) is improper without a common injury that the entire class may resolve.

    • Key concept: Commonality.

Federal Rule 23

  • 23(a) Prerequisites (C.A.N.T.):

    1. Numerosity: Class members must be so numerous that joinder is impractical.

    • Supported by the Smith case.

    1. Commonality: Questions of law or fact must be common to the class.

    • Supported by Smith Case and Dukes case.

    1. Typicality: Representative’s claims or defenses must be typical of the class.

    • Supported by Ben-Hur.

    1. Adequacy of Representation: Parties must adequately protect class interests.

    • Related to Hansberry case regarding the Due Process Clause.

  • 23(b) Types of Class Actions (R.I.P.):

    • Class actions can be maintained if 23(a) requirements are satisfied along with one of the following:

    1. Risk of Harm: Risk of harm to the class or the defendant in normal actions.

    2. Injunction: Class seeks an injunction or declaratory relief.

    3. Predominating Commonality and Superiority: Common questions predominate and class action is a better mechanism for resolution.

Federal Rule 23(c)(1): Certification Order (T.AD.A):

  • (A) Time to Issue: Court must determine class certification timely.

  • (B) Defining Class and Appointing Counsel: Certification must clearly define class claims, issues, defenses, and appoint counsel.

  • (C) Altering or Amending Order: Orders can be amended before final judgment.

Federal Rule 23(c)(2): Notice

  • Notice Requirements:

    • For classes certified under 23(b)(1) or (b)(2), the court may direct appropriate notice.

    • For (b)(3) classes, best practicable notice is required, including individual notice to identifiable members. Means of notice can include:

    • United States mail, electronic means, etc.

    • Notice must state:

    1. Nature of action.

    2. Definition of certified class.

    3. Claims, issues, defenses.

    4. Right to enter appearance through attorney.

    5. Possibility of exclusion from class.

    6. Deadline for exclusion requests.

    7. Binding effects of class judgment.

Federal Rule 23(e): Settlement/Voluntary Dismissal/Compromise (N.O.I.C.E.)

  1. Notice to the Class:

    • Notice is required to all class members who would be bound.

  2. Court Approval Requirements:

    • Adequate representation of the class.

    • Negotiated at arm's length.

    • Relief must be adequate, equitable treatment of members.

  3. Filing Agreements:

    • Agreements associated with the proposal must be filed with the court.

  4. New Opportunity to Exclude:

    • Class members must be provided another chance to exclude themselves.

  5. Member Objections:

    • Members may object to court approval of the proposal; court approval needed for payment related to objection.

Federal Rule 23(f): Appeals

  • Petition for Appeal: Must be filed with circuit clerk no later than 14 days after the order or 45 days if a U.S. party is involved.

Federal Rule 23(g): Class Counsel

  • (1) The court must appoint class counsel.

  • (2) Must ensure adequate representation.

  • (3) Interim counsel may be appointed before class action certification.

  • (4) Class counsel has a duty to fairly and adequately represent the class.

CAFA

  • Enhances federal oversight of class action settlements and modifies evaluations of coupon settlements to limit excessive attorneys' fees.

  • SMJ (Subject Matter Jurisdiction):

    • Each class member must satisfy the amount in controversy.

    • Under §1367, supplemental jurisdiction applies to claims arising from a common nucleus of fact.

Exxon Case

  • If diversity jurisdiction elements are present and one named plaintiff meets the required amount-in-controversy, courts may exercise jurisdiction over other plaintiffs.

Shutts Case

  • (1) A state can exercise jurisdiction over a claim of an absent class-action plaintiff if procedural due process is met.

  • (2) Must demonstrate that the forum state has significant contact with the claims of class members.

Provisional Remedies

  • Must state a claim for which relief can be granted.

  • Types include equitable remedies (specific performances, restitution) and tools like attachment and garnishment.

Doehr Case

  • Rule: Prejudgment attachments without prior notice violate the Due Process Clause.

  • Matthews Test: (Due process test)

    1. Consider the private interest affected by the prejudgment measure.

    2. Examine the risk of erroneous deprivation and possible additional safeguards.

    3. Government’s interests, including fiscal and administrative burdens of procedural requirements.

Federal Rule 65:

  • (a) Preliminary Injunctions:

    1. Required notice to the adverse party is essential.

    2. Can consolidate the hearing with the trial on merits.

  • (b)Temporary Restraining Order:

    • Must specify facts showing immediate irreparable harm before the party can be heard; limited to 14 days and can be issued ex parte.

Alliance for the Rockies Case (S.H.I.P)

  • Preliminary Injunction Entitlement: Must show:

    1. Likelihood of success on merits.

    2. Harsh balance favors the plaintiff.

    3. Public interest supports the injunction.

    4. Irreparable harm is likely without relief.

Pleadings and Judgements Based on Pleadings

  • Pleadings Functions:

    1. Notice of claims.

    2. Statement of facts.

    3. Narrowing issues.

    4. Quick resolution of meritless claims.

Federal Rule 7: Allowed Pleadings

  • **Pleadings Allowed: **

    • Complaint, answer, court-ordered reply. Motions and other papers.

Federal Rule 8: General Rules of Pleading

  • A Short and Plain Statement: Required elements:

    1. Claim for relief must include grounds for jurisdiction.

    2. Short statement showing entitlement to relief.

    3. Demand for relief sought.

  • Defenses: Parties must state defenses in short terms, can admit or deny allegations.

Federal Rule 9: Pleading Special Matters (Leatherman)

  • Specific rules for:

    • Capacity to sue, fraud statements, special damages, etc.

Federal Rule 10: Form of Pleadings

  • Form requirements for pleadings including caption, paragraphs, and adoption by reference.

Federal Rule 11: Requirement for Veracity

  • Signature and representations to the court; there may be sanctions for violations.

Federal Rule 12: Defenses and Objections (Defendant’s Response)

  • Answer Requirements: Must respond within 21 days, including responding to claims like SMJ, PJ, improper venue, insufficient process, etc.

  • Twombly Standard: Complaint should not be dismissed unless it is absolutely clear that the plaintiff cannot prove any facts supporting their claim.

Legal Sufficiency Standards

  1. Code Requirement of Fact.

  2. Federal Rules Requirement of Notice.

  3. Twiqbal Standard: must support a plausible claim with factual allegations, ignoring conclusions of law.

Specific Case References:

  • Durning Case: Must contain a short and plain claim showing entitlement to relief.

  • Twombly Case: Enough factual material to suggest an agreement existed for antitrust cases.

  • Iqbal Case: Complaint must survive a dismissal motion if it states a plausible claim.

  • Citibank v. Swanson Case: Court must focus on whether the alleged facts support a plausible claim.

  • Leatherman Case: Short and plain statement requirement must not have a heightened standard.

Federal Rule 41: Voluntary Dismissal

  • Dismissal without order or through stipulation allowed under specific conditions.

Federal Rule 54(c): Relief to Be Granted

  • Default judgment cannot differ from what is demanded in pleadings.

Federal Rule 55: Default and Default Judgement

  • Enforcement of Defaults: If the defense has not pleaded, matters proven with an affidavit must have the clerk or court enter judgment accordingly.

Federal Rule 15: Amendments and Supplements Before Trial

  • Amendments permitted under specified conditions before trial, changes must relate back to original claims if from the same occurrence.

Erie Doctrine

  • Determines applicable law in federal courts, addressing state or federal law's applicability in cases of diversity.

Erie Case

  • Federal courts apply state substantive laws in diversity situations, abolishing federal common law principles.

York Case

  • The federal court must apply state statutory laws if a case sits under diversity jurisdiction.

Byrd Case

  • Federal policies concerning jury questions supersede state rules that restrict the relationship of judge and jury.

Hanna Case

  • If procedures differ between state and federal systems, the Federal Rules apply as long as valid and constitutional.

Gasperini Case

  • A state court's review standards for jury verdicts can be applicable to federal courts in diversity jurisdiction cases.

Shady Grove Case

  • A state law limiting class action damages cannot restrict federal rules allowing class actions under Rule 23.

DeWeerth Case

  • Binding state court rulings on federal courts when interpreting state law.

Klaxon Case

  • Federal courts applying state laws must adhere to the choice of law rules of that state.

Discovery Rules

  • Scope of Discovery (Rule 26): Relevant information can be discovered by parties.

  • Requirement of Disclosures: Three phases, several specific elements required for initial disclosures, expert disclosures, and pretrial disclosures.

  • Types of Discovery: Depositions, interrogatories, requests to admit, production of documents, etc.

Federal Rule 30: Depositions by Oral Examination

  • General discovery and identifying sources of useful information.

Federal Rule 31: Written Questions Depositions

  • Rules allow written questions for depositions under specified conditions.

Interrogatories (Rule 33)

  • Limit of 25 interrogatories, detailed answering obligations.

Document Production (Rule 34)

  • Specific procedures for producing documents and electronically stored information.

Rule 37: Sanctions for Discovery Issues

  • Motions to compel and sanctions for noncompliance can include a variety of outcomes including deeming facts established or striking pleadings.

Rule 39: Adjudication with or without Trial

  • Jury trial rights under the 7th Amendment determined by historical analysis and remedy sought.

Summary Judgment (Rule 56)

  • Standards and procedures for moving for summary judgment.

Judgment as a Matter of Law (JMOL)

  • Similar standards to summary judgment, considerations differ slightly.

Renewed Judgment as a Matter of Law (RJMOL)

  • Must make motions within 28 days post-judgment notification.

Claim Preclusion (Res Judicata)

  • Blocks relitigation if the same parties are involved in a valid final judgment case.

Issue Preclusion (Collateral Estoppel)

  • Requires a final judgment on the merits in case one, same issue was litigated, essential to case one, and due process standards met.

Appeals Overview

  • General purposes and what's typically appealable outlined along with rules governing appeals.

Final Judgment Rule and Collateral Order Doctrine

  • Defines when appeals may occur non-matters and expectations surrounding each form.

Standards of Review

  • Discusses various review levels depending on the nature of the issue before an appellate court, typically result in varying degrees of deference.

Additional Processes for Appeals

  • Cover specifics relating to mandamus, mechanics for appealing, and limitations on appellate review processes documented.

Grade Distribution Statistics

  • A+ (4%), A (6%), A- (13%), B+ (8%), B (11%), B- (26%), C+ (15%), C (9%), C- (4%), D+ (2%).

    • Sample entries show student distribution alongside final scores and counts.