Comprehensive Study Guide for Crime Prevention and Control Approaches
Overview and Socio-Economic Context of Crime in South Africa
Crime Surge (): Violent crime in South Africa reached alarming levels during this period, dominated by contact crimes.
Major Categories of Crime: * Common assault. * Assault with intent to inflict grievous bodily harm. * Aggravated robbery. * Sexual offenses. * Murder. * Attempted murder. * Common robbery.
Geographic Hotspots: Pietermaritzburg, Pretoria, and Johannesburg recorded the highest crime indexes. These cities are identified as national crime hotspots and the most affected urban areas on the African continent.
Consequences of Crime: * On Quality of Life: Financial losses, fear of victimization, restricted movement, and paranoid behavior. * On Individuals: Immediate and long-term trauma, breakdown of trust in relationships, and lasting psychological/physical consequences. * On the State: Strain on the criminal justice system, health care system, and state finances.
Definitions and Conceptual Frameworks
Crime Prevention (Lab, ): Any activity designed to reduce the actual levels of crime or the perceived threat/fear of crime.
Crime Control (Lab, ): The preservation or conservation of current levels of crime or criminal behavior. This is specifically more reactive in nature.
Historical Distinction: * Proactive Approach: Crime prevention as an attempt to eliminate crime before its initial occurrence. * Reactive Approach: Crime control occurring after the act.
South African Policy Definition (White Paper on Safety and Security, Department of Safety and Security ): Crime prevention involves activities that reduce, deter, or prevent crimes by: * Altering the environment. * Changing conditions thought to cause crime. * Providing a strong deterrent via an effective justice system.
Academic Differences: Disagreement on definitions often stems from the educational background of scholars or the training/work experience of police officers.
Historical Development of Crime Prevention
Early Era: Crime prevention was a task for individuals, victims, and families. Retribution followed the lex talionis (eye-for-an-eye) principle.
Code of Hammurabi (): Sanctioned individual and group retribution.
Roman Empire: Policing was concentrated in cities and coordinated by the military; the general public remained self-reliant for safety.
Norman England (): Established the responsibility of male citizens to police one another. Failure of one group member to act resulted in communal responsibility for sanctions.
Watch-and-Ward System: Involved men watching over cities at night, sounding alarms for threats, and the general public assisting in apprehending offenders.
Transition to Formal Policing: * Mid- (England): Appointment of magistrates known as "thief-takers," often recruited from reformed offenders to recover stolen property for pay. * : Sir Robert Peel established the Metropolitan Police in London, though the focus remained on revenge and retribution for victims.
Modern Era Perspective (): * : Re-involvement of communities as the cornerstone of prevention. * USA (): Establishment of the National Crime Prevention Institute (NCPI). * UK (): Local crime prevention panels established; Home Office Committee on Crime Prevention followed in . * France (): Prevention councils implemented at local, regional, and national levels. * South Africa (): Post-apartheid focus shifted from political violence to domestic crime prevention through the Constitution and SAPS Act ().
Crime Prevention Models and Approaches
The Social Crime Prevention Model: * Focus: A developmental approach to preventing youth crime. * Theories Integrated: Social control theory and social learning theory. * Core Premises: Socialization units (family, schools, peers, community) influence behavior sequentially. Targeted groups include the young, old, poor, and unemployed. * Programs: Parent guidance, job creation, urban cleaning, and drug/alcohol policies.
Limiting Opportunities (CPTED): * Full Name: Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design. * Strategies: Burglar proofing, CCTV, street locks, electronic cash transfers, and supervisors. Especially successful for property crimes and vandalism.
Community-Based Prevention Model: * Focus: Awareness of high risk of being caught in specific residential areas. * Methods: Neighbourhood/flat/farm watches, citizen patrols, block watches, and safe houses.
Biophysical Prevention Model: * Focus: Identification and treatment of inner biological processes (e.g., vitamin supplements, physical therapy for feelings of inferiority). * Personnel Required: Medical doctors, psychiatrists, social workers, clinical psychologists, physiotherapists, and audiologists.
Psychological Crime Prevention Model: * Focus: Psychological needs and psychic disorders originating in early childhood. * Treatments: IQ/personality tests, psychotherapy, reality therapy, behavior modification, and social casework.
Levels of Crime Prevention (Public Health Model)
Primary Crime Prevention: * Target: General population. * Goal: Preventing crime before it occurs by eliminating environmental opportunities (proactive). * Case Study: Warwick Junction Project (eThekwini/Durban): Started in . Involved herb traders market regulation. Resulted in sharp drops in violent deaths and significant job creation ( jobs). Lamented as being in decay by after funding failures.
Secondary Crime Prevention: * Target: At-risk groups (street children, youth in informal settlements). * Goal: Early identification and intervention to block potential offending.
Tertiary Crime Prevention: * Target: Offenders who have already committed crimes. * Nature: Purely reactive. Involves arrest, prosecution, and rehabilitation within the criminal justice system.
The South African National Crime Prevention Strategy (NCPS)
Launch: as a strategic policy framework.
Historical Significance: First comprehensive policy framework shifting from reactive crime control to proactive crime prevention.
The Four Pillars of NCPS: * Pillar 1: Integrated Criminal Justice: Focuses on efficiency, deterrence, and service delivery to victims. Includes the reorganization of the criminal justice process and intelligence management. * Pillar 2: Environmental Control and Design: Includes identification (ID) systems, motor vehicle regulation, and tackling white-collar corruption. * Pillar 3: Promotion of Community Values/Education: Public education programs to dissuade the buying of stolen property and school-based life skills programs. * Pillar 4: Prevention of Transnational Crimes: Coordination with regional law enforcement to stop drug/diamond smuggling, illegal immigration, and money laundering.
Priority Crimes Identified by NCPS: * Crimes involving firearms. * Organized crime (gangsterism/narcotics). * White-collar crime. * Violence against women and children. * Inter-group conflict (taxi violence). * Vehicle theft/hijacking. * Corruption in the criminal justice system.
Child Justice and Diversion in South Africa
Diversion: Routing an accused child away from formal court procedures toward restorative justice.
Child Justice Act (Sections , , and ): * Objective: To encourage accountability without a criminal record. * Criminal Capacity: Children between ages and require proof of cognitive (understanding wrongness) and conative (ability to act on understanding) capacity.
Diversion Levels: * Level One: Less serious offenses (Schedule 1). * Level Two: Serious offenses like murder (Schedules 2 and 3).
Specific Programs for Children: * "Playing Through the Forest" ( years self-development). * "Stop to Start" (Anti-substance abuse). * "Rhythm of Life" ( years self-development). * "Wake Up Call" (Anti-substance abuse). * "Saystop" (Sexual offender program).
Global and Local Statistics on Human Trafficking ()
Detected Victims Increase: increase globally from to .
Child Victims: Account for of detected victims globally; detected child victims increased by in .
Modern Slavery Statistics: * people in modern slavery worldwide ( children). * of victims are women and girls. * individuals enslaved in Sub-Saharan Africa ( of the global total).
Profitability: Sex trafficking is the second most profitable illegal industry in the US, generating over annually.
African Context: Africans of at least nationalities were trafficked to countries in . Child trafficking is more prevalent in Sub-Saharan Africa than adult trafficking.
Objectives of Punishment
Deterrence: * Individual Deterrence: Aimed at the specific offender to prevent recidivism based on a risk/reward calculation. * General Deterrence: Aimed at the public through visibility and the fear of consequences. * Three Elements of Punishment: Celerity (swiftness), Certainty, and Severity.
Incapacitation: * Collective Incapacitation: Massive application of the same sentence for the same crime type (e.g., fixed sentences for all armed robbers). * Selective Incapacitation: Separating high-risk from low-risk offenders; only high-risk offenders receive lengthier incarceration.
Rehabilitation: Turning an offender into a law-abiding citizen through education and training. Grounded in the "Nelson Mandela Rules."
Restitution / Restoration: Offenders compensating victims or communities. In South Africa, this is informed by ubuntu and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC). * Mediation Types: Victim-Offender Mediation (VOM) and Family Group Conferencing (FGC).
Retribution (Just Deserts): Punishment proportional to the gravity of the crime. Distinct from revenge: retribution is state-imposed, whereas revenge is personal/private. * Proportionality Principle: Punishment must fit the harm and the offender's blameworthiness.
Problems in the South African Correctional System
Costs: In , the annual cost of housing one offender was between and .
Total Budget: The Department of Correctional Services (DCS) budgeted approximately for incarceration.
Overcrowding Factors: * Excess of inmates over facility capacity. * High numbers of foreign nationals and pre-trial detainees. * Inmates unable to pay bail of less than .
Recidivism / Violence: The presence of the "Number Gangs" (, , and ) facilitates the smuggling of contraband and perpetuation of crime post-release.
Questions & Discussion
Social Police Concept: The South African government aims to promote "social policing" through the introduction of Community Policing Forums (CPFs), sector policing, and demilitarization.
Child Abuse Integrated Model Support: Victims of child abuse require physiological, psychological, psychiatric, and social work treatment. Discussion revolves around whether the state should finance both the victim’s and the offender’s rehabilitation.
Incarceration Efficacy: Significant debate exists regarding whether prisons serve as a deterrent. Clifford R Shaw described prisons as "houses of corruption" where inmates refine criminal techniques. Current research suggests incarceration often fails to deter future criminal behavior.
Restorative Justice Pros/Cons: Advantages include psychological healing for victims and cost-effectiveness. Disadvantages include concerns that offenders are not truly remorseful or that victims may feel secondary victimization during confrontation.