psych conformity

PSYC 360: The Social Mind—Comprehensive Review of Social Influence & Human Connection

What is Conformity?

  • Definition: A change in behavior or opinion due to real or imagined social pressure.
Major Social Motives
  1. The Need to Belong
    • Driven by:
      • Desire for social acceptance.
      • Avoidance of rejection or isolation.
  2. The Need for Understanding
    • Informative Motive:
      • Using others as a source of information to ensure our view of the world is accurate.
  3. The Biological Link
    • Research by Klucharev et al. (2009):
      • Conformity links to brain systems involved in reinforcement learning.
      • Social disagreement treated as a "prediction error," triggering the drive to align with the group.
Interactive Reflection
  • Think of a time you changed your mind just because everyone else agreed.
  • Questions:
    • Was it to be liked or to be right?

The Three Levels of Conformity

  1. Compliance
    • Character: Short-lived
    • Motivation: Gain reward or avoid punishment.
    • Key Driver: Presence of authority or social consequences.
      • Example: "I'm slowing down because there's a speed camera ahead."
  2. Identification
    • Character: Moderate stability
    • Motivation: Desire to be like a valued person or group.
    • Key Driver: Strength of the relationship or group identity.
      • Example: "I drive safely because my parents always valued traffic laws."
  3. Internalization
    • Character: Highly stable
    • Motivation: Desire to be right / Value alignment.
    • Key Driver: Private belief that the behavior is correct.
      • Example: "I drive safely because I genuinely believe it's the right thing to do."

Asch’s Line Judgments

  • The Power of the Crowd:
    • Target Line: Unanimity is key; conformity peaks when group agreement is 100%.
    • Key Finding: Even if the answer is clearly wrong, pressure to conform is immense.
    • Prestige & Prevalence:
      • Individuals more likely to follow high-status individuals (Prestige) and behaviors that appear common (Prevalence).
    • The Power of an Ally:
      • A single defector or ally significantly reduces conformity.
      • Study: Boyanowsky et al. (1981)—Conformity pressure drops with resistance from one individual.
    • Interactive Check:
      • True or False? Even an "invalid" ally (someone who clearly can't see well) can reduce your pressure to conform.
      • Answer: True!

The "Slippery Slope" of Authority

  • Milgram Study:
    • Used a shock scale with increases in small 15-volt steps, making it easier to continue towards maximum levels.
    • 450V was the maximum administered by a significant proportion of participants.
  • Why Do We Obey?
    • Perceived Expertise:
      • Obedience increases when authority is seen as an expert with legitimate status.
    • Proximity Matters:
      • Obedience decreases as authority distance increases or victim proximity increases.
    • Presence of Defectors:
      • Visibility of others resisting authority orders reduces obedience.
      • Common explanation: "I was just following orders."

The Power of the Situation

  • What is Situationism?
    • The belief that external environments and social contexts shape human behavior more than just internal personality traits.
  • Zimbardo's Work:
    • Asks how ordinary people can be led to do terrible things.
    • Suggests the "barrel" (the situation) corrupts the "apples" (the people).
  • Dual Potential:
    • The Dark Side:
      • Situations can lead individuals toward harmful behavior, obedience to cruelty, and abandonment of personal morals.
    • The Heroic Side:
      • Explores good situations that can encourage heroism, allowing ordinary people to act extraordinarily for others.
    • Interactive Discussion:
      • If given absolute power today, how might the situation change your behavior? Would you remain the same person?

Social Norms & The Bystander Effect

  • The Bystander Effect:
    • Tendency for individuals to be less likely to help in emergencies when others are present.
Key Concepts
  1. Diffusion of Responsibility:
    • With others present, perceived burden of acting is shared, leading individuals to feel less pressure to intervene.
      • Example: "Someone else will probably call for help or step in."
  2. Pluralistic Ignorance:
    • Bystanders misinterpret others' calmness as a sign that no emergency exists.
      • Example: "Maybe I'm the only one worried; no one else is moving."
Interactive Tip
  • To break the cycle in emergencies, direct a specific person by pointing, e.g., "You in the red shirt, call 911 right now!"

Countering the Majority

  • How to Change the Group:
    • A minority can influence the majority, requiring specific, disciplined tactics.
Effective Tactics
  1. Consistency:
    • Minority must maintain the same position over time.
  2. Persistence:
    • Minority must refuse to yield to social pressure, signaling confidence in their view.
Outcome
  • Internalization:
    • Unlike majority influence leading to compliance, successful minority influence often results in internalization, leading the majority to privately rethink their positions and affecting belief systems.
Reflection
  • Recall historical movements (e.g., Civil Rights, Suffrage) that began as a persistent minority and changed the world.

Shared Reality: Connecting Inner States

  • Definition of Shared Reality:
    • The experience of having common inner states—feelings, beliefs, or perceptions—with others, meeting core needs to belong and understand the world.
Levels of Shared Reality
  1. Conversation-Level:
    • Focused on specific topics and immediate inner states in interactions.
  2. Relationship-Level:
    • Ongoing shared understanding in close personal bonds.
  3. Collective-Level:
    • Shared reality within a social group or larger collective identity.
Key Concepts
  • Collective Effervescence:
    • The unified energy and connection felt in large groups like concerts or protests.
  • Insider Language:
    • Study by Templeton et al. (2025): Connections felt stronger when specific terms unique to a group are used.

Mimicry & Synchrony: The Social Glue

  • Defining Alignment:
    • Mimicry:
      • Consciously or unconsciously imitating others’ behaviors, gestures, and mannerisms.
    • Synchrony:
      • Spontaneous alignment from shared experiences, such as walking in step or synchronizing heart rates.
Hierarchical Perspective
  • Conformity is built upon the foundations of synchrony and mimicry.
Evolutionary Roots
  1. Protection:
    • Groups moving in synchrony are better coordinated against threats.
  2. Mate Selection:
    • Synchrony can signal biological compatibility and attraction.
  3. Social Facilitator:
    • Synchrony is both a product and facilitator of Shared Reality.

Synchrony in Action: Research Findings

  1. Parkinson et al. (2018):
    • Friends exhibit significantly more similar brain responses to the same video stimuli than non-friends. Neural synchrony predicts social distance.
  2. Prochazkova et al. (2022):
    • Greater electrodermal synchrony between partners during speed dating correlates to increased mutual attraction. Physiological alignment signals romantic interest.
  3. Wiltermuth & Heath (2009):
    • Participants who walked in step exhibited higher levels of trust and cooperation in economic games.
    • Key Insight: Synchrony enhances cooperation regardless of happiness—it's about connection itself.

Interactive Review: Test Your Knowledge!

  1. Which level of conformity is most resistant to change?
    • A) Compliance
    • B) Identification
    • C) Internalization
    • Correct Answer: C) Internalization
  2. What term describes misreading others' inaction as a sign that no emergency exists?
    • A) Diffusion of Responsibility
    • B) Pluralistic Ignorance
    • C) Collective Effervescence
    • Correct Answer: B) Pluralistic Ignorance
  3. In Milgram's study, shocks increased in increments of how many volts?
    • A) 5 Volts
    • B) 15 Volts
    • C) 50 Volts
    • Correct Answer: B) 15 Volts
  • Final Insight: Understanding these forces is the first step toward becoming a situational hero.