American Enlightenment


2. Society and Governance in the Northern Colonies
  • Puritan Mindset and Idealism

    • Driven by zealous faith, escaping English societal corruption, and creating a "city upon a hill" (biblical commonwealth/theocracy).

    • Northern towns were self-governing, centered around congregational churches and local schools.

    • Principle of Consent: Voting on local laws, ministers, and governors was limited to male church members.

    • Contrast with Southern Colonies: Southern governance was heavily influenced by corporate entities (e.g., Virginia Company) with veto power over local decisions.

  • Church and State Integration

    • No separation of church and state; mandatory taxes supported churches, and attendance was legally enforced.

    • Uniform religious belief was viewed as vital to maintaining social order.

  • Patriarchal System

    • Social inequality was accepted as divine order (John Winthrop).

    • Strict male household authority (over wives, children, and servants) was critical for subsistence farming.

    • Women were denied voting and ministerial rights and were penalized for expressing unorthodox religious views.

3. Salem Witch Trials (1691–1692)
  • Puritan Worldview

    • Natural events, illnesses, and disasters were seen as signs of God's judgment or demonic intervention.

    • Execution for witchcraft was common in Europe (~50,000 executions from 1400–1800) but previously rare in the American colonies.

    • Typical Victims Historically: Older, single, widowed, or economically independent women, as well as social outcasts.

  • Three Historical Theories for the Salem Hysteria

    1. Land Grab: Economic motivation to seize property from wealthy older women.

    2. Patriarchal Enforcement: Cultural effort to suppress outspoken or non-conforming women.

    3. Ergot Poisoning: Wet harvest conditions led to Ergot bacterial contamination on barley/wheat, causing ergotism (hallucinations and seizures).

  • Progression of the Trials

    • Origins (1691): Young girls experienced fits and accused Tituba (an enslaved Caribbean woman in Samuel Parris's home) and local mothers.

    • Mass Hysteria (1692): Over 150 individuals were accused. Confessing spared one's life (resulting in banishment/torture), while maintaining innocence led to execution.

    • Casualties: 14 women and 5 men were hanged; Giles Corey was pressed to death with stones for refusing to enter a plea.

    • Unique Traits: Accusations spanned all ages (including a 4-year-old child) and genders, remaining an isolated event in colonial history.

  • Aftermath and Significance

    • The governor dissolved the witch court in late 1692 and released remaining prisoners.

    • Increase Mather published Cases of Conscience Concerning Evil Spirits, warning against spectral evidence and forced confessions.

    • The trials discredited witchcraft prosecutions and encouraged a shift toward scientific explanations for natural phenomena.

4. The American Enlightenment
  • Intellectual Shift

    • Represented a surge in scientific questioning rather than a decline in religious belief.

    • Historical Metronome Pattern: American history repeatedly swings between periods of religious extremism and scientific inquiry.

    • Core Principle: Education and science are not inherently opposed to religion; historically, science was viewed as revealing divine order.

  • European Roots and European Thinkers

    • Key scientists: Copernicus (heliocentric model), Galileo, and Isaac Newton.

    • Key philosophers: Francis Bacon, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Immanuel Kant, and Adam Smith.

  • Benjamin Franklin

    • Prominent printer, scientist, inventor, and philosopher.

    • Key Contributions: Discovered positive and negative charges; invented bifocals, the lightning rod, and the Franklin stove; established the first public library; founded the University of Pennsylvania.

    • Published Poor Richard's Almanac (1732–1758), promoting practical advice and civic wisdom.

  • John Locke and Political Philosophy

    • Published Two Treatises on Government (1690), challenging the divine right of kings.

    • Social Contract Theory:

    1. All individuals possess natural rights (life, liberty, and property).

    2. Governments are formed specifically to protect those rights.

    3. Citizens retain the right to change or overthrow a government that fails to protect their natural rights.

    • Deeply influenced Thomas Jefferson and the Founding Fathers.

5. Religious Transformations and the First Great Awakening
  • Religious Evolution in the 1700s

    • Deism: Belief in God as a creator whose plan is discovered through nature and science rather than scripture (held by many Founding Fathers, including Franklin).

    • Decline in Traditional Membership: Geographical expansion reduced church attendance enforceability, dropping membership to 10–15% in northern colonies by the 1730s.

    • Rise of Evangelicalism: Growth of Methodists, Baptists, and Presbyterians emphasizing personal, emotional faith over formal clergy training.

  • The First Great Awakening (1730s–1740s)

    • A major revival of religious enthusiasm driven by traveling (itinerant) preachers.

    • George Whitefield: Anglican revivalist who preached emotional outdoor sermons to crowds up to 8,000 people using repeaters on podiums.

    • Jonathan Edwards: Prominent preacher known for fire-and-brimstone sermons, including Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.

  • Four Major Impacts of the Great Awakening

    1. Fragmentation of Established Churches: Split congregations into "Old Lights" (traditionalists) and "New Lights" (revivalists).

    2. Growth of New Denominations: Rapid expansion of evangelical churches.

    3. Democratization of Religion: Empowered ordinary individuals to read and interpret scripture independently.

    4. Shared Colonial Identity: Created a unifying experience across all 13 colonies, fostering a shared American consciousness distinct from Europe.