American Enlightenment
2. Society and Governance in the Northern Colonies
Puritan Mindset and Idealism
Driven by zealous faith, escaping English societal corruption, and creating a "city upon a hill" (biblical commonwealth/theocracy).
Northern towns were self-governing, centered around congregational churches and local schools.
Principle of Consent: Voting on local laws, ministers, and governors was limited to male church members.
Contrast with Southern Colonies: Southern governance was heavily influenced by corporate entities (e.g., Virginia Company) with veto power over local decisions.
Church and State Integration
No separation of church and state; mandatory taxes supported churches, and attendance was legally enforced.
Uniform religious belief was viewed as vital to maintaining social order.
Patriarchal System
Social inequality was accepted as divine order (John Winthrop).
Strict male household authority (over wives, children, and servants) was critical for subsistence farming.
Women were denied voting and ministerial rights and were penalized for expressing unorthodox religious views.
3. Salem Witch Trials (1691–1692)
Puritan Worldview
Natural events, illnesses, and disasters were seen as signs of God's judgment or demonic intervention.
Execution for witchcraft was common in Europe (~50,000 executions from 1400–1800) but previously rare in the American colonies.
Typical Victims Historically: Older, single, widowed, or economically independent women, as well as social outcasts.
Three Historical Theories for the Salem Hysteria
Land Grab: Economic motivation to seize property from wealthy older women.
Patriarchal Enforcement: Cultural effort to suppress outspoken or non-conforming women.
Ergot Poisoning: Wet harvest conditions led to Ergot bacterial contamination on barley/wheat, causing ergotism (hallucinations and seizures).
Progression of the Trials
Origins (1691): Young girls experienced fits and accused Tituba (an enslaved Caribbean woman in Samuel Parris's home) and local mothers.
Mass Hysteria (1692): Over 150 individuals were accused. Confessing spared one's life (resulting in banishment/torture), while maintaining innocence led to execution.
Casualties: 14 women and 5 men were hanged; Giles Corey was pressed to death with stones for refusing to enter a plea.
Unique Traits: Accusations spanned all ages (including a 4-year-old child) and genders, remaining an isolated event in colonial history.
Aftermath and Significance
The governor dissolved the witch court in late 1692 and released remaining prisoners.
Increase Mather published Cases of Conscience Concerning Evil Spirits, warning against spectral evidence and forced confessions.
The trials discredited witchcraft prosecutions and encouraged a shift toward scientific explanations for natural phenomena.
4. The American Enlightenment
Intellectual Shift
Represented a surge in scientific questioning rather than a decline in religious belief.
Historical Metronome Pattern: American history repeatedly swings between periods of religious extremism and scientific inquiry.
Core Principle: Education and science are not inherently opposed to religion; historically, science was viewed as revealing divine order.
European Roots and European Thinkers
Key scientists: Copernicus (heliocentric model), Galileo, and Isaac Newton.
Key philosophers: Francis Bacon, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Immanuel Kant, and Adam Smith.
Benjamin Franklin
Prominent printer, scientist, inventor, and philosopher.
Key Contributions: Discovered positive and negative charges; invented bifocals, the lightning rod, and the Franklin stove; established the first public library; founded the University of Pennsylvania.
Published Poor Richard's Almanac (1732–1758), promoting practical advice and civic wisdom.
John Locke and Political Philosophy
Published Two Treatises on Government (1690), challenging the divine right of kings.
Social Contract Theory:
All individuals possess natural rights (life, liberty, and property).
Governments are formed specifically to protect those rights.
Citizens retain the right to change or overthrow a government that fails to protect their natural rights.
Deeply influenced Thomas Jefferson and the Founding Fathers.
5. Religious Transformations and the First Great Awakening
Religious Evolution in the 1700s
Deism: Belief in God as a creator whose plan is discovered through nature and science rather than scripture (held by many Founding Fathers, including Franklin).
Decline in Traditional Membership: Geographical expansion reduced church attendance enforceability, dropping membership to 10–15% in northern colonies by the 1730s.
Rise of Evangelicalism: Growth of Methodists, Baptists, and Presbyterians emphasizing personal, emotional faith over formal clergy training.
The First Great Awakening (1730s–1740s)
A major revival of religious enthusiasm driven by traveling (itinerant) preachers.
George Whitefield: Anglican revivalist who preached emotional outdoor sermons to crowds up to 8,000 people using repeaters on podiums.
Jonathan Edwards: Prominent preacher known for fire-and-brimstone sermons, including Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.
Four Major Impacts of the Great Awakening
Fragmentation of Established Churches: Split congregations into "Old Lights" (traditionalists) and "New Lights" (revivalists).
Growth of New Denominations: Rapid expansion of evangelical churches.
Democratization of Religion: Empowered ordinary individuals to read and interpret scripture independently.
Shared Colonial Identity: Created a unifying experience across all 13 colonies, fostering a shared American consciousness distinct from Europe.