knowt logo

Responses to the USA's withdrawal from Afghanistan (2021)

The US’s withdrawal from Afghanistan was begun by President Trump, and completed by President Joe Biden on 30th August 2021, ending the longest war in US history. A few months prior to this, NATO troops withdrew to initiate the process.


Actors:

  • USA: The primary state actor involved in the Afghan war, as well as the actor that withdrew, allowing the Taliban to retake Afghanistan

  • Taliban: A violent Islamist non-state actor that rose in Afghanistan, and currently has de facto rule over the state

  • Afghanistan: A state actor, that is now ruled by the Taliban, faced 20 years of war and terrorist activity

  • NATO: A Western alliance that had consisted of the coalition troops in the Middle East, they withdrew from Afghanistan before the US to initiate the process


Timeline:

  • February 2020 - Trump’s administration negotiates the US-Taliban deal, agreeing on a drawdown of US troops in Afghanistan and guarantees from the Taliban that the state will not be used for terrorist activities

  • April 2021 - President Biden decides that all US troops will be withdrawn by 11th September 2021, the 20th anniversary of 9/11, all NATO troops will also leave

  • 15th August 2021 - The Taliban capture Kabul as part of a rapid advance, capturing all but two Afghan provincial capitals

  • 30th August 2021 - The last US military forces leave Afghanistan, leaving it under Taliban rule


Responses:

The USA:

  • The USA has achieved its initial goal of ensuring Afghanistan isn’t a haven for al-Qaeda

  • US has lost a 20-year war, as they never turned Afghanistan into a successful democracy, and the Taliban still took power

Afghanistan:

  • Loss of human rights, particularly for women and children who are most affected

  • Protests against the Taliban by women, turned violent and broken apart

  • Increase in refugees and asylum seekers emigrating from Afghanistan

The Taliban:

  • Now controls the large majority of Afghanistan, with no immediate opposition

  • Abuse of power as population is censored and human rights violated, as many laws and policies return from before the war

  • Uncertain as to whether terrorism will rise or stay fallen

The World:

  • China and Russia => provides them the opportunity to economically support the Taliban, gaining influence and power globally

  • Neighbours => taken on around 2.2 million displaced peoples, however they have now closed borders

  • Pakistan => Faced threats from the TTP, and has now had to call for the deportation of Afghan refugees

Responses to the USA's withdrawal from Afghanistan (2021)

The US’s withdrawal from Afghanistan was begun by President Trump, and completed by President Joe Biden on 30th August 2021, ending the longest war in US history. A few months prior to this, NATO troops withdrew to initiate the process.


Actors:

  • USA: The primary state actor involved in the Afghan war, as well as the actor that withdrew, allowing the Taliban to retake Afghanistan

  • Taliban: A violent Islamist non-state actor that rose in Afghanistan, and currently has de facto rule over the state

  • Afghanistan: A state actor, that is now ruled by the Taliban, faced 20 years of war and terrorist activity

  • NATO: A Western alliance that had consisted of the coalition troops in the Middle East, they withdrew from Afghanistan before the US to initiate the process


Timeline:

  • February 2020 - Trump’s administration negotiates the US-Taliban deal, agreeing on a drawdown of US troops in Afghanistan and guarantees from the Taliban that the state will not be used for terrorist activities

  • April 2021 - President Biden decides that all US troops will be withdrawn by 11th September 2021, the 20th anniversary of 9/11, all NATO troops will also leave

  • 15th August 2021 - The Taliban capture Kabul as part of a rapid advance, capturing all but two Afghan provincial capitals

  • 30th August 2021 - The last US military forces leave Afghanistan, leaving it under Taliban rule


Responses:

The USA:

  • The USA has achieved its initial goal of ensuring Afghanistan isn’t a haven for al-Qaeda

  • US has lost a 20-year war, as they never turned Afghanistan into a successful democracy, and the Taliban still took power

Afghanistan:

  • Loss of human rights, particularly for women and children who are most affected

  • Protests against the Taliban by women, turned violent and broken apart

  • Increase in refugees and asylum seekers emigrating from Afghanistan

The Taliban:

  • Now controls the large majority of Afghanistan, with no immediate opposition

  • Abuse of power as population is censored and human rights violated, as many laws and policies return from before the war

  • Uncertain as to whether terrorism will rise or stay fallen

The World:

  • China and Russia => provides them the opportunity to economically support the Taliban, gaining influence and power globally

  • Neighbours => taken on around 2.2 million displaced peoples, however they have now closed borders

  • Pakistan => Faced threats from the TTP, and has now had to call for the deportation of Afghan refugees

robot