Study Notes on National Security State and Globalization pt2 (PS365)

CHAPTER 1 A&N

Introduction to Globalization and National Security

  • Definition of Globalization: Broad understanding that encompasses the expansion of a multitude of socio-economic and socio-political activities on a transnational scale.

  • Theoretical Frameworks: Various theoretical arguments are categorized as globalization hypotheses, indicating that a distinct transnational economic, political, or social process drives changes in national and international security.

  • Focus of the Chapter: Examination of the globalization-alters/kills-the-national-security-state argument by detailing common hypotheses linking global processes to security pursuits.

Varieties of the Globalization Thesis

  • Overview: Different approaches to globalization and security exist in literature, indicating unique global processes impacting state changes.

  • Identification of Seven Types of Arguments:

    1. Hard Economic Globalization: Assumes the global economy's expansion has rendered the state obsolete for managing the economy and securing national interests.

    2. Soft Economic Globalization: Suggests that growth has incrementally altered state functions, with significant changes possible in the longer term.

    3. Commercial Liberalism: Posits that increased global trade makes states less likely to resort to force against economic partners.

    4. Democratic Peace Theory: Argues that the spread of democratic norms reduces the likelihood of conflict among democracies.

    5. Global Norms Approach: Believes that political norms, particularly human rights, limit states' ability to pursue certain national security policies.

    6. Global Culture Approach: Suggests cultural convergence and the weakening of national identities stabilize international relations.

    7. Postmodern Warfare: Asserts that globalization has transformed warfare, complicating states’ ability to provide security effectively.

Composite Nature of Globalization Arguments
  • Diversity and Competing Views: Recognition of the variations and debates in the literature concerning globalization's impact on national security.

  • Core Propositions: Similar to the theories in international relations about realism and liberalism, globalization theories form a composite body of ideas regarding security.

  • Martin Shaw Perspective: Globalization viewed as a process influencing all aspects of state functions, leading to a decline in territorial significance.

Hard Economic Globalization Theorists

  • Arguments:

    • Market systems colonizing social spaces; territorial boundaries becoming less significant.

    • The erosion of state power with globalization leading firms to escape national regulations and restrain states from shielding citizens from global shocks.

  • Susan Strange’s View: Transition from states as masters of markets to being subordinate to market forces; highlights the end of geography's relevance in power dynamics.

  • Gilpin's Summary: The flow of trade and technology has irrevocably transformed global political, economic, and social activities.

  • National Loyalty Decline: The state's ability to foster loyalty among citizens is diminishing; reliance on war for national identity is declining.

  • New Security Threats: States struggling with modern transnational security challenges like organized crime and pandemics, while traditional warfare declines.

Soft Globalization Theorists

  • Argument for Incremental Change: While acknowledging deep changes, soft theorists maintain that states still have a vital role, adapting to new pressures without becoming obsolete.

  • Jonathan Kirshner's View: States face economic, political, and security challenges that require new solutions, including embracing nonstate actors and international institutions.

  • Non-Military Focus: The Canadian focus shifting from military solutions to economic stability and cooperation in global issues.

Commercial Liberalism
  • Trade and Interdependence: Free trade induces states to avoid conflict due to economic costs associated with military action.

  • Effects of Globalization: Global corporations play a pivotal role, often leading states to avoid military confrontation to maintain economic relationships.

Democratic Peace Theory
  • Democracies and War: Democratization leads to a preference for non-violent dispute resolution, given the democratic norms of tolerance and compromise.

Normative School of Thought
  • Emergence of Global Norms: Norms affecting state behavior and military actions, particularly against territorial invasions and other outdated forms of warfare.

  • Mark Zacher's Contribution: Highlights that norms around territorial integrity inhibit states from altering borders through force.

Global Civil Society and Culture
  • Cultural Unity: Growth of a global civil society, transcending traditional boundaries, fostering more peaceful international relationships due to shared values and concerns.

Global Terrorism Post-September 11
  • Nature of Threats: The emergence of transnational terrorism illustrates globalization's dual role as both a facilitator of organization and a challenge to state security,

  • Impact of Globalization on Security: The increasing complexity of security in a globalized world where threats can arise independently of borders.

Key Propositions from Globalization Theories

Global-Level Propositions (PG)
  1. PG1: Decline of Interstate Conflict

    • Decrease in interstate armed clashes due to global economic interdependence and democratic norms.

  2. PG2: Reduction in Defense Spending and Military Manpower

    • Statistically, as warfare becomes less frequent, military forces and expenditures will diminish.

  3. PG3: Role of Multilateral Institutions

    • Growth of regional/global institutions as central actors in security, responding to transnational threats.

  4. PG4: Increase in Global Terrorism

    • The arrival of a more sophisticated and widespread terrorism that calls for coordinated, transnational countermeasures.

State-Level Propositions (PS)
  1. PS1: Shift in Warfare Nature

    • Change from traditional interstate wars toward civil or ethnic conflicts; introductory quote from Klare.

  2. PS2: Focus on Counterterrorism

    • Adaptation of national security sectors to these new, non-state threat realities emphasizing counterterrorism measures.

  3. PS3: Inclusion of NonDefense Areas

    • Expansion of national security concerns into trade, environment, and public health due to global threats.

  4. PS4: Abandon Offensive Military Doctrines

    • Shift towards defensive strategies as traditional interstate wars decline in frequency.

  5. PS5: Preference for Soft Balancing

    • Nations opting for non-military strategies to manage relations with powerful adversaries.

  6. PS6: Decline in Military Size and Conscription

    • Anticipated reductions in traditional military structures with fewer conscription policies.

  7. PS7: Decrease in Defense Spending

    • Economic rationalization leading to lower military budgets amidst fewer large-scale threats.

  8. PS8: Transition to Policing

    • A move from conventional military roles to internal policing and crime-fighting duties.

  9. PS9: Privatization of Security

    • Increasing reliance on nonstate actors and private entities to fulfill security needs.

  10. PS10: Regional Security Institutions

    • States seeking security through regional partnerships and communal political entities as opposed to national frameworks alone.

Conclusion and Future Directions

  • The chapter concludes by presenting a roadmap for examining the validity of these propositions in the context of globalization's impact on security. Subsequent analyses will draw on macro-level changes and specific state-level frameworks to evaluate the ongoing evolution of national security protocols in the face of globalization challenges.