Aggression in Sport Lecture Notes
Examples of Aggression in Contemporary Sport
NBA Pistons–Pacers Brawl: A notable incident cited as an example of modern sports aggression.
NHL Todd Bertuzzi and Steve Moore: NHL player Todd Bertuzzi delivered a blindsided punch that broke the vertebra of competitor Steve Moore.
Youth Coaching: A local youth ice hockey coach was reported to have conducted a drill where players specifically practiced fighting.
Collegiate Soccer: A female college soccer player directed several aggressive acts toward opponents from BYU, including kicking, punching, and tripping. These actions culminated in her pulling an opponent to the turf by her ponytail.
Defining Aggression and Specific Criteria
Formal Definition: Calculated by Baron & Richardson (1994) as – – “any form of behavior directed toward the goal of harming or injuring another living being who is motivated to avoid such treatment.”
Four Essential Criteria for Aggression: * Aggression is a behavior (it is an action, not just a feeling or thought). * Aggression involves intent (the harm must be purposeful). * Aggression involves harm or injury, which can be either physical or psychological in nature. * Aggression is directed toward a living organism that is motivated to avoid that harm.
Principal Types of Aggression
Hostile or Reactive Aggression: The primary goal of the individual is to inflict injury or psychological harm on another person.
Instrumental Aggression: This form of aggression occurs in the quest of some nonaggressive goal (e.g., to gain a tactical advantage or win a game).
Relationship Between Types: It is considered too simplistic to view instrumental and hostile/reactive aggression as a simple dichotomy or opposite ends of a single continuum. * The clear majority of instrumental aggressive acts occur in conjunction with some type of hostile process. * At times, an aggressive act might involve elements of both hostile and instrumental aggression.
Analysis of Aggressive vs. Nonaggressive Scenarios
Scenario 1: A football safety delivers an extremely vicious but legal hit to a wide receiver and later indicates he wanted to punish the receiver to make him think twice about coming across the middle again. * Classification: Aggressive. * Reasoning: The intent was to inflict harm.
Scenario 2: A football safety delivers an extremely vicious and illegal hit to a wide receiver. * Classification: Nonaggressive. * Reasoning: In the context provided (implied by contrast to scenario 1), there was no mention of intent to inflict harm; the act itself being illegal does not inherently meet the definition without intent.
Scenario 3: A basketball coach breaks a chair in protesting a disputed call. * Classification: Nonaggressive. * Reasoning: The act was not directed at a living being.
Scenario 4: Marcia, a field hockey midfielder, uses her stick to purposely hit her opponent in the shin in retaliation for her opponent doing the same thing to her. * Classification: Aggressive. * Reasoning: The intent was to inflict harm.
Scenario 5: A race car driver kills a fellow competitor by running into the competitor’s stalled car coming out of a turn. * Classification: Nonaggressive. * Reasoning: There was no intent to do harm; it was an accidental outcome of a sports incident.
Scenario 6: Coach Sullivan calls a time-out to make a field-goal kicker on the opposing team worry and think about negative ramifications of a game-winning kick. * Classification: Aggressive. * Reasoning: The intent was to inflict psychological harm.
Scenario 7: Barry falsely tells Liam that Coach Hall will replace him in the lineup if he does not putt better, knowing Liam is sensitive about his putting pressure. * Classification: Aggressive. * Reasoning: The intent was to inflict psychological harm.
Scenario 8: Meriel beans Lyla with a fastball that got away from her. * Classification: Nonaggressive. * Reasoning: There was no intent to harm.
Major Theories on the Causes of Aggression
Instinct Theory: * Proposes that people have an innate instinct to be aggressive, which builds up until it must be expressed through direct action or catharsis. * Status: There is no support for this theory.
Frustration-Aggression Theory: * Suggests aggression is the direct result of frustration caused by goal blockage or failure. * Status: There is no support for this hypothesis; it is generally dismissed today.
Social Learning Theory: * Suggests aggression is learned through observing others (modeling) and having similar behavior reinforced. * Status: There is support for this theory.
Revised Frustration-Aggression Theory: * Combines elements of frustration–aggression theory with social learning theory. * Frustration does not automatically lead to aggression; instead, it increases the likelihood of aggression by increasing arousal, anger, and other negative thoughts/emotions. * Increased arousal and anger only result in aggression when socially learned cues suggest that aggression is appropriate in that specific situation. * Status: There is considerable support for this theory.
General Aggression Model: * Aggression occurs as a result of a complex process mediated by thoughts, feelings, and emotions, resulting from the interaction of personal and situational factors. * Status: There is support for this model.
Spectator Dynamics and Violence
Seven Categories of Spectator Violence: 1. Assault 2. Fighting 3. Verbal abuse 4. Pitch or field invasion 5. Discharge of a missile (throwing objects onto the field) 6. Vandalism 7. Terrorism
Explanatory Factors: No single factor explains fan/crowd violence. However, spectator aggression is associated with: * Younger, disadvantaged male spectators. * Losing, particularly when fans have high team identification. * Rivalries, especially those involving violent-oriented titles and logos. * Small-scale, on-the-field aggressive acts by players. * Personal variables like aroused conditions. * Alcohol use. * Crowded conditions combined with high team identification. * Fan enjoyment and affirmation of social identity (in some cases).
Verbal, Peer, and Leadership Aggression
Verbal Aggression and Abusive Leadership: Abusive coaching has negative effects on the behaviors of players.
Prevalence: According to the U.S. Center for Safe Sport, coaches are abusive to in NCAA athletes.
Peer Aggression: Peer-to-peer physical harm occurs frequently in sports and requires further study.
Moral and Cognitive Aspects of Aggression
Bracketed Morality: Many athletes view aggression as inappropriate in general society but appropriate within the sport environment.
Moral Disengagement: Athletes justify aggressive acts by displacing responsibility to others (such as officials) or by cognitively restructuring the violent action so it is not viewed as immoral. This mechanism explains why individuals commit aggressive acts even when they know the acts are wrong.
Impact on Athletic Injuries
Evidence shows a strong relationship between aggressive play and injuries: * of injuries in junior hockey players resulted from opponents' aggressive acts. * of all injuries were penalty-related, many involving acts like tripping. * of spinal cord injuries in Canadian hockey players aged to years resulted from checking from behind (a form of aggression).
Physical and Neural Bases of Aggressive Behavior
Ambient Temperature: Aggression increases as temperature increases, as athletes become more irritable.
Executive Function: Lower executive function scores are associated with increased aggression in male athletes.
Neural Basis: This association is likely due to prefrontal lobe deficits, which create impulse control problems and difficulties anticipating the consequences of aggressive behavior.
Performance and Atmospheric Factors
Athletic Performance: No clear pattern has been found between aggression and performance levels. Professionals must decide if they value potentially enhanced performance over the cost of increased aggression.
Team Moral Atmosphere: Team norms, along with coach and peer influences, create a moral atmosphere that dictates aggressive behavior. Coaches and teammates are essential in establishing these norms.
Determinants of Sport-Specific Aggression
Athletes are more likely to be aggressive if:
Someone has committed aggression against them first.
The opposition has annoyed them.
The teams compete with each other frequently.
They are highly ego-oriented and possess a low level of moral development.
They want to demonstrate their toughness.
They perceive aggression as part of their specific role on the team.
They feel pressure from the group to be aggressive.
Gender and Cultural Differences
Gender: Males exhibit higher frequencies of aggression compared to females.
Culture: Aggression levels in Chinese athletes and Western populations are very similar. However, Chinese athletes ruminate more about aggression, suggesting members of collectivist cultures are less likely to accept aggression as a tool for goal achievement.
Alcohol-Related Aggression
Athletes report higher rates of alcohol-related aggression and antisocial behavior than nonathletes.
Curbing the Issue: Best practices include discussing the negative effects of excessive drinking on performance and modifying the athletes' social environment.
Professional Practice and Control Strategies
Identifying High-Risk Situations: Aggression is most likely when people are frustrated and aroused, which occurs when: * Losing by a large margin. * Losing to an opponent they feel they are outplaying. * Perceiving unfair officiating. * Feeling embarrassed or in physical pain. * Playing below their capabilities.
Intervention and Training: * Provide stress or emotion management training. * Distinguish between aggression and assertive/intense play. * Teach nonviolent conflict resolution and empathy. * Reinforce that aggression is not legitimate.
Controlling Spectators: * Implement strict alcohol control policies. * Immediately penalize spectators for aggressive acts.
Leadership and Media: * Hire officials who do not tolerate aggression. * Explicitly inform coaches that aggression is intolerable. * Collaborate with media to avoid the glorification of aggressive acts. * Keep winning in proper perspective.