Striving For Equality
White Middle-Class Reform and Assimilation Pressures
Progressive Era Hostility and Indifference Towards Minorities:
The Progressive Era was not actually progressive for non-white people and immigrants living in the United States.
Most progressive reformers were white, Anglo-Saxon, and Protestant.
Reformers either completely ignored or were openly mean to racial, ethnic, and religious minorities.
Their main goal was to build a standard American society by making everyone follow white, middle-class ways of life, rules, and values.
The Americanization Movement and Settlement Houses:
Community groups, settlement houses, and the Americanization movement were the main ways progressives tried to make immigrants fit in.
While these programs taught immigrants English, their main goal went far beyond teaching the language.
These programs tried to force immigrants to change their daily habits, their home life, and their political ideas.
Reformers told immigrants how to dress like white, middle-class Americans.
Immigrants were pushed to give up their native foods, cultural habits, and religious traditions and replace them with Protestant values and practices.
Progressive reformers believed that making immigrants completely fit into American society was needed to turn them into loyal, good citizens.
Immigrant Culture, Alcohol Use, and the Temperance Movement:
Progressive reformers were very worried about how immigrants used alcohol.
In many European cultures, drinking wine or beer with family meals was a normal daily tradition.
Progressive reformers thought these drinking habits showed bad character and poor choices.
Because of this, bad feelings against immigrants helped drive the movement to ban alcohol (the temperance movement).
Scientific Racism and Systemic Segregation
Pervasive Racial Prejudice and Misguided Theories:
Progressive reformers usually held the same unfair views against non-white people as most white Americans at the time.
They believed that certain groups of people were naturally better and more fit to lead society.
Reformers accepted wrong scientific ideas claiming dark-skinned people were less smart than white people.
In the late 1800s, Southern progressives used these wrong ideas to justify passing laws that took away voting rights from African Americans.
Southern Progressives and Moderate Opposition to Anti-Black Violence:
Some Southern progressive leaders wanted to stop extreme violence, terrorism, and lynchings against African Americans.
However, these same reformers openly refused to support equal rights or civil rights.
Edgar Gardner Murphy, a church leader and major progressive in Alabama, explained this view by saying that an African American:
"will accept in the white man's country the place assigned him by the white man, not by stress of rivalry, but by genial cooperation with the white man's interests."
Legalization and Expansion of Systemic Segregation:
In 1896, the United States Supreme Court made a major ruling in , which said Jim Crow segregation laws were legal.
After this ruling, states in both the North and the South passed widespread laws keeping races apart.
By 1910, racial segregation was normal all across the country.
Starting after 1914, federal government offices in Washington, D.C. were officially segregated under rules approved by President Woodrow Wilson, who was a progressive.
Debates on Civil Rights: Washington vs. Du Bois and Trotter
Booker T. Washington's Accommodationist Strategy (1856–1915):
Booker T. Washington was the most famous African American leader of his time.
Washington told African Americans to be patient and work slowly toward fairness.
He argued that by working hard, being patient, and earning their own money, African Americans would eventually earn the respect of white Americans and get their voting and citizenship rights.
Key Ideas of Washington's Thinking:
"The Negro must live peaceably with his white neighbors."
"The Negro must deport himself modestly depending upon the slow but sure influences that proceed from the possessions of property, intelligence, and high character for the full recognition of his political rights."
Earning money and owning property must come before getting political and civil rights.
Black Americans should put up with unfair treatment and separation while proving they are equal over time.
W. E. B. Du Bois and William Monroe Trotter's Radical Demand for Equality:
W. E. B. Du Bois (1868–1963) and William Monroe Trotter completely rejected Booker T. Washington's slow approach.
Both Du Bois and Trotter grew up in New England and went to Harvard University.
They insisted that African Americans must immediately demand all the rights given to citizens by the Constitution.
Key Ideas of Du Bois's Thinking:
"We claim for ourselves every single right that belongs to a freeborn American."
"And until we get these rights, we will never cease to protest. How shall we get them? By voting where we may vote, by persistent, unceasing agitation, by hammering at the truth, by sacrifice and work."
Black Americans must actively demand social and civil rights right now, or they will always be victims of racism.
African Americans must fight every day to get the rights promised by the U.S. Constitution.
The Niagara Movement and the Founding of the NAACP
The Niagara Movement (1905):
Du Bois and Trotter were very worried that Black men across the South were being stopped from voting.
In the summer of 1905, Du Bois, Trotter, and a group of Black leaders met to fight racial injustice.
Because no hotel on the New York side would give rooms to Black guests, the group had to meet on the Canadian side of Niagara Falls.
They named their group the Niagara Movement and spoke out strongly against going slow and giving up rights.
The group criticized Booker T. Washington for being willing to compromise basic Black rights and for focusing only on job skills.
Du Bois said that job training "can create workers, but it cannot make men."
The movement argued that smart Black students needed to learn history, literature, and philosophy so they could think for themselves.
Outbreaks of Racial Violence:
Violence against Black people was widespread in both Northern and Southern cities:
Wilmington, North Carolina (1898): White mobs attacked Black residents and killed as many as 300 people.
Atlanta, Georgia (1906): Anti-Black riots led to 100 deaths.
Springfield, Illinois (Summer 1908): A white mob tried to kill two Black prisoners in jail. When they found out the prisoners were moved to safety, the mob attacked Black neighborhoods, killing 2 people and destroying 40 homes.
Formation and Mission of the NAACP (1909):
The Springfield riot shocked white progressives, leading them to team up with leaders of the Niagara Movement.
In 1909, white reformers and Black leaders officially formed the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP).
The NAACP was built to help African Americans become:
Physically free from forced low-pay debt labor (peonage).
Mentally free from lack of schooling.
Politically free from lost voting rights.
Socially free from unfair insults.
Well-Known Founders and Leaders:
White progressives Jane Addams, Ray Stannard Baker, and Florence Kelley.
Ida B. Wells, a newspaper owner in Tennessee who put her safety at risk to write about the horrors of lynching.
W. E. B. Du Bois, who was the editor of the NAACP magazine, The Crisis.
James Weldon Johnson, a lawyer, teacher, and former representative for the U.S.
The NAACP mainly used lawsuits in court to overturn bad laws and protect rights given by the Constitution.
In the early 1900s, they focused on getting fair housing and good jobs, like teaching.
Economic Assistance and the Urban League
Urban Migration and Local Aid Networks:
In the early 1900s, many African Americans moved from Southern farms to big cities.
In response, local Black churches and clubs created job agencies and helper groups to help new arrivals settle in and find work.
Establishment of the Urban League (1911):
In 1911, more than 100 local Black job and relief groups in many cities joined together into a national group called the Urban League.
Different focus between civil rights groups:
The NAACP focused on political and social rights for middle-class African Americans through court cases.
The Urban League focused on job help and basic needs for poorer, working-class African Americans.
Services Provided by the Urban League:
Gave out clothes and schoolbooks to families.
Helped families send their children to school.
Helped factory workers and house workers find jobs.
Both the NAACP and the Urban League still help people today.
Ethnic and Religious Self-Help Organizations
Catholic and Jewish Support Systems:
Catholic Parishes: Catholic churches in Northern cities provided community help to new European immigrants. In Chicago, Polish Catholic groups were so strong the area was called "American Warsaw."
B'nai B'rith: Started in New York in 1843 to offer religious classes and money help to Jewish families.
Anti-Defamation League (ADL): Created in 1913 by B'nai B'rith to stand up against hatred toward Jewish people.
Built to protect Jewish people and others from verbal attacks, physical attacks, and unfair treatment.
Fought bad business practices in the late 1800s and early 1900s that refused to hire or serve Jewish people.
Mexican American Organizations and Mutualistas:
Partido Liberal Mexicano (PLM): Formed by Mexican Americans in Arizona to give city residents job and community help like the Urban League did.
Mutualistas: Helper groups formed by Mexican Americans in several states that provided:
Low-interest loans.
Legal advice and help in court.
Health and injury insurance to help families when workers were too sick to work.
Legal Action Against Debt Peonage: Many Mexican American workers were forced into unfair labor contracts that kept them in constant debt to landowners. In 1911, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that laws forcing this debt work were illegal.
Native American Rights, Allotment, and Citizenship
The Dawes General Allotment Act of 1887:
Divided Native American reservation land into small family farms.
Stated that any land left over could be sold to non-Native buyers.
Stopped Native Americans from selling their farm land for 25 years, promising full land ownership and U.S. citizenship after 25 years.
Aimed to force Native Americans to fit in, destroy tribal cultures, and end Native self-rule.
Terrible Land Loss: By 1932, about two-thirds of all tribal land held in 1887 had been taken over by white owners.
Native American Self-Determination and Resistance:
Carlos Montezuma: A Native American doctor from Arizona who cared for people on reservations. In 1911, Montezuma helped start the Society of American Indians, the first formal group made to stand up for Native rights and protest federal Indian rules.
Encouraged Native Americans to keep their culture alive and not depend on the government.
Mission Indian Federation: Started in 1919 by California Indians to demand civil rights, legal rules, and self-rule.
Progressive reformers who wanted Native Americans to fit in were very troubled by Native demands to keep their culture and rule themselves.
The American Indian Citizenship Act of 1924:
By the 1920s, government land division and forced fitting-in rules were seen as complete failures.
Congress passed the American Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, giving full U.S. citizenship and voting rights to all Native Americans.
The official government reason was to reward Native Americans for serving in World War I.
Supporters also hoped that giving citizenship would speed up the process of making Native Americans adopt white American habits.
Asian American Immigration and Legal Battles
Systemic Discrimination and Anti-Asian Laws:
Gentlemen's Agreement (1907): An informal deal between the United States and Japan. The U.S. promised not to pass official laws banning Japanese immigrants, and Japan promised to stop giving passports to people trying to come to the U.S.
California School Segregation: Japanese immigrant children in California were forced into separate public schools.
California Alien Land Law of 1913: Allowed only U.S. citizens to own farm land. Because federal law blocked Asian immigrants from becoming naturalized citizens, this law forced Japanese immigrants to sell their land.
Legal Way Around the Law: Japanese immigrants got around the law by buying land in the names of their children who were born in the U.S. and were citizens by birth.
This land law also hurt immigrants from China and India by stopping them from owning land.
Legal Challenge of Takao Ozawa (1922):
Takao Ozawa, a Japanese immigrant, filed a court case challenging the law that stopped Asian immigrants from becoming naturalized citizens.
In 1922, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against Ozawa, keeping the ban on naturalized citizenship for Asian immigrants.
In response to the Supreme Court ruling, a Japanese American newspaper stated:
"the slim hope that we had entertained has been shattered completely."