Chapter 6: The Practice of Policing

Prepared by Rochelle Stevenson
University of Windsor
Copyright © 2017 Nelson Education Ltd.

Learning Objectives

  • Preventive, Reactive, and Proactive Styles of Policing
      - Preventive: Intended to deter crime before it occurs.
      - Reactive: Responding to crime after it has happened.
      - Proactive: Actively gathering information to prevent crime from occurring.

  • Problems with Reactive Style of Policing
      - Discusses the limitations and critiques associated with reactive policing practices.

  • Understanding the Broken Windows Model
      - Examination of why this model gained popularity in policing strategies.

  • Differentiate between Problem-Oriented and Community Policing
      - Identifying the characteristics and goals of each approach.

  • Controversy Around Zero-Tolerance Policing
      - Analysis of criticisms of this policing strategy.

  • Intelligence-Led vs. Predictive Policing
      - Differences between these two data-driven policing techniques.

Introduction

  • Dominant Practice of Policing: Patrolling is the prevailing method utilized in policing efforts, with the following three main types:
      - Preventive Patrols: Aimed at deterring crime.
      - Reactive Patrols: Responding to crimes that have already occurred.
      - Proactive Patrols: Focused on collecting information to better understand and prevent crime.

Reactive Policing

  • Definition: Incident-based policing grounded in random patrol, rapid responses to incidents, and reactive investigative efforts.

  • Association: This approach aligns with the professional model of policing.

Characteristics of Reactive Policing
  • Patrol Officers: Deploying marked patrol cars allows officers to respond quickly to reported crimes.

  • Routine Observation: Officers conduct general surveillance to detect criminal behavior.

  • Rapid Response: Leveraging technology to facilitate quick intervention.

  • Measures of Success and Efficiency:
      - Focus on response times and arrest rates as indicators of effectiveness.

Reactive Criminal Investigations

  • Components of Investigation:
      - Preliminary Investigation: Conducted by patrol officers who gather initial information, assist victims, and make arrests if necessary.
      - Follow-Up Investigation: Handled by detectives focused on more detailed investigations, including routine, secondary, and tertiary activities.

Critiques of Reactive Policing

  • Knowledge Gap: Police often have limited understanding of local communities.

  • Fear of Crime: Reactive patrols do not alleviate public fear regarding crime.

  • Efficiency Measures: Traditional metrics may not accurately reflect police effectiveness.

  • Community Stereotyping: Reactive strategies can lead to biased enforcement practices.

Changes to Address Critiques
  • Differential Response: Adjusting responses based on the nature and severity of incidents.

  • Clearance Rate: Utilizing arrest and clearance rates as measures of efficiency in policing outcomes.

Effectiveness of Reactive Policing

  • Key Questions:
      - Does random patrol effectively deter crime?
      - Does rapid response impede criminals?
      - Are reactive investigations successful in solving crimes?

Alternative Forms of Police Patrols

Foot Patrol
  • Benefits: Increases positive interactions between officers and community members, resulting in decreased fear of crime and improved perceptions of safety.

Directed Patrol
  • Focus: Targets specific areas of elevated criminal activity.

  • Tools: Incorporates Geographic Information Systems (GIS) for resource allocation and crime mapping.

Proactive Policing

  • Focus: Centered on the gathering and analysis of information to inform strategies for crime control.

  • Components of Proactive Policing:
      - Hot Spots Patrol
      - Broken Windows Theory
      - Problem-Oriented Community Policing

Hot Spots Patrol
  • Understanding Crime Distribution: Recognizes that crime is clustered both temporally and spatially.

  • Resource Allocation: Police resources are directed to high-crime areas, known as