Results Writing Workshop: Tables, Figures, and Prose

  • Introduction to Results Writing Workshop

    • Learning Objectives:

    • Define a results section.

    • Understand when to use tables and figures.

    • Recognize characteristics of good tables or figures.

    • Define and understand the purpose of prose in scientific writing.

    • Learn how to include prose with tables and figures effectively.

    • Identify relevant information for a results section.

  • Tables and Figures in the Results Section

    • Tables and figures are crucial visual representations of data, correlations, and results. They should only contain the most relevant and conclusive information to aid audience understanding. While primarily found in the results section, figures may also appear in the abstract, introduction, and conclusion, and both tables and figures can be referenced throughout a paper.

    • Components of Tables and Figures:

    • Units: Clearly indicated.

    • Relevant Data: Only conclusive information.

    • Captions/Titles: Descriptive and informative.

    • Formats and Labels: Adhering to specific guidelines (e.g., ACS).

  • ACS Formatting for Tables

    • When formatting tables according to ACS guidelines, the following key elements must be included:

    • Title: All tables must have a bolded and capitalized title positioned above the table. It must begin with "Table" followed by its numerical order in the paper (e.g., Table 1: Title of Table). This title number serves as the reference point within the prose.

    • Column Headers: The top row of each table must contain headers for every column. These headers should explicitly include any units pertinent to the data within that column.

    • Internal Borders: The main text or data within the table should not have any internal borders.

    • Units in Text: Since units are specified in the column headers, they should generally not be repeated within the table's main text, unless a unit is unique to a specific item in the column.

    • Footnotes: If clarification for information about a table item is needed, a footnote can be added at the bottom. An asterisk (∗*) or a superscripted number within the reference cell should be used to designate the footnote.

    • External Borders: The only borders permitted in the table should be at the very top and very bottom, serving to separate the headers from the data.

    • Aesthetics: Tables should be created in Word and should not incorporate any additional colors or row shading.

    • Resource: Specific ACS formatting guidelines for tables are available on the JACS (Journal of the American Chemical Society) website.

  • ACS Formatting for Figures

    • When formatting figures, graphs, and non-graphical images in articles according to ACS guidelines, the following components are essential:

    • Graphical Figures (Graphs):

      • Axes Titles and Units: All axes must be titled clearly and include their respective units.

      • Grid Lines: No grid lines should be present within the graph area.

      • Data Utilization: The data should fill the entire allocated space of the graph.

      • Labels and Legends: Labels and legends should be located within the graph area itself.

      • Specific Labels: Data labels must be specific and accurately point to the correct data points or series.

      • Clear Legends: Legends should contain clear identification for all data presented.

    • Captions: All figures (graphs and non-graphs) must include a caption placed directly below them. Similar to tables, figures should be identified with a sequential number (e.g., "Figure 1") for easy referencing within the prose.

    • Non-Graphical Figures (Schematics, Images, Scans):

      • Labels: Important items within the image must be clearly labeled.

      • Captions: Each non-graphical figure requires a caption.

      • Example (Scans): In one example, each scan had two labels: a bottom right-hand corner marker referenced in the prose and a letter (A-R) used for discussion within the caption only.

      • Example (Schematics): Schematics should identify each part of a setup clearly, using arrows to illustrate experimental processes. Labels must be unambiguous.

    • Inappropriate Image Inclusions

      • Screenshots from Software: Never include screenshots of data visualization software (e.g., LoggerPro titration curves with data tables) in the results or appendix. These belong only in a lab notebook.

      • Raw Lab Photos: Photos of a typical lab setup may or may not be appropriate. Consider using well-edited and labeled setup photos only if a specific, non-standard component or modification is being highlighted. For normal setups, a schematic diagram is generally preferred, with lab images reserved for the notebook or appendix.

  • Prose in the Results Section

    • Prose refers to the written presentation of data without analysis. It serves to include relevant observations, equations, and important measurements obtained during the experiment, alongside tables and figures. The results section, containing the prose, is situated after the introduction and methods sections but precedes the conclusion.

    • Components of Results Prose:

    • Relevant data discussion.

    • Appropriate ordering of tables and figures.

    • Putting findings into your own words.

    • Discussing data manipulation.

    • Relevant Data, Tables, and Figures in Prose

    • Visualization: Use figures, tables, and equations as needed to visualize the data discussed in the prose.

    • Purpose of Captions vs. Prose:

      • Captions: Provide a basic, literal description of what each table or figure describes and contains. There should be no interpretation of results.

      • Prose: Discusses what the data represents. It addresses questions like: "What are the important values, trends, and relationships the audience should observe in these tables and figures?"

    • Data Presentation:

      • No Raw Data: Neither the prose nor the tables and figures should contain raw data. All data included should be manipulated or processed.

      • Combining Runs: If an experiment involves multiple runs (e.g., titrations, absorptions with different concentrations), combine the different runs within the same table or figure for easier comparison and readability. Raw data from multiple runs should remain in the lab notebook.

    • Exclusion of Methods: The results section is not the place to describe experimental methods. Methods are covered in a separate, preceding section and are outside the scope of results writing.

    • Ordering Tables and Figures

    • Organizing data effectively is crucial for guiding the audience through your findings and demonstrating how they relate to the broader context. Several strategies for ordering are possible:

      • Experimental Order: Follow the chronological sequence of the experiment as described in the methods section, presenting findings in the exact order of discovery.

      • Calculation Order: If the experimental sequence doesn't best narrate the story, use the order of your calculations to reach a final conclusion as a map for arranging tables and figures.

      • Publisher Discretion: In professional literature, publishers and editors may reorder tables and figures to optimize publication space, which can alter their presentation order in the prose.

      • Tables vs. Figures:

      • Tables: Best for presenting numerical data, showing means, or comparing specific data sets.

      • Figures: Ideal for illustrating qualitative differences and visualizing trends on graphs.

      • Setting Up the Conclusion: The most critical function of the results section is to use your data to logically set up the conclusion section. It details the experimental journey that leads to the conclusions discussed later.

    • Structure of Prose with Tables and Figures (The 'Sandwich' Approach)

    • When presenting visual data, it's recommended to "sandwich" tables and figures between prose:

      • 1. Initial Introduction: Begin with a short introduction to the table or figure, explaining how the specific data was collected or what it generally represents. This is not a methods section but a lead-in to your data.

      • 2. Table/Figure Presentation: Present the table or figure itself.

      • 3. Further Discussion: Following the visual, discuss your specific findings, important results, or trends observed within that table or figure. This explains the significance of the data presented.

      • For Equations: The introduction describes mathematical relationships. Further discussion is not necessarily needed; instead, the prose immediately following an equation must define all variables used.

      • References: Any derivations or additional information (e.g., appendices) should be referenced as needed.

    • This "introduce-present-discuss" process should continue throughout the entire results section.

    • Putting Findings into Your Own Words

    • Captions/Titles: These should offer a literal description of the content seen in the table or figure, without interpretation of the results.

    • Prose: Expands upon the caption's information, describing the important components, implications, and interpretations within the tables, figures, and equations.

    • Referencing: Always reference tables, figures, or equations using their assigned numbers (e.g., "as shown in Table 1", "Figure 2 illustrates…"). If calculations or extra data are in an appendix, reference the specific appendix within the prose.

    • What to Describe (Examples):

      • Graphs: Important points, trends, and outliers in the data.

      • Images: Visual similarities and differences between items.

      • Tables: Important trends or overall points of comparison.

    • Audience Guidance: The prose is essential for guiding the audience through your narrative, helping them understand the story you intend to convey with your data and leading them towards your conclusions.

    • Example Application (Wash Test from Literature):

      • In a study on fabric effectiveness against sneeze droplets (Activity 4), the prose introduced the reasoning for specific tests, detailed relevant methods (e.g., "two cycles of fifteen-minute washing in a machine at 6060 degrees Celsius"), and used consistent reference labels (cotton, polyester) from earlier scan images to connect visual data to results.

    • Student Example (Aspirin Purity - Activity 5):

      • When discussing aspirin purity, effective prose would:

      • Highlight percent purity differences between pure, recrystallized, and crude aspirin samples.

      • Mention the expected R∗fR*f value for pure aspirin and *acknowledge* (but not explain the reason for) any differences from the actual aspirin R∗fR*f value.

      • For spectral data, note differences in peaks and identify ideal peaks sought.

  • Equations and Calculations Used in Prose

    • Only the most important equations used to manipulate data presented in tables and figures should be included directly in the prose. Sample calculations and medial steps of derivations should be relegated to the appendix.

    • Literature Example (QACs): In a complex sequence of equations studying QAC (Quaternary Ammonium Compounds) concentrations in blood, each equation had its purpose articulated, and all variables were defined within the prose. Once defined, a variable does not need redefinition in subsequent equations.

    • Student Example (Aspirin Synthesis):

    • Inclusion in Prose: For aspirin synthesis, the chemical equation and the equation for percent yield are suitable for inclusion in the prose. Only the standard equations (without numerical values) should be included.

    • Exclusion from Prose: Most other calculation information, including the numerical values in the percent yield calculation, should remain in a dedicated calculations section or appendix. In upper-level labs, even the percent yield equation may be moved out of the prose.

    • Actual Yield: The actual yield of aspirin, being a key result, should be included in a table within the prose.

  • The 'Strainer' Analogy: Data Flow from Notebook to Prose

    • This analogy illustrates how data should be selectively presented across different sections of a lab report:

    • 1. Lab Notebook (Finest Strainer): This is the most comprehensive repository, completed during experimentation. It should contain all collected raw data, including: sample masses, exact molarities, images of setup and samples, sample volumes, and dilution calculations.

    • 2. Appendices (Medium Strainer): After initial data manipulation (calculations), some information can be moved to the appendices. This includes: properly formatted graphs of multiple runs of titrations or absorptions, fully written-out formula derivations with all steps, and sample calculations for individual data points.

    • 3. Prose (Coarsest Strainer): Only the highlights of the manipulated data should make it to the prose. This means: the most important tables, figures, and equations (with all variables defined). All other supporting information in the appendices or notebook should be referenced accordingly in the prose.

  • Critique of a Student Example Results Section

    • A student example of an aspirin synthesis and analysis lab report, covering recrystallization, TLC, melting point, IR spectroscopy, and acid-base titration, revealed several common issues:

    • Redundant or Flawed Table/Figure Inclusions (TLC Example):

    • TLC Data: Instead of including a plot of R∗fR*f values *and* an image of the TLC run, only one or the other should be chosen (e.g., a table or a single image of the run). The R∗fR*f plot is often redundant.

    • Table Content: For a TLC table, the most crucial information is purity and RfR_f values. Raw data (e.g., sample and mobile phase distances) is typically unnecessary in the results section's table.

    • Image Quality: An unlabeled figure of a TLC run is unhelpful and should be omitted. Any labels on figures should be made digitally for clarity, not handwritten.

    • Prose and Formatting Issues:

    • Point of View: The prose was written in the first person ("I", "we") instead of the required third person.

    • Vague/Unprofessional Language: The language used was often vague or unprofessional. For instance, when discussing melting point results, phrases like, "this seemed to be a pretty good match," or "pretty close" should be replaced with specific numerical differences and precise language.

    • Overly Long Introductions: The introduction to the TLC experiment was excessively long for a results section. Reasoning for experimental choices should be cut down or moved to the discussion section.

    • Incorrect Equation Placement: An equation for a calculation (e.g., Equation 2 from the example) was improperly placed in the results section. Such detailed calculations belong in the appendix or lab notebook rather than directly in the prose.

    • Missing Captions/References: Several tables and figures lacked captions or were not referenced anywhere within the prose. Every table or figure included in the results section must be referenced in the text.

  • Review and Resources

    • Results Section Purpose: The results section is dedicated to the presentation of collected data and discoveries made through experimentation. It may incorporate tables, figures, equations, and schematic diagrams.

    • Location: It is found within the body of a report, following the methods section and introduction, and preceding the conclusion.

    • Components of Tables and Figures:

    • Units

    • Relevant data

    • Captions or titles

    • Formatting and labels (ACS specific guidance available online)

    • Components of Prose:

    • Relevant data discussion

    • Order of tables and figures

    • Putting findings into your own words

    • Data manipulation discussion

    • Grading Rubrics: Two rubrics, provided at the end of the workshop handout, are used to grade the results section based on specific components discussed in this video. They are scored from "below expectations" to "distinguished" and should be used as a reference for all reports and writing activities.