Evolutionary Psychology of the Family

Evolutionary Psychology of the Family

Human Development

  • Human babies are dependent on parents for a long time.

  • Newborns can only sleep and feed.

  • They depend on caregivers for food, warmth, and safety.

  • Similar to newborn chimpanzees and other primates, but different from other mammals where offspring are more independent.

Why Primates Are Born So Young

  • Primates are born "prematurely" to safely pass through the birth canal.

  • Human babies have proportionally bigger heads.

  • Once the head passes through the vagina, the rest of the body follows l more easily.

  • If humans were born later, they would be too big for vaginal birth, risking injury or death to the mother.

Family Size and Birth Spacing

  • Other great apes wait longer between births (around 5 years), balancing with their longer lifespans.

  • Humans have shorter birth intervals (1-2 years in modern humans; 4 years in pre-modern humans) despite living longer.

  • This is partly due to co-operative breeding practices (e.g., alloparents).

  • Short birth interval results in increased pressures:

    • Lactation is highly calorific.

    • Mothers carry infants and toddlers, which is difficult with multiple young children.

    • Higher risk of still or premature birth with short inter-birth intervals.

Families: Offsetting Costs with Benefits

  • How do we offset the costs of brain development with the benefits of brain development?

Definition of Families

  • Groups of related individuals where offspring continue to live with their parents.

    • Simple family: Single female who breeds.

    • Extended family: Two or more females or pairs reproduce.

    • Male presence is not essential.

      • Matrilineal: Only females provide parental care.

      • Biparental: Both fathers and mothers contribute to raising offspring.

  • Families are not the norm in primates; humans are an exception.

  • Pair bonding is rare, and offspring migrate to other social groups.

  • It is rare for males to contribute to parental care.

Prevalence of Families

  • Families occur in <3% of species.

  • In these species, pair bonds tend to be long-lasting (monogamy).

  • Parental care is provided for extended periods of offspring development.

Life History Theory

  • A part of evolutionary theory that accounts for trade-offs within the lifespan of individual organisms.

  • To maximize reproductive success, organisms must make compromises across several variables.

  • Life-history theory explains the existence of families across the animal kingdom.

  • Predicts that the longer an organism lives (as a species), the more likely family systems will evolve.

Fast vs. Slow Life History

  • Fast life history:

    • Resource unpredictability/abundance.

    • Early onset of reproduction.

    • Dispersal and family dissolution.

  • Slow life history:

    • Delayed onset of reproduction.

    • Parental investment.

    • Retention of young and family formation.

  • Breeding conditions, offspring survival probability, and offspring age/experience influence the life history strategy.

Why Parent? Attachment Theory

  • In developmental psychology, attachment is a concept where:

    • Children seek to be with a caregiver, especially during anxiety- or fear-provoked episodes.

    • In the presence of a suitable and responsive caregiver, the child’s social and psychological development will be more successful than in the presence of an insensitive caregiver (or where no secure attachment has formed).

  • Proposed by Ainsworth and Bowlby, with evolution in mind.

  • Infants with secure attachment are more likely to grow up and successfully reproduce (Ultimate Cause).

Attachment Strategies

  • Secure strategies (low risk):

    • Favors future reproduction (delayed reproduction) and high parenting effort.

    • Can be affected by factors like genetics, prenatal/perinatal hormones, environmental effects.

  • Anxious strategies.

  • Avoidant strategies (high risk):

    • Favors current reproduction and high mating effort.

Advantages of Families

  • Even though most species do not form families, there are distinct advantages to living as a family unit.

  • Delaying reproduction and parental investment allows time for offspring to learn and develop useful skills:

    • Education.

    • Social rules.

    • Practical skills.

  • Increased survival probability means that more offspring will go on to reproduce in turn – Ultimate Cause.

Costs of Families

  • Costs to parents include:

    • Biological costs: Production of gametes (especially for females), production of milk, energy spent in other child-rearing activities.

    • Financial/Material costs: Housing, food, education.

    • Personal costs: Physically protecting offspring from danger.

    • Fitness costs: Time spent finding a suitable mate, time cannot easily be split raising different sets of offspring, risk of “investing” in raising a child that is not your own (for males).

Parenting - Fathers

  • Family members contribute in different ways:

  • Human babies require substantial investment and resources to raise, mostly by the mother.

  • Fathers contribute only ~5% to direct parental care, providing most care indirectly.

  • Human fathers contribute significantly more compared to other primate species, with modern trends pushing towards equal division of child care.

Parenting - Fathers in Chimpanzees

  • In chimpanzees, the polygynandrous mating system means males have no exclusive sexual relationships (females mate with multiple males).

  • Father-offspring recognition is non-existent in chimpanzees.

  • This leads to a diffusion of responsibility.

Evolution of Paternal Care in Humans

  • Three factors have supported the evolution of paternal care in humans:

    • Paternity certainty: Monogamous mating system increases the probability of being the father.

    • Perceived visual resemblance to the child is positively correlated with a father’s parental investment.

    • Cost of lost mating opportunities: Negative selection pressure towards casual sex for females (biological cost of pregnancy).

      • Males prefer multiple partners, committing to a single relationship means potentially lost chances for reproduction.

      • Aversion to casual sex as the norm for females creates positive selection pressure for men to contribute child care.

    • Benefits to offspring: Fathers influence offspring’s sexual maturity and adult reproductive strategies in early life.

      • Absence of father is associated with early onset of puberty in females (Ultimate Cause).

Alloparents

  • Alloparents are members of the group/family who are not the parents but contribute to the care and raising of offspring.

Benefits of Alloparental Care

  • In primate species, alloparental care increases reproductive rates (i.e., shorter interbirth interval) and faster growth of offspring (i.e., faster weaning time).

  • Alloparents also act as a failsafe should one or both parents die, otherwise offspring would most likely not survive.

Grandmothers as Alloparents

  • Humans are the only primates where females live long after menopause.

  • Grandmothers are highly significant as alloparents.

Families and Consanguinity

  • Kin Recognition

Inbreeding and Outbreeding

  • A table showing consanguineous marriage is observed in varying percentages around the world.

Kin Recognition and Avoiding Inbreeding

  • How to avoid inbreeding?

    • Kin recognition

    • Dispersal

    • Familiarity

    • Co-residence

End goals

  • Compare human development to that of other mammalian species.

  • Describe what a family is and why it would be selected for.

  • Understand attachment from an evolutionary point of view.

  • Explain how division of care in parental activities are beneficial to child survival.

Reading

  • Chapter 5 Van De Braak "Evolutionary Psychology"

  • Chapter 6 Hampton "Essential Evolutionary Psychology"