Notes on Philippine Politics and Political Science

By Whom and for Whom: Studying Philippine Politics and Political Science in the Philippines

  • Contextual Nature of Politics: Politics evolves based on social, economic, cultural, and political conditions.

  • Not a fixed concept; it comprises various ideas and practices.

  • Understanding Politics:

  • Politics as Social Reality: Involves power exercises, conflicts, and day-to-day interactions regarding justice and freedom.

  • Politics as a Discipline: Political science involves systematic studies using theories and methods to analyze society politically.

  • Importance of examining who shapes political understanding in the Philippines and for whom the analysis is done.

Studying Philippine Politics

  • Analyzing political dynamics based on a century of theories and research.

  • Philippine politics is distinct yet often compared to Western democracies.

  • Emphasis on critical examination of existing theories and exploration of new frameworks of understanding.

Dominant Approaches in Philippine Politics

  • Historical Trends:

  • Early scholars focused on government institutions (executive, legislative, judiciary) leading to the statist approach.

  • Shift to socio-cultural perspectives examining individual behaviors (Carl Lande on patronage and clientelism).

  • Patronage and Clientelism:

  • Personal relationships between political patrons and loyal clients.

  • Bossism: Local bosses controlling resources and using violence to maintain power (John Sidel).

  • Money Politics: Elections as business transactions, affecting social service provision.

  • Machine Politics: Power networks dominated by political dynasties emphasizing ongoing patronage systems.

  • Emerging perspectives challenge elite-centered views, calling for a broader understanding of political dynamics.

Emerging Perspectives on Philippine Politics

  • Contested Democracy: Democracy shaped by diverse voices and experiences relevant to the Philippines.

  • Everyday Politics: Focus on daily political experiences beyond formal institutions (Kerkvliet & Scott).

  • New theories address exploitation, class struggles, moral conflicts, and community resistance (Hutchcroft, Rivera, Kusaka).

  • Redefinition of Terms: Terms like "tulong" (help) shift perceptions beyond typical patronage frameworks.

  • Expanding narratives to include unconventional political spaces:

  • Resistance studies (media portrayals, sidewalk vendors' actions, university politics).

Beyond Existing Theories

  • Focus on Non-Elites: Shifting attention from elites to grassroots communities showcasing local experiences in political discussions.

  • Filipino political scientists strive to frame theories around local contexts.

  • Emphasis on studying politics oriented by Filipinos and for Filipinos, aligning with local realities instead of foreign frameworks.

Political Science Education in the Philippines

  • Shift from a focus on institutions towards a more dynamic understanding of political processes since 2017.

  • History includes comparative politics and international relations.

  • Curriculum updates:

  • Political Theory & Methodology: Now separate fields, previously combined.

  • Increased emphasis on political analysis, qualitative and quantitative research methods.

  • Research Findings:

  • Dominance of administrative topics in research, with public policy and social actors gaining prominence.

  • Limited research in political parties and judiciary due to perceived weaknesses.

  • Diversity in university programs reflecting faculty expertise and local demands.

Ontology, Epistemology, and Methodology in Political Science

  • Dependence of political science study on three areas: ontology (existence), epistemology (knowledge), and methodology (study approaches).

  • Predominantly qualitative methods are utilized, although mixed methods are gaining traction.

  • Increase in research reflected through mixed methods, though still primarily qualitative.

  • Challenges exist in research funding and faculty constraints, impacting the scope of studies.

Towards a Filipino Political Science

  • Proposal to transition from "Philippine political science" to "Filipino political science" to encompass the Filipino perspective and experience.

  • Focus on understanding politics through local narratives, symbols, and societal engagement.

  • Integration of Filipino language into political discussions enhances cultural relevance.

  • Examples include using terms like "pulitika" and "tulong" for a better reflection of Filipino values.

Political Science for the Filipino

  • Importance of political science serving the Filipino populace for social change and political development.

  • Role of political scientists as guides for informed political action and active citizenship.

  • Need for political science to make substantive impacts beyond academic discussions, engaging with policymakers.

Conceptualizing and Measuring Modern Democracy

  • Education and public interest in measuring democracy based on various definitions, highlighting different elements necessary for a functional democracy.

  • Definition adjustments are required to consider human quality of life improvements alongside procedural metrics.

Democracy in the Philippine Context

  • Discussion on the Philippines' classification as a democracy amidst significant governance issues, revealing underlying oligarchic traits.

  • Reassessment of the democratic status based on criteria like electoral integrity, political equality, and economic justice.

  • Perceptions of democracy among Filipinos, showing hope against a backdrop of persistent economic and societal struggles.

  • Exploration of ongoing challenges, including electoral fraud, political dynasties, institutional ineffectiveness, and conflicts, leading to a more accurate characterization of governance in the Philippines.

Conclusion: Addressing Misconceptions

  • The distinction between perceived democracy and the lived reality of Filipinos necessitates a critical approach to political analysis.

  • Call to action for recognition of real problems facing Philippine governance and mobilization towards genuine democratic practices rather than illusory claims.