Notes on Philippine Politics and Political Science
By Whom and for Whom: Studying Philippine Politics and Political Science in the Philippines
Contextual Nature of Politics: Politics evolves based on social, economic, cultural, and political conditions.
Not a fixed concept; it comprises various ideas and practices.
Understanding Politics:
Politics as Social Reality: Involves power exercises, conflicts, and day-to-day interactions regarding justice and freedom.
Politics as a Discipline: Political science involves systematic studies using theories and methods to analyze society politically.
Importance of examining who shapes political understanding in the Philippines and for whom the analysis is done.
Studying Philippine Politics
Analyzing political dynamics based on a century of theories and research.
Philippine politics is distinct yet often compared to Western democracies.
Emphasis on critical examination of existing theories and exploration of new frameworks of understanding.
Dominant Approaches in Philippine Politics
Historical Trends:
Early scholars focused on government institutions (executive, legislative, judiciary) leading to the statist approach.
Shift to socio-cultural perspectives examining individual behaviors (Carl Lande on patronage and clientelism).
Patronage and Clientelism:
Personal relationships between political patrons and loyal clients.
Bossism: Local bosses controlling resources and using violence to maintain power (John Sidel).
Money Politics: Elections as business transactions, affecting social service provision.
Machine Politics: Power networks dominated by political dynasties emphasizing ongoing patronage systems.
Emerging perspectives challenge elite-centered views, calling for a broader understanding of political dynamics.
Emerging Perspectives on Philippine Politics
Contested Democracy: Democracy shaped by diverse voices and experiences relevant to the Philippines.
Everyday Politics: Focus on daily political experiences beyond formal institutions (Kerkvliet & Scott).
New theories address exploitation, class struggles, moral conflicts, and community resistance (Hutchcroft, Rivera, Kusaka).
Redefinition of Terms: Terms like "tulong" (help) shift perceptions beyond typical patronage frameworks.
Expanding narratives to include unconventional political spaces:
Resistance studies (media portrayals, sidewalk vendors' actions, university politics).
Beyond Existing Theories
Focus on Non-Elites: Shifting attention from elites to grassroots communities showcasing local experiences in political discussions.
Filipino political scientists strive to frame theories around local contexts.
Emphasis on studying politics oriented
by Filipinos and for Filipinos, aligning with local realities instead of foreign frameworks.
Political Science Education in the Philippines
Shift from a focus on institutions towards a more dynamic understanding of political processes since 2017.
History includes comparative politics and international relations.
Curriculum updates:
Political Theory & Methodology: Now separate fields, previously combined.
Increased emphasis on political analysis, qualitative and quantitative research methods.
Research Findings:
Dominance of administrative topics in research, with public policy and social actors gaining prominence.
Limited research in political parties and judiciary due to perceived weaknesses.
Diversity in university programs reflecting faculty expertise and local demands.
Ontology, Epistemology, and Methodology in Political Science
Dependence of political science study on three areas: ontology (existence), epistemology (knowledge), and methodology (study approaches).
Predominantly qualitative methods are utilized, although mixed methods are gaining traction.
Increase in research reflected through mixed methods, though still primarily qualitative.
Challenges exist in research funding and faculty constraints, impacting the scope of studies.
Towards a Filipino Political Science
Proposal to transition from "Philippine political science" to "Filipino political science" to encompass the Filipino perspective and experience.
Focus on understanding politics through local narratives, symbols, and societal engagement.
Integration of Filipino language into political discussions enhances cultural relevance.
Examples include using terms like "pulitika" and "tulong" for a better reflection of Filipino values.
Political Science for the Filipino
Importance of political science serving the Filipino populace for social change and political development.
Role of political scientists as guides for informed political action and active citizenship.
Need for political science to make substantive impacts beyond academic discussions, engaging with policymakers.
Conceptualizing and Measuring Modern Democracy
Education and public interest in measuring democracy based on various definitions, highlighting different elements necessary for a functional democracy.
Definition adjustments are required to consider human quality of life improvements alongside procedural metrics.
Democracy in the Philippine Context
Discussion on the Philippines' classification as a democracy amidst significant governance issues, revealing underlying oligarchic traits.
Reassessment of the democratic status based on criteria like electoral integrity, political equality, and economic justice.
Perceptions of democracy among Filipinos, showing hope against a backdrop of persistent economic and societal struggles.
Exploration of ongoing challenges, including electoral fraud, political dynasties, institutional ineffectiveness, and conflicts, leading to a more accurate characterization of governance in the Philippines.
Conclusion: Addressing Misconceptions
The distinction between perceived democracy and the lived reality of Filipinos necessitates a critical approach to political analysis.
Call to action for recognition of real problems facing Philippine governance and mobilization towards genuine democratic practices rather than illusory claims.