Untitled Flashcards Set
While ESG is likely to evolve both in substance and name in the coming years, its underlying impulse is here to stay. Here’s how companies can take a more systematic and rewarding approach to ESG. by Lucy Pérez, Vivian Hunt, Hamid Samandari, Robin Nuttall, and Donatela Bellone How to make ESG real August 2022 The ‘how’ of a company’s environmental, social, and governance (ESG) proposition starts with recognizing what companies should be solving for: maintaining and reinforcing their social license to operate, in the face of rising externalities. Rising scrutiny of how companies address ESG means that a robust approach is more critical than ever, irrespective of whatever name one may choose to give to the attempt to address these externalities, whatever contours one may define for them at a given point, and whatever organizational or governance construct one may put in place for them. Indeed, we believe one may be agnostic to the term ESG but not to its underlying concerns.1 Not all aspects of “E,” “S,” and “G,” however, are priorities for all companies, and it is unrealistic to expect that companies do not have to make hard trade-offs within and among ESG dimensions, or that they can lead on every topic. It is therefore instructive to observe companies that approach ESG in a rigorous, strategy-driven, socially attuned way. We call these organizations “forward-looking companies.” They make ESG intrinsic to their strategy by defining, implementing, and refining a carefully constructed portfolio of ESG initiatives that connect to the core of what they do. Forward-looking companies also contribute to a competitive landscape where good corporate citizenship is marshaled against existential challenges, not least—but not only—climate change. When a company determines the dimensions of ESG where it wishes to be good and where it wishes to be excellent, it is making important decisions, with broader secondand third-order consequences. Forward-looking companies approach ESG decisions by seeking to gain a deep, evidence-based understanding of their own business and its broader potential effects. Since by now every major company has begun to embark on an ESG journey, and many have significant programs already under way, it is helpful to 1 These issues are addressed in detail in the accompanying article, “Does ESG really matter—and why?,” by Lucy Pérez, Vivian Hunt, Hamid Samandari, Robin Nuttall, and Krysta Biniek, McKinsey Quarterly, August 10, 2022. 2 consider ESG progress in the context of a maturity curve. The ESG practices of today’s large companies generally cluster along three levels of ambition (Exhibit 1). Being forward looking in ESG necessarily calls for considering the needs of a range of stakeholders and society more broadly. Stakeholder demands are shifting, and these shifts can over time dramatically affect competitive dynamics. Nor is the rate of change linear. As external shocks such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine have shown, companies find it hard to move rapidly unless they have an ESG framework that is derived from, and deliberately advances, their strategy. Anticipating risks and opportunities and considering what value stakeholders have at stake requires continuous, judicious analysis; ESG is a process, not an outcome (Exhibit 2). The approach of forward-looking companies is marked by four reinforcing parts of mapping, defining, embedding, and engaging. The science of ESG mapping The term “mapping” is used frequently in other competitive contexts. Mapping for ESG requires a thorough and inclusive exercise. The critical analysis is to figure out how the organization’s specific business model matches against each ESG dimension. Exhibit 1 Web 2022 HowMakesESGReal Exhibit 1 of 2 Examples and organizational mindsets are segmented across three levels of an environmental, social, and governance (ESG) practice There are three levels of ambition in ESG. Risk-mitigation and “do no harm” measures • React to trends a ecting industry and business • Address external vulnerabilities • Donate resources (nancial, in-kind, volunteer) • Meet and report baseline standards • Pledge to minimal commitment levels Substantive e orts, mostly outside the core business • Track major trends a ecting the business with contingency plans in place • Use strengths to deliver increased value across specic ESG goals and metrics • Comply with voluntary industry standards and perform above industry average • Create a comprehensive sustainability policy • Implement inclusive HR practices • Run strategic, high-impact philanthropic programs • Engage with stakeholder groups to understand what matters Full integration of ESG into strategy and operations Minimum practice Common practice ‘Next level’ practice • Leverage “superpowers” to move sector standards • Increase social impact via innovation, market, and customer choices • View ESG as a di erentiator and core to overall strategy • Link clearly articulated leadership areas (“win the game”) with purpose • Embed ESG in capital and resource allocation • Tie ESG to employee incentives and evaluations • Improve sustainability outcomes internally and externally • Ensure that ESG disclosures cover company’s full operations Risk management Impact 3 1. Considering what stakeholders have at stake Comprehensive ESG mapping attempts to take account of who the important stakeholders are and what they value. Purpose is an enabler; it is much easier for a company to operationalize ESG when it has a clearly articulated corporate purpose, moored to the business model. It will not come as a surprise that forward-looking companies actively engage with their shareholders, whose capital is at risk. To unlock opportunities for all of their stakeholders, however, these companies tend to listen to a broad range of constituencies. Employees rank highly on any list of essential stakeholders. The benefits of engaged employees include heightened loyalty and a greater willingness to recommend the company to others.2 Engaged customers are also essential. Consumers hold companies and their brands accountable for the impact of their conduct on employees, society, and the environment. Though customer preferences can vary, there are indications about what is likely to matter more for consumers in the years ahead. Our research on Generation Z (born 1995–2010) shows that young consumers are particularly mindful of ethical consumption, transparency, authenticity, and equality.3 One study found that purposedriven brands achieve more than twice the brand-value growth of brands that focus purely on profit generation.4 2. Identifying superpowers and vulnerabilities The second element of mapping is to identify a company’s superpowers and vulnerabilities. Superpowers are a company’s unique capabilities to have differential impact. 2 For example, see “More than a mission statement: How the 5Ps embed purpose to deliver value,” McKinsey Quarterly, November 5, 2020; “Purpose: Shifting from why to how,” McKinsey Quarterly, April 22, 2020; Aaron De Smet, Bonnie Dowling, Marino Mugayar-Baldocchi, and Bill Schaninger, “‘Great Attrition’ or ‘Great Attraction’? The choice is yours,” McKinsey Quarterly, September 8, 2021; Arne Gast, Nina Probst, and Bruce Simpson, “Purpose, not platitudes: A personal challenge for top executives,” McKinsey Quarterly, December 3, 2020; and Naina Dhingra and Bill Schaninger, “The search for purpose at work,” McKinsey, June 3, 2021. 3 Tracy Francis and Fernanda Hoefel, “‘True Gen’: Generation Z and its implications for companies,” McKinsey, November 12, 2018. 4 Erica Sweeney, “Study: Brands with a purpose grow 2x faster than others,” Marketing Dive, April 19, 2018. Exhibit 2 Web 2022 HowMakesESGReal Exhibit 2 of 2 Mapping Dening Embedding Engaging 1 2 4 3 • Considering what stakeholders have at stake • Identifying superpowers and vulnerabilities • Benchmarking regularly and judiciously • Considering high jumps and long jumps • Thinking systematically about ESG trade-os • Measuring and assessing • Syncing ESG with operations • Following through on initiatives to ensure impact • Discerning what the numbers do—and do not—say about ESG • Using ESG engagement to sharpen strategy • Showing investors the business proposition • Making cadence core to the dialogue ESG is a process, not an outcome. ESG journey 4 Vulnerabilities are the foundational expectations that critical stakeholders will require a company to address, in light of its specific business model. Identifying superpowers and vulnerabilities requires answering questions such as, What do we bring to society that no one else can? What are the areas of dissonance, where we need to change practices to align strategy with our societal impact? What do we do that is irreplaceable? What “home field” advantage do we have? For example, Natura &Co is a Brazilian-based manufacturer and distributor of cosmetics and other personal-care products, with significant operations in Latin America, Europe, and the Middle East. Its superpower is channeling its “home turf” of the Amazon rainforest; it can tap into its highly motivated base of stakeholders to protect biodiversity and advance global solutions to climate change. Forward-looking companies test and strengthen their ESG proposition by conducting exercises such as an “ESG teardown.” Teardowns—dismantling a product or service to learn more and to compare it with the offerings of rivals—have long been used in manufacturing. ESG teardowns analyze what a company is doing now, and why. Frequently, the exercise will surface reasons for some initiatives that include “it seemed like a good idea at the time,” or “many companies seemed to be doing something similar.” Perhaps these explanations make sense in some cases, yet it is not possible to make a distinctive contribution by merely copying others—and at all events, companies have unique superpowers and vulnerabilities. Forward-looking companies carefull