AI Planning and Preparation Peer Discussion Prompt Bank

Facilitation and Implementation Guidelines

  • Core Context and Purpose:

    • Designed for adult educator reflection, peer discussion, and non-evaluative self-assessment.

    • Formatted as a peer discussion prompt bank focused on artificial intelligence (AI) combined with lesson planning and preparation.

  • Source Generation Instructions for Knowt and Kai:

    • Use the discussion and reflection items as short-answer prompt sources.

    • Preserve the intent and wording of every prompt as closely as possible.

    • Format Preference: Prefer Short Answer format over standard multiple-choice.

    • Evaluation Status: Explicitly designated as NOT a proficiency assessment.

    • Rubric Application: Apply a broad-acceptance rubric for each item so that any relevant, good-faith response receives full credit.

    • Evaluation Constraints: Do not infer AI skill level, rank participants by expertise, or generate "gotcha" style answers.

Reflection Prompts: Routine Planning Tools and Workload Distribution

  • Question 1: Existing Planning and Preparation Tools

    • Prompt: What tools are already part of your planning and preparation routine? Name up to three.

    • Response Guidance Examples: Google Docs/Slides/Sheets, Google Classroom, Canva, ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot, Knowt, MagicSchool, Diffit, Curipod, or another tool.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant good-faith response that names one or more tools, including "none yet."

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Find one tool named by someone else that you have not tried. Ask: "What do you actually use it for?"

  • Question 2: Current Time Allocation in Planning

    • Prompt: Where does most of your planning or preparation time currently go?

    • Response Guidance Examples: Finding resources, creating lessons/materials, differentiating, assessments, slides/handouts, feedback, or organization.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant planning/preparation task or workload description.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Compare answers with a partner. Which task feels most repetitive versus most professionally important?

Reflection Prompts: AI Adoption Frequency, Applications, and Intentionality

  • Question 3: School Year AI Adoption Frequency

    • Prompt: How would you describe your use of AI for planning this school year?

    • Response Guidance Examples: Regularly, a few times, once or twice, not yet, or interested but unsure where to start.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any response describing current AI-use frequency or readiness.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: What has made AI easier—or harder—to use consistently?

  • Question 4: Specific AI Creation and Adaptation Tasks

    • Prompt: What is one thing you have actually asked an AI tool to help you create, adapt, or improve?

    • Response Guidance Examples: Lesson ideas, questions, reading levels, examples/non-examples, assessments, rubrics, discussion prompts, summaries, projects, or student-facing materials.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant example; "I have not used AI yet" is also valid.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Share one request that produced a surprisingly useful result—or one that failed.

  • Question 5: Primary Intent When Using AI

    • Prompt: Complete the sentence: "When I use AI for planning, I usually ask it to…"

    • Response Guidance: Keep the response to one sentence or phrase.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant completion, including a statement that the participant does not currently use AI.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Listen for patterns: brainstormer, creator, adapter, critic, organizer, or something else?

Reflection Prompts: Quality Evaluation and Rejection Triggers

  • Question 6: Usability Standards for AI Resources

    • Prompt: What makes an AI-generated resource useful enough for you to actually use?

    • Response Guidance Criteria: Alignment, accuracy, student fit, voice, rigor, usability, time saved, or editability.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant criterion for usefulness or trust.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Which matters more to you: speed, accuracy, alignment, or editability? Why?

  • Question 7: Factors Prompting Rejection or Heavy Revision

    • Prompt: What usually makes you reject or heavily revise an AI-generated resource?

    • Response Guidance Examples: Too generic, inaccurate, wrong difficulty, poor fit for students, wrong tone, weak formatting, or too much cleanup.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant limitation, concern, or quality issue.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: What is one quick check you use—or could use—before trusting an AI output?

Reflection Prompts: Task Delegation, Peer Learning, and Strategic Alignment

  • Question 8: Task Offloading and Boundaries of Teacher Judgment

    • Prompt: If AI could remove one planning or preparation task from your week, what would you hand off first?

    • Response Guidance: Name the task, not the tool.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant planning/preparation task.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: With a partner, separate "safe to delegate" from "teacher judgment should stay central."

  • Question 9: High-Value Collaborative Workflows

    • Prompt: What AI or digital-tool workflow would be most valuable to explore with colleagues?

    • Response Guidance Examples: Saving planning time, differentiation, stronger questions, assessment development, student engagement, project/unit planning, grounding AI in teacher materials, or checking accuracy.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant workflow, need, or area for peer learning.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Who in the room might already have something useful to share about that workflow?

  • Question 10: Peer Learning Targets and Action Steps

    • Prompt: What is one tool, strategy, or workflow someone else mentioned today that you want to see in action?

    • Response Guidance: Name the tool/workflow and, if possible, the colleague you want to learn from.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant peer-learning target.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Use responses to choose the next peer demo, mini-lab, or shared planning experiment.

  • Question 11 (Optional Closer): Integration with Strategic Frameworks

    • Prompt: Where could one of these tools make it easier to plan for Key Strategy 1 or Key Strategy 2 without adding another task to your workload?

    • Response Guidance: Focus on an existing planning task that could be strengthened, shortened, or made easier to revise.

    • Broad-Acceptance Rubric: Accept any relevant connection between a tool/workflow and Key Strategy 1 (KS1) or Key Strategy 2 (KS2) planning.

    • Peer-Discussion Follow-Up: Name one tiny experiment worth trying before the next Common Planning Time (CPT) / Professional Learning Community (PLC) conversation.