Module+7.2+-+Progressive+Political+Reforms

Module 7-2: Progressive Political Reforms

Learning Targets

  • Understand the calls for expert reliance among progressives to enhance government efficiency.

  • Analyze the preservationists and conservationists’ roles in establishing national parks, with conflicting views on government intervention in resource overuse.

  • Explore the debates on immigration restrictions among progressives.

  • Evaluate the progressive amendments to the Constitution and their alignment with progressive ideals.

Thematic Focus

  • Examine how progressive reforms shaped local activism and influenced legislation in the U.S. from the late 19th to early 20th century, highlighting connections to previous American reform movements and existing social structures.

Historical Reasoning Focus: Continuity and Change

  • Reflect on how progressivism represented a paradigm shift in American political, social, and economic practices while maintaining continuity with prior reform efforts.

Characteristics of Progressivism

  • Progressives aimed for governmental intervention without a complete overhaul of capitalism or democracy.

  • Public support emerged for key progressive politicians, such as Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson, despite conservative opposition advocating for individualism and socio-economic power.

Immigration Around 1900

  • By 1910, one-third of the U.S. population was foreign-born or descended from immigrants, primarily settling in urban areas where their communities had established themselves.

  • Major urban centers like New York City, Chicago, and San Francisco had significant immigrant populations, leading to demographic shifts and cultural diversity.

  • Immigrants faced exploitation in industries; the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire highlighted the dangers and poor labor conditions of the time.

Expansion of Immigration Patterns (Page 2)

Key Cities Affected by Immigration

  • Cities such as New York, Chicago, and San Francisco had populations over 75% comprised of immigrants or their children.

  • The immigration stations, Ellis Island and Angel Island, differentiated the experiences of various immigrant groups, with Angel Island serving as a detention center primarily for Chinese immigrants.

Triangle Shirtwaist Fire

  • In 1911, the deadly fire at Triangle Shirtwaist Company, resulting in 146 worker deaths, sparked public outrage and led to reforms in labor laws, emphasizing safety regulations and workers' rights.

Municipal and State Reform (Page 4)

Urban Government Reforms

  • Corruption in municipal governments led to the implementation of new governance structures, like commission governments and city managers, focusing on efficiency.

  • Introduction of direct primaries allowed voters a more direct role in electing candidates, reducing the influence of corrupt political machines.

The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire

  • This incident catalyzed significant reforms in factory conditions, with leaders advocating for improved safety measures and labor laws addressing worker exploitation.

Theodore Roosevelt and the Square Deal (Page 7)

Role of the Presidency

  • Roosevelt utilized the presidency as a platform to promote progressive reforms, notably through the “Square Deal,” aiming to balance the needs of workers and businesses.

  • Faced with labor unrest, Roosevelt acted as a mediator, contrasting previous administration responses which largely sided with business.

Trustbusting Initiatives

  • Roosevelt launched legal actions against monopolies under the Sherman Antitrust Act, promoting fair competition and consumer protection.

  • Significant legislation, including the Elkins Act and the Hepburn Act, targeted railroad monopolies, emphasizing government regulation of private industry.

Wilson’s New Freedom (Pages 11-12)

Distinction from Roosevelt’s New Nationalism

  • Woodrow Wilson’s agenda focused on limited federal intervention and preserving small businesses, contrasting Roosevelt’s push for extensive regulation.

Legislative Achievements

  • Wilson’s administration produced pivotal laws like the Clayton Antitrust Act and the Federal Reserve Act, solidifying reforms aimed at economic fairness and banking stability.

Social Justice Measures

  • Although initially resistant to broader social reforms, Wilson’s presidency did enact progressive labor measures, signaling an evolution of his political stance over time.

Progressive Legacy (Page 13)

Expectations of Government and Society

  • By the conclusion of the Progressive Era, Americans anticipated a government that ensured safety in food and medicine, and protections against labor abuses.

  • Progressives sought a balance between individual liberties and social control, although often framing reforms as benefiting the general public while preserving dominant class interests.

Racial Dynamics

  • While various racial groups, including African Americans and Native Americans, engaged in progressivism, the movement was frequently marred by exclusionary and racist policies, notably in Southern states.

Conclusion

  • The diverse and uneven nature of progressive reforms reflected complex societal power dynamics, achieving significant advancements while leaving certain groups marginalized. The reforms addressed issues that might have led to greater unrest, contributing to modernization and left a lasting influence on subsequent reforms.