L4

Costs, Profitability and Breakeven Analysis

Sales and Cost of Goods Sold (Cholla Pharmacy 2011)

  • Sales:

    • Total Sales: 1,500,0001,500,000 (100.0%)

  • Cost of Goods Sold (COGS):

    • Total COGS: 1,150,0001,150,000 (76.7%)

    • Gross Margin:

    • Gross Margin Amount: 350,000350,000 (23.3%)

Operating Expenses

  • Total Operating Expenses: 321,500321,500 (21.4%)

    • Salaries and Benefits: 225,000225,000 (15.0%)

    • Rent: 12,00012,000 (0.8%)

    • Utilities: 10,00010,000 (0.7%)

    • Professional Fees: 9,0009,000 (0.6%)

    • Taxes and Licenses: 2,5002,500 (0.2%)

    • Insurance: 10,50010,500 (0.7%)

    • Interest: 11,00011,000 (0.7%)

    • Computer Expenses: 9,5009,500 (0.6%)

    • Depreciation: 19,00019,000 (1.3%)

    • Marketing: 1,0001,000 (0.1%)

    • Miscellaneous: 12,00012,000 (0.8%)

  • Net Income Before Taxes:

    • Net Income: 28,50028,500 (1.9%)

Tests of Profitability & Performance

  • Gross Margin % Calculation:

    • Formula: ext{GM ext{%}} = rac{ ext{Sales} - ext{COGS}}{ ext{Sales}} imes 100 ext{%}

    • Explanation: This measure reflects the firm’s profitability before considering expenses. High gross margins are positive but may come at the expense of potential sales.

    • Scenario Examples:

    • Scenario 1:

      • Cost = 55, Price = 1010, Units Sold = 1010

      • Gross Margin % = rac{(10 - 5) imes 10}{10 imes 10} imes 100 = 50 ext{%}

      • Gross Profit = 5050

    • Scenario 2:

      • Cost = 55, Price = 88, Units Sold = 2020

      • Gross Margin % = rac{(8 - 5) imes 20}{20 imes 8} imes 100 = 30 ext{%}

      • Gross Profit = 6060

Importance of Good Purchasing to Profitability

  • Sales Analysis:

    • Scenario 1:

    • Sales: 2,000,0002,000,000, COGS: 1,425,600-1,425,600

    • Gross Margin: 574,400574,400, Expenses: 452,000-452,000

    • Net Income: 122,400122,400

    • Scenario 2:

    • Sales: 2,000,0002,000,000, COGS = 1,440,000-1,440,000, Gross Margin: 560,000560,000,

    • Net Income: 108,000108,000

    • Key Insight: A decrease in COGS by 1% increased profits by 13%.

Gross Margin Overview for Pharmacies 2022

  • Overall Gross Margins by Company:

    • CVS Health: 25.9% (Prescriptions: 77%)

    • Rite Aid: 24.9% (Prescriptions: 70%)

    • Walgreens Boots Alliance: 21.7% (Prescriptions: 74%)

    • Independent Pharmacies: 23.3% (Prescriptions: 93%)

    • Source: Drug Channels Institute analysis of company reports and NCPA Digest.

Gross Profits and Margins for Independent Pharmacies (2017 to 2021)

  • Gross Profit per Prescription Dispensed:

    • 2017: 11.6011.60

    • 2018: 11.5311.53

    • 2019: 11.7811.78

    • 2020: 12.5612.56

    • 2021: 11.6411.64

  • Gross Margin per Prescription Dispensed:

    • 2017: 21.0%

    • 2018: 20.9%

    • 2019: 21.1%

    • 2020: 20.8%

    • 2021: 20.7%

    • Source: Drug Channels Institute analysis of NCPA digest data.

Factors for Improving Gross Margin in Compounding Pharmacies

  1. Private pay / cash

  2. Earned discounts

  3. Selective 3rd party accounts

  4. Compounding and other specialized services

Low Gross Margin Issues and Considerations

  • Potential Reasons for Low Gross Margin (< Median):

    • Membership in buying groups and potential underutilization of benefits

    • Not taking full advantage of discounts (cash, volume, prompt payment, etc.)

    • Pricing might be outdated

    • Signing undesirable third-party contracts

    • Excessive shrinkage due to theft, obsolescence, breakage, etc.

Net Income and Profitability Analysis

  • Net Income % Calculation:

    • Formula: ext{Net Income ext{%}} = rac{ ext{Net Income}}{ ext{Sales}} imes 100 ext{%}

    • Explanation: This ratio shows net profit margin after considering all expenses. When used with GM%, it indicates how well the manager controls operating expenses.

  • Low Net Income Considerations:

    • Check Gross Margin % and operating expenses through cost-of-dispensing analysis targeting high expenses.

Cost of Dispensing Study (2018)

  • Survey Overview:

    • Total Surveys: 66,000

    • Response Rate: 24%

    • Mean Overall Cost of Dispensing per Prescription:

    • Mean: 12.4012.40

    • Median: 11.1511.15

  • Major Cost Drivers:

    • Payroll costs account for approximately 58% of total costs of dispensing, i.e., 7.227.22 out of 12.4012.40.

Return on Equity (ROE)

  • ROE Formula:

    • ext{Return on Equity ext{%}} = rac{ ext{Net Income}}{ ext{Owner's Equity}} imes 100 ext{%}

    • Explanation: Measures profit earned per dollar of invested capital and allows investors to compare with alternative investment returns.

  • Low ROE Action Points:

    • Review Net Income % for improvement opportunities.

    • Assess capital investment, possibly shifting surplus capital to higher-yield investments or reducing own capital in favor of borrowed funds.

Return on Assets (ROA)

  • ROA Formula:

    • ext{Return on Assets ext{%}} = rac{ ext{Net Income}}{ ext{Total Assets}} imes 100 ext{%}

    • Explanation: Evaluates the effectiveness of all available funds to generate profits, considered superior to ROE by some.

  • Low ROA Considerations:

    • Review Net Income % for possible improvement.

    • Analyze Current Ratio, Inventory Turnover, and Accounts Receivable Collection Period for control over assets.

Limitations of Profitability Measures

  • Conventional Profit Measures:

    • Indicate past success but are ineffective for projecting future profits.

  • Break-even Analysis Benefits:

    • Enhances decision-making by illustrating profit/cost relationships across varying sales volumes and conditions.

Classification of Costs

  • Fixed Costs:

    • Remain unchanged over significant sales ranges (e.g., salaries, utilities, insurance, depreciation).

  • Variable Costs:

    • Vary in direct proportion to sales volumes (e.g., COGS, supplies like vials and labels).

Break-even Analysis

  • Break-even Point (BEP):

    • The sales volume where total revenues equal total costs; leads to neither profit nor loss.

    • Calculable in dollars or units for single product firms (e.g., a pharmacy's prescription department).

    • Multiple product firms must calculate BEP on total revenues and costs together.

Surrywood Pharmacy Case Study: Costs and Revenues

  • Total Variable Costs: 643,300643,300

  • Total Fixed Costs: 207,300207,300

  • Total Costs: 850,600850,600

Break-even Graphs for Surrywood Pharmacy
  1. Break-even Graph for Surrywood Pharmacy:

    • Sales = 892,000892,000

    • BEP = 744,000744,000

  2. Profit and Loss Estimation Graph:

    • Loss @ sales 600,000600,000 is 40,00040,000.

  3. Prescription Department Break-even Graph:

    • Orders analyzed based on prescriptions dispensed over time.

Contribution Margin

  • Contribution Margin Definition:

    • Contribution Margin = Revenue - Variable Costs

    • Represents revenue exceeding variable costs that contributes to fixed costs and net income.

  • Example Calculation:

    • Contribution Margin = 248,700248,700

    • Net Income = 41,40041,400

Depreciation

  • Depreciation Definition:

    • The accounting process to recognize the loss in value of a fixed asset over time.

  • Components for Calculation:

    • Acquisition Cost (C), Useful Life (N), Residual Value (R).

Straight-line Depreciation Example
  • Straight-Line Method Equation:

    • D=rac(CR)ND = rac{(C - R)}{N}

    • Example Calculation: For a cholesterol testing device costing 1,9951,995 with a useful life of 5 years and residual value of 100100,

    • Annual Depreciation Expense: D=rac(1995100)5=379D = rac{(1995 - 100)}{5} = 379