Principles, Accuracy, and Calibration of Radio Positioning
Principles, Accuracy, and Calibration of Radio Positioning
1. Overview of Positioning
Positioning classification
Based on Lines of Position (LOP) systems:
Circular systems (based on distances)
Polar systems
Hyperbolic systems
Parameters for geometric quality
Statistics and Accuracy
Modeling:
Circular systems
Polar systems
Hyperbolic systems
Calibration for:
Circular systems
Hyperbolic systems
2. Terrestrial Radio Positioning Systems
Circular Method (Active):
Also known as the ‘range/range’ method
Involves sender and receiver on a vessel
Coastal stations receive signals and respond, usually by pulse or phase.
Systems used:
Synchronised clock on vessel (e.g., atomic clock or GNSS time)
Determines distances to 2 or 3 coastal stations.
Results in circular LOPs.
Circular Method (Passive):
‘Pseudorange’ Method:
Represents false circular method, operates as a hyperbolic system.
Coastal stations send signals, synchronised (e.g., with atomic clocks).
Options include pulse or continuous wave.
Reception through:
Time difference or Phase difference.
Determines distance differences => results in hyperbolic LOPs needing 3 coastal stations to obtain intersection of 2 hyperboles.
Polar Method (Active):
Uses both distance and bearing.
Coastal station determines vessel direction using radio-goniometer.
Interaction involves pulse sent from coastal station to the vessel and back.
High accuracy achieved due to orthogonal intersections of LOPs, utilizes telemetry for position transmission.
Hyperbolic Method:
Involves a master and slave(s) system, which are synchronised.
Continuous waves are sent; phase differences correspond to distance differences, leading to hyperbolic LOPs.
3. Geometric Quality of Positioning
Random Errors:
Precision is measured by individual and accidental deviations relative to the average value.
Caused by observation or equipment imperfections.
Inevitable errors that cannot be corrected even by calibration.
Characteristic clustering of measured values around average position, where good precision indicates small random errors.
Statistics:
Boxplot Representation:
Displays first, second, and third quartiles.
Defines outlier as distance to box > 1.5 * box height.
If no outliers, whiskers connect to smallest and largest values.
Standard Deviation (SD):
More commonly used than CEP for scientific purposes.
Sensitive to small numbers of large errors.
SD is calculated by SD = \sqrt{\frac{\sum (x_i - \bar{x})^2}{N-1}}
For a normal Gaussian distribution, 68% of values lie within 1 standard deviation from the mean, and 95% lie within 2 standard deviations.
Circular Error Probable (CEP):
Defined as the radius of a circle, containing 50% of all measurements around the best guess for the “correct position.”
4. Systematic Errors (Bias)
Systematic Error:
Defined as the deviation of the average of measurements from the 'true' position, which is often unknown.
Accuracy inversely relates to the size of the systematic error.
The most probable value can be approximated by assuming minimal systematic errors.
Sources of Systematic Errors:
Non-properly calibrated sensors; should be calibrated using more accurate values or compensated computationally.
Assumptions or simplifications in mathematical models can introduce errors; utilize precise models for accuracy.
5. Reliability and Measurement Precision
Repeatability:
Refers to positional variation with repeated measurements using the same instrument over time at the same location.
Low test-retest reliability causes variability in results.
Difference between repeatability (variation at the same place and time) and reproducibility (variation at the same location but different instances).
Blunders and Reliability:
A blunder is defined as a careless mistake that can be easily traced.
Reliability pertains to the ability to identify blunders, with improved reliability from more data availability.
6. Calibration**
Essential for checking:
Installation quality of the positioning chain.
Coordinate precision of reference beacons.
Stability of transmission parameters and good radio paths.
Calibration Practices:
Involves comparing measurements with known references (baseline crossing techniques) to verify accuracy.
Different methods for circular and hyperbolic systems involve adjustments for delays and biases to achieve accuracy.
7. Final Considerations
Distance Measurement Corrections:
Assumptions regarding the difference in shortest pathways while incorporating radio path lengths and height variations.
Address variations in speed of propagation due to atmospheric conditions and adjustments based on height differences.