Cognitive Lecture 10

Problem Solving & Expertise

Key Terms

  • AI: Artificial Intelligence

  • Recursive: Working on something in a loop to achieve new results repeatedly

  • Domain: An area of knowledge or skill

  • Abnormality: Something unusual, derived from the prefix "ab-" indicating absence of normalcy

  • Diagnostic: A process or tool that aids in identifying diseases or conditions


Key Takeaways from Lectures

  • Understanding cognition is limited by the inability to measure thought directly.

  • The brain focuses on the most noticeable and familiar information for perception.

  • Prioritization of identification and action is crucial for brain function.

  • Language is a unique trait of humans.

  • Generalizations, narratives, and schemas help simplify complex information.

  • Attention acts as a filtering mechanism between perception and cognition.

  • Psychologists focus on deliberate memorization techniques.

  • Long-term memory is multifaceted and well-researched.

  • Decision-making models have shown versatility.

  • Observing individuals at their best provides valuable insights.


Defining a Problem

  • Problem: A situation that obstructs goal achievement.

    • Cannot always rely on learned or habitual solutions.

    • Novel solutions are often necessary.


Types of Problems

  • Well-defined problems:

    • Clear goals.

    • Definable options for solving.

    • Methods available to measure solution quality.

    • Examples include puzzles and games.

  • Ill-defined problems:

    • Goals and options are ambiguous; quality of solutions is hard to define.

    • Examples include finding a job or solving a crime; most real-world problems fall into this category.


Gestalt Approach to Problem Solving

  • Examines how problems are represented and what information is considered key.

  • Gestalt psychologists dismiss trial-and-error methods focused on past animal studies.

  • Productive vs. Reproductive Thinking:

    • Productive thinking involves insights; reproductive thinking relies on known solutions.

  • Köhler's studies with chimpanzees demonstrated problem-solving through insight ("Eureka" moments).


Challenges in Problem Representation

  • Surface Features: Irrelevant but noticeable aspects of a problem.

  • Functional Fixedness: The tendency to stick to usual uses of problem elements, hindering new solutions.

  • Einstellung: Reliance on known solutions can lead to missing better options.


Analogical Transfer in Problem Solving

  • Solving new problems can be aided by recognizing analogies with others.

  • Success in analogical transfer depends on:

    • Direct comparison of problems.

    • Similar content or structural relationships.


Computational Approach: Problem Solving

  • Pioneered by Alan Newell and Herb Simon, foundational in cognitive science and AI.

  • Problem Space: All possible states between initial and goal conditions.

  • Operators: Actions that transition the current state.

  • Means-End Analysis: Involves identifying differences between states and finding appropriate actions.


The General Problem Solver (GPS)

  • Developed by Newell, Shaw, and Simon in 1959.

  • A recursive program designed to solve a wide range of problems using means-end analysis.

  • Requires problem knowledge on available methods and distance to the goal.


Expertise Development

  • Acquiring extensive knowledge and skills in a domain requires years of practice:

    • Example domains: Medicine, law, athletics, and music.

  • Deliberate Practice:

    • Not merely about hours spent practicing; focused on skill improvement, feedback, and coaching.


Expertise and Information Processing

  • Expertise enhances working memory for specific domains.

    • Example: Chess experts show superior memory for positions after short exposure compared to novices.

  • Chunk Theory: Experts can encode larger units of information in memory.

  • Template Theory: Related chunks form templates for understanding more complex scenarios.


Expert Attention

  • Expertise influences attention to relevant diagnostic information.

    • Example: Doctors and athletes quickly identify key details in their respective fields.


Differences in Problem-Solving by Experts

  • Experts see different similarities in problems compared to novices, leading to more effective solutions.

  • Expertise, while essential, is complemented by innate cognitive abilities that can impact learning and career success.


Summary of Key Concepts

  • Problem Solving: Approaches include Gestalt and Computational.

  • Expertise: Involves deliberate practice, improved memory, and problem-solving capabilities.

  • Study findings support the notion that deliberate practice and talent are both factors in achieving expertise.