Modesty, Clothing, and Cultural Signaling in Modern Discipleship

Modesty as a General Social and Behavioral Principle

  • Comprehensive Definition: Modesty is defined as a general principle that governs various aspects of life, including financial stewardship (how one handles money), the choice and display of possessions (such as a car), and personal conduct in social settings. It is not exclusively a matter of clothing.

  • The Murder and Speed Limit Analogy: While broader issues of personal character and serious societal sins (likened to murders) are of high importance, this does not invalidate the need for specific rules regarding presentation and clothing (likened to speed limits). Both levels of behavioral standards serve necessary functions in maintaining order and respect within a community.

Clothing as Messaging and Identity Signaling

  • Intentional Communication: Clothing is universally understood as a method of signaling messages to others. This is evidenced by the social norm of grooming and dressing specifically for public engagement. For instance, the act of showering and shaving before a recorded session is a choice made to present oneself properly to a large audience.

  • Identity Markers and Cultural Signaling:

    • Nerd Culture Signaling: Wearing a Sauron ring specifically during a gaming session serves as a signal to peers of a shared identity and interest in fantasy literature or nerd culture.
    • Organizational Branding: Styles from specific communities, such as "Naboo Supply" or "Ward Radio," signify membership or support for particular cultural niches. Leaders may even joke about specifically branded clothing (e.g., "incel" branding) to highlight how clothing immediately labels a person within a group context.
  • Biological and Sexual Signaling: Fitness, grooming, and healthy presentation are social markers that double as biological markers for health and sexual partnership. Even in single-gender environments, there is a latent biological competition for the opposite sex that is reflected in physical presentation and attire.

Evolution of Latter-day Saint Media and Standards

  • Historical Specificity: Former church manuals used highly specific rules to define modesty. Examples of past requirements included:

    • Specific hair grooming rules, such as the prohibition of rollers in public.
    • Constraints on extravagant hair colors or styles that draw undue attention.
    • Explicit coverage requirements, such as requiring sleeves (covering shoulders), avoiding cleavage, and ensuring clothing was not too tight or sheer.
    • Male grooming standards emphasizing being "neat and clean."
  • The "Higher and Holier" Shift: The current approach found in the For the Strength of Youth pamphlet (FSY) has transitioned toward universal principles rather than a detailed list of prohibitions. This is described as a "higher and holier" way, which suggests a harder path of personal responsibility rather than simple compliance with a list.

  • The Doctrine of Agency and Free Will: The move toward principle-based modesty is grounded in D&C 58:26−27D \& C\,58:26-27, which states: "For behold, it is not meet that I should command in all things; for he that is compelled in all things, the same is a slothful and not a wise servant; wherefore he receiveth no reward. Verily I say, men should be anxiously engaged in a good cause, and do many things of their own free will, and bring to pass much righteousness."

The Current FSY Guidelines and Invitations

  • The Three Core Sections of the Manual:

    1. Making Inspired Choices: Teaching the method of decision-making.
    2. Jesus Christ Will Help You: The role of the Savior as a support in personal progression.
    3. God's Path vs. Personal Truth: The manual emphasizes being invited to follow God's specific path, contrasting with the secular idea of "personal truth" or a customized plan that does not align with objective standards.
  • Specific Invitations Provided in FSY:

    • Treating the body and the bodies of others with respect.
    • Asking: "Am I honoring my body as a sacred gift from God?"
    • Viewing others as children of God with a divine destiny rather than mere physical bodies.
    • Avoiding styles that emphasize or draw inappropriate attention to the physical body instead of the person's identity as a child of God.
    • Letting moral cleanliness and love for God guide choices, while seeking counsel from parents and leaders.

Philosophical and Ethical Debate over "The Line"

  • The Existence of an Objective Line: Despite modern cultural pushback against labeling attire as "immodest," there is a consensus that a "line" exists where public presentation becomes inappropriate.

    • The Naked Man Scenario: If a naked man sat on a park bench in front of playing children, societal consensus (including contacting legal authorities) proves that a standard of modesty exists.
    • The Supermodel Scenario: An unclothed supermodel walking through a locker room is fundamentally categorized as inappropriate by everyone, regardless of their personal stance on clothing rules.
    • Bad Faith Arguments: Some argue that "there is no line" as a way to avoid defining standards, but in practice, everyone has a threshold where they would find a lack of clothing unacceptable. The argument is about the location of the line, not its existence.
  • Gospel Approaches: Checklist vs. Personal Generation:

    • The Checklist Gospel: A focused emphasis on external marks (shoulders, length, tightness) that can lead to pride or a belief that one is "finished" with spiritual growth once the marks are checked.
    • The Self-Generated Truth Gospel: Associated with figures like Julie Hanks, this approach suggests that the individual generates their own reality and standard, often pushing back against ecclesiastical control.
    • The Mosaic Law as a Schoolmaster: Reflecting on Jewish traditions (as highlighted by Ben Shapiro), some argue that performing physical rituals and following specific rules blindly can eventually teach the underlying truth behind them. The law serves as a necessary developmental stage.

Gender Dynamics and Protective Instincts

  • The Male Gaze and Biological Reaction: Scientific studies suggest that viewing a woman in a bikini for even a microsecond registers differently in the brain (lighting up different neurological pathways)(\text{lighting up different neurological pathways}) compared to viewing a clothed woman. This biological reality underpins the discussion of modesty for both genders.

  • The Role of Fathers: Research, including that cited by Janet Erickson, suggests that the presence of a father in the home is a primary predictor of a daughter's sexual stability and healthy pre-marital standards. Fathers are encouraged to comment on standards and assist in facilitating "common sense" regarding presentation and safety.

  • Empathy and Social Tension: Modesty can be framed as an act of empathy toward others. By dressing in a way that does not create unneeded tension, temptation, or distraction, individuals acknowledge the impact they have on the community around them.

The "Art of Shatupari" and Modern Rhetoric

  • The Shutdown Strategy: Modern discourse often employs the "Art of Shatupari," a series of slogans and phrases (such as calling someone a "Pharisee") designed to make the interlocutor "shut up" rather than actually engaging with the topic at hand.

  • The Pharisaical Accusation: Often, accusations of being "Pharisaical" are used to label anyone who suggests there is a standard or a line to be followed, even though the original Pharisees in the New Testament used their own version of "Shatupari" to shut down the teachings of Jesus.

Questions & Discussion

  • Are standard guidelines better than principle-based guidelines?: The discussion notes a "love-hate relationship" with Mosaic law. While Specific rules can provide a clear foundation, principles allow for personal spiritual engagement. However, there is a risk that youth and parents will use the shift to principles as a justification for ignoring the standard entirely.

  • How should leaders and parents communicate if FSY has no enumerated rules?: Leaders and parents are expected to have opinions and weigh in on where the line is for the youth they supervise. They should not merely be "cheerleaders," but should help kids think through the doctrine of their sacred identity.

  • Does modesty apply to men?: Yes. The discussion highlights instances where men are asked to remain clothed (e.g., keeping shirts on during sports) as part of a mutual standard of modesty that is not gender-exclusive.

  • What is the role of comfort vs. standard?: While yoga pants and other athletic gear are comfortable, the debate remains as to where they fall on the spectrum of "presentability" versus "sexual signaling," a topic often debated by cultural commentators like Matt Frad.

  • How much of the gospel is about modesty?: It is acknowledged that modesty is only a small fraction (perhaps 1/501/50) of gospel conversations, yet it remains a necessary part of the broader discussion on discipleship.