Human Flourishing Notes
Human Flourishing
Objectives
- Articulate one’s vision, justification, and criteria of human flourishing.
- Identify different conceptions of human flourishing.
- Compare Buddhist and materialist economics.
- Critique human flourishing vis-à-vis progress of science and technology.
- Write a reflection paper on human flourishing.
Definition of Human Flourishing
- A Greek and Western concept.
- Relates to eudaimonia (good spirited, by Aristotle) to describe the pinnacle of happiness attainable by humans.
- Often misrepresented by an overdeveloped and highly technological society.
- The process of developing the capacities, strengths, and virtues of the individual in different areas of their life.
Reflection Question
- Is development and wealth (or access to comfort) always the measure of a well-lived human life?
Western Conceptions
- Claims may not always representative of Western notions of human flourishing, they still operate within Western conceptions of a well-lived life.
Buddhist Economics
- E.F. Schumacher uses religious and moral principles to address human flourishing in "Small is Beautiful: Economics as if People Mattered."
- “Right Livelihood” is one of the requirements of the Buddha’s Noble Eightfold Path.
- Spiritual health and material well-being are not enemies, they are natural allies (Schumacher, 2014, p.421).
- Traditional Western economics misunderstands by prioritizing goods over people, or utility over creativity.
- Some economists treat their field as a positive science rather than a social science with assumptions.
Objective Reality
- Human flourishing isn't based on an objective criteria.
- Flourishing is more complicated than simple physical and mechanical movement.
- Understanding flourishing as mechanical reduces humans to robots or objects.
Negative Thinking Toward Work
- Focusing solely on wealth acquisition leads to unnecessary effort and dissatisfaction.
Source of Wealth & Labor
- The source of wealth is human labor.
- Automation can remove the cost in the process.
- Employer: Disutility - labor as a letting go of leisure and comfort; in relation to this, wages are understood as a kind of compensation for the sacrifices made.
Differing Views
- Employers envision “an output without employees,” while the work force envisions an “income without employment”.
- If work is treated as something to escape and run away from, then every attempt to reduce workload is always preferable. The more processes decrease labor, the better.
Automation & Division of Labor
- Companies automate due to cost, leading to division of labor and specialization.
- This efficiency is often misunderstood as progress or human flourishing.
Buddhist Perspective on Labor (Human Flourishing)
- Labor is:
- To give a man a chance to utilize and develop his faculties.
- To enable him to overcome his ego-centeredness by joining with other people in a common task.
- To bring forth the goods and services needed for a becoming existence.
Negative Understanding of Work
- Focuses on goods rather than people.
- Lacks compassion.
- Reduces the soul to a worldly existence.
- To favor leisure than work is to forget the complementarity of work and leisure in living and to destroy “the joy of work and bliss of leisure.”
Automation Types
- Enhances the skill and power of humanity (Buddhist vision for human flourishing).
- Reduces human work to a mechanical slave (leaves humanity to the position of serving the slave not the vision of human flourishing).
Buddhist Economics vs. Modern Materialism
- Civilization is about the purification of human character, not the duplication of wants and desires.
- Liberation, not against physical well-being; attachment to money and wealth is the enemy of salvation.
- It is not wrong to enjoy pleasurable things; it is wrong to live craving for them.
Consumerist Culture
- Prioritizes productivity over presence.
- Determines development by consumption: the more one consumes, the better they are from those who do not.
Human Flourishing & Consumption
- Human flourishing cannot be understood vis-à-vis consumption.
Sustainable Lifestyles
- Flourishing as a species requires locally sustainable lifestyles.
Science, Technology & Buddhist Economics
- Study of Buddhist economics is valuable even for those prioritizing economic growth.
- Finding the right path to development: the Middle Way between materialist heedlessness and traditionalist immobility, finding “Right Livelihood”.
Science, Technology, and Human Flourishing
- Every discovery, innovation, and success contributes to our pool of human knowledge.
- Human flourishing is deeply intertwined with goal-setting relevant to science and technology.
- The end goals of both science and technology and human flourishing are related, in that the good is inherently related to truth.