Macroeconomics Study Notes: GDP, National Accounting, and Economic Welfare

Fundamental Principles of Gross Domestic Product (GDP)

  • Definition of GDP: Gross Domestic Product (GDP\text{GDP}) is defined as the total market value of all newly produced final goods and services made in one country in one year.
  • Data Compilation: In the United States, macroeconomic data is compiled by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) and the US Census Bureau.
  • Output versus Income:
    • A country's total GDP\text{GDP} measures total economic output.
    • To capture average income within a country, GDP per capita\text{GDP per capita} is utilized.
    • Rankings of countries differ significantly when comparing total GDP\text{GDP} versus GDP per capita\text{GDP per capita}.
    • There is no clear relationship between country size and economic development.

The National Accounting Identity

  • Fundamental Identity: The core accounting identity of macroeconomics states that total production, total income, and total expenditure are strictly equal:   Production=Income=Expenditure\text{Production} = \text{Income} = \text{Expenditure}

  • Production = Income:

    • The total value of national production equals the sum of everybody's incomes across the economy.
    • Income components include wages, corporate profits, proprietors' income, plus a few smaller accounting categories.
  • Income = Expenditure:

    • Goods and services are valued (whenever possible) at the market price at which they are sold.
    • Total value produced (YY) must equal total spending across four economic components:
    • Consumption (CC)
    • Investment (II)
    • Government Purchases (GG)
    • Net Exports (NXNX), defined as total exports (XX) minus total imports (MM)
    • Accounting Formula:     Y=C+I+G+NX=C+I+G+(X−M)Y = C + I + G + NX = C + I + G + (X - M)

Measuring Production and Market Value

  • Market Value: Contribution to GDP\text{GDP} is evaluated using market prices. Specific tricky issues arise when measuring market value:

    • Home Production: Goods and services produced within households (e.g., homemade meals) are not accounted for in GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Underground Economy: Transactions in the informal or underground economy go mostly unrecorded due to a lack of direct data.
    • Government-Provided Services: Services provided by the government (e.g., police protection, national defense) are valued at their cost of production.
    • Imputations: Specialized accounting estimates are made for non-marketed items, such as owners' equivalent rent.
  • Newly Produced Goods:

    • Goods manufactured in previous years but sold during the current year do not count towards current GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Only the earnings of intermediaries in the transaction—if any—count towards current GDP\text{GDP}, representing service value rendered in the current year.

Value Added and Final Goods versus Intermediate Goods

  • Sum of Added Values:

    • To avoid double counting, intermediate inputs must be subtracted when calculating national output.
    • Formula:     GDP=Sum of Added Values=Sum of Revenue−Cost of Intermediate Inputs\text{GDP} = \text{Sum of Added Values} = \text{Sum of Revenue} - \text{Cost of Intermediate Inputs}
    • Alternatively, GDP\text{GDP} equals total sales of final goods to consumers.
  • Two-Country Comparative Example:

    • Eastland:
    • A farmer grows wheat and sells it for n3,000\\n3{,}000 to a miller.
    • The miller processes the wheat into flour and sells it to a baker for n5,000\\n5{,}000.
    • The baker bakes bread and sells it to final consumers for n9,000\\n9{,}000.
    • Value added by farmer: n3,000\\n3{,}000
    • Value added by miller: n5,000−n3,000=n2,000\\n5{,}000 - \\n3{,}000 = \\n2{,}000
    • Value added by baker: n9,000−n5,000=n4,000\\n9{,}000 - \\n5{,}000 = \\n4{,}000
    • Total Eastland GDP=n3,000+n2,000+n4,000=n9,000\text{GDP} = \\n3{,}000 + \\n2{,}000 + \\n4{,}000 = \\n9{,}000
    • Westland:
    • The farmer, miller, and baker work together in a single integrated firm, Country Bread, Inc.
    • The firm grows wheat, mills flour, bakes bread, and sells it to the public for n9,000\\n9{,}000
    • Total Westland GDP=Added value of Country Bread Inc=n9,000\text{GDP} = \text{Added value of Country Bread Inc} = \\n9{,}000
    • Conclusion: Final goods sales equal n9,000\\n9{,}000 in both countries.
  • Inventory Exception for Intermediate Goods:

    • Intermediate goods add to GDP\text{GDP} only if they are produced but not used within the same calendar year.
    • In that scenario, they are categorized as inventory investment, which will be subtracted when used in future production.
  • Product Classifications:

    • Intermediate Goods: Inputs used up in the production of other goods.
    • Capital Goods: Machinery and physical capital that help produce other goods; categorized as final goods because they last for years.
    • Increased Inventories: Categorized as investment in national accounts.

Geographic Scope: GDP versus GNP

  • Domestic Production (GDP): GDP\text{GDP} measures output produced within the geographic boundaries of the US by both American citizens and foreign workers.

  • Gross National Product (GNP):

    • Measures output produced by a country's national citizens, regardless of location.
    • Calculated by adding Net Factor Payments from abroad (NFPNFP) to GDP\text{GDP}, where NFPNFP equals income earned by Americans overseas minus income earned by foreigners in the US:     GDP+NFP=GNP\text{GDP} + NFP = \text{GNP}
  • International Comparisons:

    • United States: US GDP\text{GDP} and GNP\text{GNP} are very similar in overall size.
    • Turkey: Turkish GNP>GDP\text{GNP} > \text{GDP} due to substantial earnings sent back by Turkish nationals working abroad.
    • Ireland: Irish GDP>GNP\text{GDP} > \text{GNP} due to the heavy concentration of foreign multinational corporations located in Ireland.

Expenditure Approach Breakdown

  • Consumption (CC):

    • Represents approximately 23\frac{2}{3} of total GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Divided into durable goods (e.g., cars), nondurable goods (e.g., food), and services (e.g., university courses).
  • Investment (II):

    • Highly volatile component, fluctuating between 13%13\% and 20%20\% of GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Includes both business investment and residential investment.
    • Defined as Gross Investment, meaning it includes capital depreciation.
  • Government Purchases (GG):

    • Ranges between 15%15\% and 20%20\% of GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Includes government employee salaries, military equipment, roads, and public buildings.
    • Exclusion: GG does not include transfer payments (e.g., Social Security, unemployment benefits, or disability benefits).
  • Net Exports (NXNX):

    • Equals Exports (XX) minus Imports (MM).
    • Has recently been close to −3%-3\% of GDP\text{GDP} in the US.

Income Approach Breakdown

  • National Income Distribution Table:
Type of IncomePercent of GDP
Compensation of employees54.9%54.9\%
Proprietors' income8.1%8.1\%
Individual rents + interest income7.8%7.8\%
Corporate profits8.1%8.1\%
Taxes on production and imports4.2%4.2\%
Plus Depreciation of capital17.0%17.0\%
Plus Statistical discrepancy−0.1%-0.1\%
TOTAL100.0%100.0\%
  • Income Shares & Economic Debates:
    • Rule of Thumb: Approximately 23\frac{2}{3} of GDP\text{GDP} goes to labor income (labor share) and 13\frac{1}{3} goes to capital income (capital share).
    • Economic Debate: A major debate over the last decade centers on rising capital shares and increasing wealth inequality (notably highlighted by Piketty).

The Circular Flow of Income

  • Flow of Funds:
    • YY represents total income paid by firms to households for factors of production: wages, rent, interest, and profits.
    • Expenditure occurs as households, governments, firms, and the rest of the world spend funds on Consumption, Investment, Government Purchases, and Net Exports.

Circular Flow of Income Diagram

Nominal versus Real GDP and Inflation Adjustment

  • Nominal Variables:

    • Measured in current dollars.
    • Nominal GDP\text{GDP} can grow either because physical quantities of goods/services increase or because market prices increase over time.
  • Measuring Inflation (PtP_t):

    • Price level (PtP_t) is tracked using price indices such as the Consumer Price Index (CPI).
    • Related price indices include Chained CPI, GDP Deflator, Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE), and Producer Price Index (PPI).
  • BLS Methodology:

    • The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) surveys consumers to establish a representative market basket of goods and prices.
    • The representative basket is updated every few years.
    • Core CPI: Excludes volatile food and energy prices.
    • Housing: Direct house purchase prices are not included in the CPI market basket.

Purchasing Power Parity (PPP)

  • Atlas Methodology: Simply converts foreign nominal GDP\text{GDP} into standard currency units using prevailing official foreign exchange rates:   GDPChinaAtlas=GDPChinaYuan×Exchange Rate\text{GDP}_{\text{China}}^{\text{Atlas}} = \text{GDP}_{\text{China}}^{\text{Yuan}} \times \text{Exchange Rate}

  • PPP Adjustment: Because most goods and services are cheaper in developing nations (such as China) compared to developed countries, international comparisons use an international basket of goods to adjust for relative purchasing power differences.

Shortcomings of GDP per Capita as a Welfare Indicator

  • Although GDP per capita\text{GDP per capita} is essential for tracking development, it omits several vital factors that directly impact human wellbeing:
    • Pollution: Environmental damage decreases human wellbeing but is not deducted from GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Natural Resource Depletion: Extracting resources (e.g., drilling oil) raises current GDP\text{GDP} while depleting non-renewable reserves, reducing future economic potential.
    • Value of Leisure: Time spent playing, home-cooked meals, and quality time with family enhance wellbeing but are excluded from GDP\text{GDP}.
    • Income Distribution: If national income distribution is highly skewed toward a small minority, GDP per capita\text{GDP per capita} overstates the living standard of a typical citizen. In such cases, median income provides a superior measure.