PM

Notes: Evaluating Social Impact Information and CSR Reporting

Defining Corporate Social Responsibility

  • CSR defined as a self-regulating business model whereby companies integrate social, environmental, ethical, and human rights concerns into their business operations and core strategy.
  • Also described as the continuing commitment by business to behave ethically and contribute to economic development while improving the quality of life of the workforce, their families, the local community, and society at large.
  • A concept that extends beyond legal compliance and philanthropic activities.
  • Key characteristics:
    • Voluntary but increasingly expected
    • Integrated into business operations
    • Addresses impact on multiple stakeholders
    • Balances profit motives with broader responsibilities
  • In January 2025, sustainability reporting became mandatory in Australia for large corporations.

Dimensions of Corporate Social Responsibility

  • Economic Responsibility:
    • Sustainable business growth
    • Fair business practices
    • Responsible supply chain management
    • Example: Fair payment terms for suppliers
  • Legal Responsibility:
    • Compliance with laws and regulations
    • Ethical business conduct
    • Transparent operations
    • Example: Environmental compliance reporting
  • Social Responsibility (perceived as philanthropic):
    • Community development
    • Human rights protection
    • Labor practices
    • Example: Worker safety programs
  • Ethical Responsibility:
    • Values-based decision making
    • Anti-corruption measures
    • Corporate governance
    • Example: Ethics hotlines for employees

Drivers of CSR Reporting

  • Why businesses produce CSR reports:
    • Government and regulatory pressure
    • NGO and activist demands for transparency
    • Investor expectations
    • Consumer preferences
    • Reputation management
    • Competitive advantage
    • Employee attraction and retention

Reading CSR Reports: Purpose and Framing

  • CSR reports portray a relationship between a corporation and society, in the view that:
    • CSR reports aren’t neutral; they are strategic communications tools
    • Designed to influence key stakeholders
    • Represent how companies want to be perceived
    • Contain selected information presented in a specific way

Global Sustainability Reporting: Growth and Challenges

  • Sustainability reporting has grown worldwide, but:
    • There are no universal standards for information
    • Hard to interpret different kinds of data
    • Hard to compare between businesses
    • Need to know what information is not provided
    • Hard to know what information is reliable
    • Information is used by many different people with different purposes (managers, investors, communities, activists)

Key Issues in CSR Reporting

1) Short-termism: Corporate leaders prioritize short-term financial gain over long-term sustainability, hindering long-run CSR commitments.
2) Lack of Accountability: Insufficient mechanisms to ensure suppliers/partners uphold CSR standards.
3) Selective disclosure of information
4) Lack of Reliability
5) Difficulty comparing across companies or industries

Case Study: The Role of Consultants

  • Large corporations outsource reporting to consultants for:
    • Perceived objectivity and independence
    • Specialized expertise in reporting frameworks
  • Potential issues:
    • Selective framing of data
    • Limited scope of work
    • Lack of in-depth knowledge of operations
    • Reports reviewed by management prior to release
    • Limited external verification

Case Study: Australian Climate Disclosure Laws

  • Proposed climate disclosure laws:
    • Mandatory climate-related disclosures for large corporations
    • Requirements to publish climate risks and opportunities
    • External auditing requirements
  • Potential impacts:
    • Increased transparency vs. compliance without action
    • Regulatory burden vs. climate progress
    • Skills gap in reporting and auditing expertise

Questions to Ask When Evaluating Social Impact Information

  • Where can we find relevant information about social or environmental impact?
  • Who is the target of the information about social or environmental impact?
  • How is information created and shared?
  • What information is missing or incomplete?

Why Do Businesses Report Their Social and Environmental Impact?

  • The Business Case:
    • Positive effects on company image and reputation
    • Positive effects on employee motivation, retention, and recruitment
    • Revenue increases from higher sales and market share
    • CSR-related risk reduction (avoid negative press)
  • A Stakeholder Approach:
    • Measuring and improving non-financial performance increases reach of impact
    • Accountability and increased social responsibility necessitate communicating with ALL stakeholders

Benefits of CSR for Society and the Environment

  • Community Engagement: CSR initiatives address social needs, build trust, and enhance quality of life in local communities; creates shared value for companies and communities
  • Environmental Protection: Sustainable practices (reducing emissions, conserving resources, renewable energy) mitigate environmental impacts and contribute to a better future
  • Support for Human Rights: CSR initiatives that respect human rights in supply chains and production facilities promote fairer, more equitable development

Examples of Successful CSR Initiatives

  • LEGO's Sustainable Product Plan: Shift to sustainable materials in bricks and packaging; setting industry standard for environmental responsibility
  • Patagonia's Supply Chain Transparency: Efforts to eliminate forced and child labor; promotes ethical production models
  • Coca-Cola's 5by20 Initiative: Aims to empower five million female entrepreneurs across its global value chain by 2020; promotes gender equality and economic development

Information That Might Be Missing or Misleading

  • Confusing or incomplete information; selective measurement and reporting; missing data and context
  • Auditing: Minority of businesses are audited by a third party; lack of third-party verification
  • Lack of follow-through on previous commitments; reporting gaps in following through on past promises
  • Stakeholder relationships: Key stakeholder groups impacted may be left out of reporting

Where Can We Find Information About Business and Social Impact?

  • Produced by the business:
    • CSR Reports, Social Impact Reports, Sustainability Reports, Governance Reports, Annual Reports, corporate website, advertising, events, social media, storytelling
  • Alternative sources produced by other stakeholders:
    • Audits, NGO reports, journalism/media, documentaries, websites, personal stories, academic research, third-party certifications (e.g., B Corps)

Third-Party Certification Example: B Corp

  • Global presence: Over 8{,}500 certified B Corps
  • Regional presence: Approximately 700 in Australia and New Zealand
  • Evaluation across five impact areas:
    • Governance
    • Workers
    • Community
    • Environment
    • Customers
  • Certification threshold: minimum score of 80/200 for certification, i.e., 80/200 = 0.4 (40%)
  • Australian example: Thankyou Group (score: 125.7)

Tools for Evaluating Information of Large Corporations

  • Five-step framework for evaluating large corporate reports:
    • Relationships emphasised
    • Values expressed
    • Balance of impact activities
    • Missing or misleading information
    • Alignment with other sources (media coverage, NGO assessments, etc.)
  • Guiding questions:
    • Why is the business reporting this information? (business case vs. stakeholder approach)
    • How are values aligned with the core values of the business?
    • Is there a balance of economic, social, and environmental activities reported?
    • What information may be missing or misleading? (changed metrics, areas of concern not addressed)
    • Does the information align with others’ reports and assessments?

Framework for Evaluating Social Impact Information in Small and Alternative Businesses

  • Small/alternative firms face resource limits; reports can be time-consuming and expensive to produce and share
  • Key focus areas:
    • How relationships are emphasized? Consider community connections, funding relationships, customer engagement
    • Other ways of sharing information: online, social media, blogs, NGO partnerships, direct communication, stakeholder meetings, community forums, storytelling
    • Is disclosure proportionate to capacity? (appropriate expectations based on size; quality vs quantity)
    • For cooperatives, collectives, indigenous businesses, timebanks, etc., sharing social impact may look different
    • Cooperative Power: Members vote on how surplus is distributed to the community

Tools for Evaluating Information for Small or Alternative Businesses (Continued)

  • Form of information
  • Relationships emphasised
  • Social/Environmental Impact Activities
  • Values expressed
  • Disclosure relative to capacity
  • Alignment with other sources
  • Questions:
    • What sources are used to share information?
    • Who is the business trying to build a relationship with?
    • What do their social/environmental activities say about the core purpose of the business?
    • What values are expressed through these activities?
    • What is their disclosure relative to capacity to disclose information?
    • Does the information align with others’ reports of the business?

CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION: Key Takeaways

  • Apply critical analysis to all corporate impact claims
  • Consider both self-reporting and external perspectives
  • Question what information might be missing
  • Understand motivations behind reporting
  • Use appropriate evaluation frameworks
  • Balance skepticism with recognition of genuine progress

Is CSR Enough?

  • [Prompted question: Is CSR enough?]

HOW SHARED VALUE DIFFERS FROM CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY (CSV vs CSR)

  • Creating Shared Value (CSV) should supersede CSR in guiding corporate investments in communities
  • CSR programs focus on reputation and have limited connection to the business, making them hard to justify and sustain over the long run; CSV is integral to profitability and competitive position
  • CSV leverages company resources to create economic value by creating social value; aligns company success with societal progress
  • Key contrasts:
    • Value focus:
    • CSR: Value = doing good; citizenship, philanthropy, sustainability
    • CSV: Value = economic and societal benefits relative to cost; joint value creation for company and community
    • Motivation/agenda:
    • CSR: discretionary or external pressure; separate from profit maximization
    • CSV: integral to competing and to profit maximization; agenda is company-specific and internally generated
    • Scope and integration:
    • CSR: limited by corporate footprint and CSR budget
    • CSV: realigns the entire company budget; more deeply embedded in strategy
  • Examples:
    • CSR example: Fair trade purchasing
    • CSV example: Transforming procurement to increase quality and yield