Property Law Notes: Week 7
Property Law Notes: Week 7
Topics: Present Estates & Future Interests (Part 1 & 2), Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP) & RAP Reforms
Topic 1 & 2: Present Estates & Future Interests
Present estates give the holder an immediate right to possess property, while future interests give the holder a right to possess property in the future.
┌── Present Estates (e.g., Life Estate, Defeasible Fees)
│
Division of Property By Time ─────┤
└── Corresponding Future Interests
├── Retained by Grantor: Reversion, Possibility of Reverter, Right of Entry
└── Created in Third Party: Remainder (Vested/Contingent), Executory Interest
1. Classification Matrix: Present Estates & Corresponding Future Interests
Present Estate | Words of Limitation / Examples | Corresponding Future Interest |
Fee Simple Absolute | "To A and her heirs" or "To A" | None. Transfers all present and future rights. |
Fee Simple Determinable | "To A for so long as...", "until...", "during..." | Possibility of Reverter (retained by Grantor; automatic forfeiture). |
Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent | "To A, but if... O has a right to re-enter and retake." | Right of Entry / Power of Termination (retained by Grantor; not automatic, requires entry/action). |
Fee Simple Subject to Executory Limitation | "To A, but if [event occurs], to B." | Executory Interest (created in Third Party; divests/cuts short prior estate). |
Life Estate | "To A for life." | Reversion (in Grantor) OR Remainder (in Third Party). |
2. Future Interests Retained by the Grantor
Future interests held by the grantor/transferor when they convey less than their entire estate or attach specific limitations:
Reversion: Arises automatically when a grantor transfers a lesser estate than they hold (e.g., fee simple owner conveys a life estate or term of years). Always considered vested.
Possibility of Reverter: Follows a Fee Simple Determinable. If the specified condition is violated, title automatically reverts to the grantor.
Right of Entry (Power of Termination): Follows a Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent. If the condition is broken, title does not automatically revert; the grantor must take affirmative legal or physical action to terminate the estate.
3. Future Interests Created in a Third Party
┌── Vested Remainder
│ ├── Indefeasibly Vested
│ ├── Vested Subject to Open (Partial Divestment)
│ └── Vested Subject to Complete Divestment
│
Future Interests in Third Party ──┼── Contingent Remainder
│ ├── Unascertained Person
│ └── Subject to Condition Precedent
│
└── Executory Interest
├── Shifting (Divests a grantee)
└── Springing (Divests the grantor after a gap)
A. Remainders
A remainder is a future interest created in a third party that follows the natural termination of a prior life estate.
Vested Remainder: Given to an ascertained person AND not subject to any condition precedent (other than the natural termination of the prior estate).
Indefeasibly Vested: Holder is guaranteed to gain possession in the future (e.g., "To A for life, then to B").
Vested Subject to Open (Partial Divestment): Created in a class of persons where at least one member is qualified/ascertained, but new members can join prior to class closing (e.g., "To A for life, then to A's children" when A currently has one child).
Vested Subject to Complete Divestment: Vested, but could be cut short by a subsequent condition (e.g., "To A for life, then to B, but if B dies under 21, to C").
Contingent Remainder: Created in an unascertained person OR subject to a condition precedent (e.g., "To A for life, then to B if B reaches 21"; or "To A for life, then to the heirs of B" while B is alive).
B. Executory Interests
An executory interest is a future interest in a third party that is not a remainder because it cuts short/divests a prior estate or becomes possessory after a gap in time:
Shifting Executory Interest: Cuts short or divests the estate of a prior grantee (e.g., "To A, but if A serves alcohol, to B").
Springing Executory Interest: Divests the grantor at a future time after a gap in possession (e.g., "To A when A passes the bar exam", or "To A for life, then to B 5 years after A's death").
4. Key Case Law Analysis
Knopf v. Gray (Tex. 2018)
Issue: Did a will devised "to Bobby... land is not to be sold, but passed on down to your children" convey a fee simple absolute or a life estate?
Rule: Testator intent governs. Restricting sale and directing property to pass to children represents the legal essence of a life estate, invalidating a fee simple conveyance to a third party.
Baker v. Weedon (Miss. 1972)
Issue: Can a court order a judicial sale of real property burdened by a life estate and contingent remainders when requested by an impoverished life tenant?
Rule: A court may order a sale of property burdened by future interests only when it is in the best interests of all parties (life tenant AND remaindermen). Selling the entire property was improper because it harmed the financial interests of the remaindermen.
Paul Smith’s College v. Roman Catholic Diocese (N.Y. App. Div. 2015)
Issue: Did a deed specifying "used for church purposes only, and in case premises shall be devoted to any other use... conveyance shall be void" create a fee simple determinable or fee simple subject to a condition subsequent?
Rule: The word "void" indicates an automatic termination upon breach (Fee Simple Determinable). The property automatically reverted to the grantor's successor when non-church use occurred.
Mountain Brow Lodge No. 82 v. Toscano (Cal. Ct. App. 1967)
Issue: Is a deed restriction limiting property use solely to a fraternal organization an invalid restraint on alienation?
Rule: While absolute restraints on alienation are void, land-use restrictions attached to a defeasible fee are valid and enforceable, even if they limit the practical market of buyers.
Folsom v. Rowell (Ga. 2007)
Issue: When does a contingent remainder vest if left to "whichever child takes care of disabled daughter Alma"?
Rule: The contingent remainder vested in the first child who satisfied the condition precedent by taking Alma into her home. Grandchildren were excluded because "children" in a will strictly excludes grandchildren unless explicit intent is shown.
5. Abolished Common Law Doctrines
Destructibility of Contingent Remainders: Abolished. Under common law, a contingent remainder was destroyed if it failed to vest at or before the termination of the preceding life estate.
Rule in Shelley’s Case: Abolished. Transformed a grant "To A for life, remainder to A's heirs" into a Fee Simple Absolute in A.
Doctrine of Worthier Title: Abolished in most states. Converted a grant of a future interest to the grantor's own heirs (e.g., "To A for life, then to O's heirs") into a retained reversion in the grantor.
Topic 3, 4, & 5: The Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP) & Reforms
1. Classic Common Law Rule
"No interest is good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest."
The purpose of RAP is to prevent "dead-hand control" and keep real property freely alienable and marketable.
[Is Interest Subject to RAP?]
│
┌───────────────────────┴───────────────────────┐
▼ ▼
[YES: Subject to RAP] [NO: Exempt from RAP]
├── Contingent Remainders ├── Vested Remainders (except Open)
├── Executory Interests ├── All Grantor Future Interests
├── Class Gifts (Subject to Open) │ (Reversion, Possibility of Reverter,
└── Commercial Options (in many states) │ Right of Entry)
└── Fully Vested Interests
2. Analytical Step-by-Step RAP Framework
Identify the Interest: Check if it is a contingent remainder, executory interest, open class gift, or commercial option.
Identify the Measuring Life (Validating Life): Find a person in existence at the creation of the interest who is connected to the grant.
Test Vesting: Determine if there is any possible scenario in which the interest could vest or fail to vest more than 21 years after the death of all measuring lives.
Remedy: If it can vest too remotely, the interest is void from the outset and struck from the instrument.
3. Classic RAP Pitfalls & Traps
The Fertile Octogenarian: Presumes any living person, regardless of age or medical condition, is legally capable of having children.
The Unborn Widow: A grant "To A for life, then to A's widow for life, then to A's surviving children" is invalid as to the children's remainder because A might marry someone who was not yet born at the time the grant was created.
Class Gifts ("All-or-Nothing" Rule): If the interest of any potential class member could vest too remotely, the gift fails as to the entire class.
Rule of Convenience: A judicial rule that closes an open class at the death of the life tenant to save a class gift from RAP.
4. Commercial Options Case Law
Symphony Space, Inc. v. Pergola Properties, Inc. (N.Y. 1996)
Facts: Option agreement allowed repurchasing a Broadway building up to 24 years after execution.
Rule: RAP applies to commercial options to buy real estate. Because corporate entities have no human measuring lives, the statutory period is strictly 21 years. Because the option could be exercised in year 24, it was void from the beginning.
5. Modern RAP Reforms Summary
┌── 1. Wait-and-See Approach
│ (Wait until prior estate ends to see if interest actually vests)
│
├── 2. Cy Pres / Equitable Reformation
│ (Court rewrites grant to match grantor intent, e.g., reducing age 25 to 21)
RAP Statutory Reforms ────┼── 3. Specific Statutory Fixes
│ (Abolishing unborn widow trap; setting fertility limits 13–65)
│
├── 4. Uniform Statutory Rule Against Perpetuities (USRAP)
│ (Establishes a flat 90-Year Wait-and-See period)
│
└── 5. Perpetual Dynasty Trusts
(Abolishing RAP for trusts where trustee has power to sell)
Wait-and-See Doctrine: Validity is determined by actual events as they unfold at the end of the prior estate, rather than speculative possibilities at creation.
Cy Pres / Reformation: Courts rewrite grants to carry out general intent while complying with RAP (e.g., reducing a age contingency of 25 down to 21).
Uniform Statutory Rule Against Perpetuities (USRAP): Adopted in about half of US jurisdictions; establishes an alternative flat 90-year wait-and-see period.
Trust Exemptions: Many states have completely abolished RAP for perpetual/dynasty trusts where the trustee maintains authority to alienate/sell assets.