STS concepts

Latour, "Opening Pandora's Black Box"


  • What is the distinction between "ready-made science" and "science in the making"? How does "ready-made science" provide an inaccurate picture of how scientific knowledge is developed? 

  • What is a black box?

  • How does the story of Watson and Crick and their identification of the double helix structure of DNA illustrate the concepts of science in the making and black boxes?

Thomas Kuhn's theory of scientific revolutions


  • Be able to describe the following concepts and how they are related to Kuhn's ideas:

    • Paradigm

    • Normal science

    • Scientific crisis

    • Anomalies

    • Scientific revolution

  • How does the Copernican Revolution illustrate Kuhn's ideas?

Merton and the scientific ethos


  • The four "sets of institutional imperatives" that make up the scientific ethos

  • How do these imperatives motivate scientists while encouraging them to advance knowledge?

Bourdieu and science as a field of struggle


  • Science as a struggle over scientific authority

  • What are some of the negative effects of this struggle?

  • How does competition within the scientific community minimize these negative effects, and encourage the progress of knowledge?

What are the main features of big science? Contrast big science with earlier forms of experimental science, using one or two examples.

What is the experimenter's regress, and how is it illustrated by the detection or non-detection of gravitational waves?

Gender inequality and feminism


  • What are the three dimensions of gender inequality in science?

  • Be able to give one example of each and suggest some plausible explanations for the persistence of inequality.

  • Why do some historians and philosophers argue that the definition of scientific objectivity is gender-biased?

  • Be able to give one example of possible bias in textbook science.

The social construction of technology (SCOT)


  • Be able to recognize the three common erroneous theories of technology and why they are wrong

    • The linear model

    • The diffusion model

    • technological determinism

  • Why is it important to study technology development through the eyes of relevant social groups?

  • How does the development of the bicycle illustrate this approach?

Socio-technical systems


  • What is a socio-technical system? Be able to provide one good example

  • How does the development of Edison's lighting system illustrate the concept of socio-technical systems

  • What are some of the typical social components of these systems?

  • Be able to explain and provide at least one example for each of the following concepts:

    • Reverse salient

    • technological momentum

    • System

Expertise


  • What are the two elements of expertise, and why is it difficult to identify who is an expert?

  • Why is there often a disconnect between these two elements? Be able to provide an example.

  • How has our reliance on experts grown in the past 75 years? Provide one or two examples.

  • What factors explain the "crisis of trust" in experts?

  • How can experts, through their own actions, lose public trust? How does the case of the Cumbrian sheep farmers after the Chornobyl disaster illustrate this?

  • What role do the internet and social media play in the crisis of trust in experts?

Participatory research and lay expertise


  • What are the alternatives to the traditional division between experts and laypeople? Name and describe at least two.

  • How have activist organizations tried to overcome the lay-expert divide? Be able to provide at least one good example.

  • What are some of the pitfalls of lay expertise or activist-expert collaboration? How is this problem exemplified by the case of AIDS activists? Be able to illustrate with a real-world case.