Criminal Liability - Actus Reus

Elements of Crimes

  • Crimes do not exist in the abstract, but rather are specifically defined by a statute passed by a legislature

    • Each crime is made up of specific ingredients, which we call elements

  • The elements or ingredients of a crime:

    • Tell us what conduct is prohibited and what state of mind is necessary to have a crime

    • Example:

      • One section of the crime of the murder statute in Ohio sets forth these elements: “purposely caused the death of another.” So to be guilty of murder in Ohio under that section, the defendant would have to commit the conduct of “causing the death of another”, and would also have to do so with the mental culpability of doing that “purposely”

        • Purposely is separately defined in the Ohio Revised Code, and we will examine that in our next chapter.

    • Tell us what the government must prove to obtain a lawful conviction

Concurrence

  • Generally, in the US we only punish people who commit a prohibited act when they also have the requisite mental culpability…

    • And the mental aspect coincides with the criminal conduct

    • We call this “concurrence”

Motive Not Required

  • While the elements of the crime include the criminal conduct that is prohibited, and the mental culpability required…

  • The elements do not include “motive”

  • Motive means the reason for committing the crime

  • And while it may be helpful for the government to prove motive, it is not required

Actus Reus

  • The “Actus Reus” is the conduct or act which is prohibited by the statute

    • Each crime must clearly state what act or conduct is prohibited

      • E.g., “cause the death of another” or trespass in an occupied structure” or “drive under the influence of alcohol”

Thought and Act

  • Cannot have a “thought” crime

    • In other words, just contemplating committing a crime without more is not a crime

  • The criminal law only punishes thoughts which are expressed through conduct

    • Even if the crime of conspiracy (as we will see later) requires some “act” some conduct

  • For there to be a crime the conduct must be a VOLUNTARY act

    • For example, hitting someone with your arm while having a seizure is NOT an assault because there was no voluntary act

    • Crashing a car during an unforeseen heart attack is NOT negligent or reckless driving

Important Ideas

  1. Criminal law punishes people, not for who they are, bit what they do

    1. We punish acts, not intentions

    2. We punish acts, not status

  2. We can only punish people we can blame

  3. We can only blame people who are responsible for their acts

  4. People are only responsible for their voluntary acts

Status Offenses

  • The government cannot punish someone for their state of being or status

    • Robinson v. California

  • However, the government can prohibit certain behavior or conduct that was done due to that status

    • While you cannot be convicted of being an alcoholic, you can be convicted of driving while intoxicated

Omission to Act

  • A failure to act may be made criminal if there is an affirmative duty to act

    • In other words, if there is a “legal requirement” to act under those conditions

      • The best example is you would not have to face punishment for not filing you tax return unless there was a law requiring you to do so

      • That law sets forth a “legal duty” to act

        • If you omit (fail to complete) that legal duty you are subject to criminal penalty because of that law

Interpretation of Statutes

  • Sometimes judges want “to do the right thing” or “to do justice”, yet the statutes which the legislature passed don’t allow it

    • Can the judge ignore the statutory language and decide it means something else?

  • If the language in the statute is clear, a judge is not legally supposed to change that language just because the judge disagrees with that law as it is written

    • However, in real life there are times when judges do so anyway!

  • Judges are not supposed to change the law just because they think it is in the best interest of one of the parties, both of the parties, or even society in general. That is not their job

  • If a court adds or subtracts an element of the crime as passed by the legislature and signed by the governor or president, it deprives all of us notice beforehand of what conduct is, or is not, a crime

    • Doesn’t doing so violate the Ex Post Facto and Due Process clauses of the U.S. Constitution?

Possession

  • Possession can be a criminal act in and of itself, bit it must be more than mere possession:

    • The defendant must “know” they possess the substance or item which is illegal

    • If the person merely has the item on or about their person, with no knowledge that they have it, it will not be a criminal act

      • Example: If you were in an airport and a stranger stuck a packet of cocaine in your carry-on bag without your knowledge and your bag was searched. If you could prove these facts, you would not be guilty of possession of cocaine

  • Two types of Possession:

    • Actual Possession

    • Constructive Possession

Actual Possession

  • Actual Possession:

    • Physical possession when you know you possess it

    • Example: Having the item in your purse or briefcase that you are holding or have near you

Constructive Possession

  • Constructive Possession:

    • Know where the item is and are in a position to exercise dominion and control over that item either personally or through others; however

      • Do not actually have it in your personal, physical possession

        • E.g., You know you have marijuana under the driver’s seat of the car you are driving

Circumstantial Evidence

  • A crime can be proven by DIRECT EVIDENCE,

    • That is evidence that comes from a witness’s own five senses, OR

  • CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE

    • That is evidence where one fact can be inferred from another fact

  • OR a combination of both

Example

  • Let’s say Hermione baked a cherry pie, and places the pie on a rack on the kitchen table so that it can cool.

  • She hears her clothes dryer downstairs buzz and she leaves her four-year-old son upstairs so that she can go downstairs to get the laundry before it wrinkles.

  • When Hermione comes back up, she sees a piece of the pie missing, and she sees Harry’s face all red with cherry juice on it.

    • With the evidence above, I can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Harry took the piece of pie, even though no one directly saw him do it, right?