ARP Lec 2: Writing a Scientific Manuscript and Working in a research team

Group Work and Supervisor Communication

  • All students have been divided into groups for project work.

  • Importance of reaching out to your assigned supervisor:

    • Supervisors should be informed about group assignments.

    • Maintain strong communication from the start to ensure a positive relationship and avoid being chased for updates.

    • Introduction email should include your excitement and requests for a meeting time.

    • Ensure supervisors are aware of who you are as they may not recognize your names initially.

  • Supervisor marking criteria will account for engagement over the whole year, not just initial contact.

    • No immediate penalties for late contact, but proactive communication is essential.

Writing Scientific Modules

  • Focus of this segment: Writing research manuscripts.

  • Importance of reviewing the Scientific Writing Module:

    • Many students have already completed this; it's highly beneficial.

    • Provides resources for writing, referencing (e.g., EndNote), literature review processes, and list building.

  • Major themes to consider in writing:

    • Scientific writing differs significantly from prior assignments.

    • Emphasis on providing a coherent narrative and guiding the reader through the research context.

Structure of Introductions

  • Guidelines for constructing the introduction of a manuscript:

    • Start with a broad overview of the subject area to provide context.

    • Include literature to outline existing research and identify gaps, leading to your research question.

    • Ensure all sections in the literature review align logically with your selected question.

  • Developing a compelling research question:

    • Should influence the initial literature review and guide the remainder of the manuscript.

    • Avoid writing a review that strays from the research question.

Writing Strategies and Methods

  • Importance of drafting in academic writing:

    • Write initial drafts without the fear of quality; editing can improve upon early drafts later.

    • Writing paragraphs with clear topic sentences can aid in structuring ideas.

  • Suggestions on structuring methods section:

    • Clearly state what was done, possibly writing it prospectively.

    • Very straightforward focus; easy to draft at the beginning of the writing process.

Results and Discussion Sections

  • Key differences:

    • Results Section:

    • Focuses on describing data obtained (e.g., graphs/tables).

    • Each significant piece of data should be contextualized rather than displayed in abundance.

    • Discussion Section:

    • Links findings back to the introduction; explores implications and provides meaning.

    • Discusses the significance of results, potential future directions, and how they relate to previous work in the field.

  • Encouragement to reflect on the findings while writing results to prepare for the discussion.

Conclusion and Manuscript Structure

  • Conclusions summarize key points and convey the take-home message of the research.

  • Stress on not leaving manuscript writing to the last minute:

    • Need for time to refine the work after initial drafts, requiring distance from the text for clarity in revision.

  • Common structure used in academic writing is IMRAD (Introduction, Method, Results, and Discussion).

Research Question Development

  • Importance of crafting a good research question:

    • Should be related to the dataset and practitioners' needs.

    • Avoid overly broad questions; ensure it can feasibly be answered within the project time frame.

    • Discuss potential hypotheses, if applicable, depending on research type (exploratory studies may not necessitate a hypothesis).

Assessment Criteria and Timelines

  • First assessment consists of an introduction (1,500 words) and a visual abstract (500 words) due at exam time.

    • Provide substantial literature reviews and context.

    • Visual abstracts can be done in various formats (PowerPoint, Canva) but should not exceed the word limit, focusing more on visuals.

  • Contribution to the first assessment is cumulative; feedback will guide revisions in future assignments.

Peer Review Process

  • Importance of peer feedback:

    • Opening avenues for collaboration and refining research through external perspective.

    • Submission of visual abstracts will involve peer review early in semester two; structures should be accessible yet engaging for a broader audience.

Team Dynamics in Research

  • Research is primarily collaborative; diverse teams offer varying perspectives and skills to enhance outcomes.

  • Effective communication is crucial for project success:

    • Regular updates and shared responsibilities can optimize teamwork.

    • Initiating communication with supervisors is a student responsibility.

Group Work Expectations

  • Establish reasonable expectations for communication, roles, and workload among team members and supervisors:

    • Foster an environment of active participation and accountability.

    • Supervisor communication: clarity on methods of contact and expectations for feedback timelines should be established from the start.


1. Overview of Session

  • Break from clinical content → focus on manuscript writing + teamwork

  • Students should:

    • Be assigned to research groups

    • Contact supervisors early

    • Start communication immediately (even if meeting is later)

  • Supervisor mark:

    • Based on engagement across the whole year

    • Not contacting early ≠ 0, but ongoing engagement matters


2. Writing Scientific Manuscripts

2.1 Scientific Writing Module

  • Important to complete before submitting introduction

  • Provides:

    • Writing guidance

    • Referencing help (e.g., EndNote)

    • Literature searching strategies

  • Especially useful for students with limited scientific writing experience


2.2 General Writing Approach

✏ Key Principle: “Tell a Story”

  • Guide the reader through your thinking

  • Structure:

    • Start broad → narrow down → lead to research question

🧠 Writing Advice

  • Write first, edit later

    • Even if it feels “bad”

    • Easier to edit than start from blank page

  • Writing styles vary:

    • Paragraph structure planning

    • Topic sentences first

  • Use temporary headings during drafting

  • Avoid deleting ideas → keep them for later use


2.3 Introduction Structure

Typical Flow:

  1. Broad context

    • e.g., prevalence of hearing loss

  2. More specific background

  3. What is known

  4. What is unknown (gaps)

  5. Research question / aim

⚠ Important:

  • Literature review must align with research question

  • Avoid mismatch between:

    • Literature discussed

    • Research question asked


2.4 Referencing

  • Recommended tools:

    • EndNote (via uni)

    • Zotero (free)

  • Benefits:

    • Automatic formatting

    • Easy editing when order changes

  • Referencing style:

    • APA common in audiology

    • Any style acceptable


2.5 Methods Section

  • Easier to write

  • Focus:

    • What was/will be done

  • Can be written early:

    • Prospective (“will do”)

    • Retrospective (“was done”)


2.6 Results vs Discussion

Results:

  • Describe findings only

  • Include:

    • Data

    • Tables/figures

  • NOT:

    • Just figures without explanation

  • Avoid:

    • Too many figures (e.g., 25+)

    • Reporting all insignificant results individually

Discussion:

  • Interpret results

  • Address:

    • What do results mean?

    • Why do they align / not align?

    • Comparison with literature

  • Include:

    • Explanations

    • Implications

    • Future research

💡 Tip:

  • While analysing results → write down thoughts

    • These become discussion content


2.7 Relevance (“So What?”)

  • Discuss:

    • Clinical implications

    • Educational implications

    • Broader impact


2.8 Conclusion

  • Short, clear summary

  • Key take-home messages

  • Often read first by others


2.9 Writing Process Advice

  • Do NOT leave writing to last minute

  • Allow time to:

    • Reflect

    • Re-read with fresh perspective

  • Writing improves with distance from draft


3. Research Questions

3.1 General Points

  • Usually NOT directly given

  • Supervisors provide:

    • Broad aim

  • Students refine:

    • Specific research question(s)


3.2 Scope of Research Question

  • Must be:

    • Answerable

    • Not too broad

    • Suitable for dataset

  • Can focus on:

    • Subset of data

  • Multiple questions allowed (but not too many)


3.3 Designing Research Questions

Consider:

  • What data do you have?

  • What analysis is needed?

  • Feasibility within timeframe

Example Insight:

  • Correlation → easier

  • Causation → more complex


3.4 Placement

  • Comes at end of introduction


3.5 Aim vs Hypothesis

  • All projects:

    • Have an aim

  • Some:

    • Have hypotheses

  • Some (e.g., scoping reviews):

    • Cannot have hypotheses


3.6 Good Research Question Criteria

  • Related to:

    • Data

    • Overall project

  • Reasonable & practical

  • Specific

  • Answerable

  • Time-feasible (~8 months)


3.7 Important Notes

  • Results do NOT need to be significant

  • Non-significant findings are still valuable

  • Research question can change over time


4. Assessments

4.1 Introduction + Visual Abstract

  • Total: 2000-word equivalent

    • 1500 words (written)


    • visual abstract component

Introduction (1500 words):

  • Literature review

  • Context

  • Aim

  • (Optional) hypothesis


4.2 Visual Abstract

Purpose:

  • Communicate research visually

  • Increase accessibility and engagement

Characteristics:

  • Less technical language

  • Similar to poster (but simpler)

  • Minimal words preferred

Structure:

  • Background

  • Aim

  • Methods

  • Expected results

  • Expected conclusions

Important:

  • Mid-year → predicted results (not actual)

  • End-year → updated with real results


4.3 Peer Review

  • Occurs in Semester 2

  • Students review:

    • Another student’s visual abstract

  • Features:

    • Anonymous

    • Not same project topic

  • Focus:

    • Constructive feedback

    • Professional tone


5. Writing Workflow (Step-by-Step)

  1. Meet supervisor → understand project

  2. Read key literature

  3. Develop research question

  4. Plan structure

  5. Allocate content to paragraphs

  6. Insert literature

  7. Write draft


6. Working in Research Teams

6.1 Importance of Teams

  • Research rarely done alone

  • Benefits:

    • Shared workload

    • Different perspectives

    • Diverse skills


6.2 Communication (CRITICAL)

  • Must be:

    • Consistent

    • Timely

  • Avoid:

    • Leaving messages unanswered for weeks

Expectations:

  • Students initiate communication

  • Supervisors do NOT chase students


6.3 Communication Methods

  • Supervisor:

    • Usually email

  • Team:

    • Any agreed platform


6.4 Meetings

  • Suggested frequency:

    • ~every 3–4 weeks

  • Prefer:

    • Group meetings (more efficient)

  • Zoom etiquette:

    • Camera on

    • Professional behaviour

    • Record if someone absent


6.5 Email Practices

  • CC all team members

  • Keep everyone informed


6.6 Response Time Expectations

  • Supervisor:

    • Allow a few days

    • Follow up after ~1 week

  • Peers:

    • ~24 hours reasonable


6.7 Timeframes

  • Plan early

  • Agree on deadlines

  • Supervisor manuscript review:

    • Minimum ~2–3 weeks notice


6.8 Responsibilities

Supervisor:

  • Provide guidance

  • Ensure project feasibility

  • Support (not do work)

Students:

  • Initiate communication

  • Complete tasks

  • Maintain data accuracy

  • Stay engaged


6.9 Meetings – Best Practice

  • Come prepared with questions

  • Take notes

  • Optional agenda helpful

  • Record meetings if needed


7. Team Dynamics & Personalities

Common Roles (from activity):

  • Dominator

  • Silent member

  • Procrastinator

  • Idea thief

Key Insight:

  • Different personalities affect teamwork

  • Important to:

    • Be self-aware

    • Manage weaknesses

    • Work toward shared goal


8. Feedback

8.1 Nature of Feedback

  • Essential in research

  • Often focuses on:

    • What needs improvement (not positives)


8.2 How to Approach Feedback

  • Not personal criticism

  • Aim:

    • Improve work

  • May feel uncomfortable initially

  • Reflection helps recognise value


8.3 Types of Feedback

  • Peer review

  • Supervisor feedback

  • Examiner feedback