CLC Lecture 4
Servant Leadership
Page 10
Servant leadership is about influencing and serving.
Most writing on servant leadership focuses on how it should be, rather than how it is in practice.
Servant leaders prioritize the good of their followers and emphasize follower development.
Servant leaders are ethical and lead for the greater good of the organization, community, and society.
Anyone can learn how to be a servant leader.
Servant leadership challenges traditional beliefs about leadership.
Page 11
Servant leadership characteristics:
Listening
Empathy
Healing and helping others overcome their problems
Awareness
Persuasion
Conceptualization
Foresight and anticipation
Stewardship and taking responsibility for their role
Commitment to the growth of people
Building community
Greenleaf's writings identified these characteristics as central to servant leadership.
Page 12
Antecedents of servant leadership:
Context and culture influence servant leadership across different norms and expectations.
Leader attributes, such as moral development and emotional intelligence, impact the ability to engage in servant leadership.
Follower receptivity influences the impact of servant leadership on outcomes.
Page 13
Behaviors of servant leadership:
Conceptualizing and understanding the organization's big picture.
Emotional healing and being supportive of others' concerns and well-being.
Putting followers first and prioritizing their interests and success.
Helping followers grow and succeed by supporting their goals.
Behaving ethically and maintaining high ethical standards.
Empowering followers and allowing them to be independent and make decisions.
Creating value for the community by giving back.
Page 14
Outcomes of servant leadership:
Follower performance and growth.
Followers achieve self-actualization and realize their full capabilities.
Followers become more effective at their jobs.
Followers may become servant leaders themselves.
Organizational performance is enhanced with increased citizenship behaviors, improved team effectiveness, and improved group process and clarity.
Servant leadership has a positive impact on society indirectly.
Page 15
Servant leadership focuses on putting followers first and supporting their personal development.
It includes being honest and fair with followers.
Leaders develop strong long-term relationships with followers to understand their abilities, needs, and goals.
These behaviors allow subordinates to achieve their full potential.
Receptivity of followers is important for the success of servant leadership.
Servant leadership should result in community and societal change over the long run.
Page 21
Authentic leadership fosters positive development through greater self-awareness and self-regulated positive behaviors.
Authentic leaders are confident, hopeful, optimistic, resilient, transparent, moral/ethical, future-oriented, and prioritize developing associates to be leaders.
Multiple definitions of authentic leadership exist, focusing on intrapersonal, interpersonal, and developmental approaches.
Page 23
Intrapersonal definitions of authentic leadership:
Leaders have well-developed self-knowledge, self-regulation, and emotional intelligence.
They have realistic self-concepts rooted in values like loyalty, responsibility, trustworthiness, integrity, and accountability.
Personal life experiences and the roles played by followers contribute to the leader's development.
Interpersonal definitions of authentic leadership:
Emphasize the reciprocal interactions between leaders and followers.
Authentic leaders foster positive follower attitudes and outcomes through positive modeling, identification, emotional contagion, and positive social exchanges.
Developmental definitions of authentic leadership:
Consider both intrapersonal characteristics and interpersonal behaviors that can be learned.
Capabilities that can be learned include self-awareness, internalized moral perspective, balanced processing, and relational transparency.
Page 24
Four core components of authentic leadership:
Self-awareness: being aware and trusting one's own characteristics, values, motives, feelings, and cognitions.
Internalized moral perspective: ensuring values align with intentions and actions.
Balanced processing: objectively processing both negative and positive information before making decisions.
Relational transparency: being open and truthful in communication, building trust and fostering teamwork.
These components contribute to authentic leadership.
Self-assessment is important to determine one's level of authenticity.
Authentic Leadership (Page 25)
Positive psychological attributes such as confidence, hope, optimism, and resilience are important for authentic leadership.
These traits can be seen as fixed aspects of personality but can also be developed through training or coaching.
Moral reasoning is an important factor in authentic leadership, referring to the capacity to make ethical decisions.
Critical life events, both positive and negative, can act as catalysts for change and promote individual growth, learning, and understanding.
Other factors that positively influence authentic leadership include factors such as training, coaching, and personal development.
How Authentic Leadership Works (Page 26)
Authentic leadership goes beyond a trait-based or relational approach to leadership.
Authentic leaders possess key characteristics or core capabilities, which can be developed over time.
Authentic leaders have strong values, are transparent and trustworthy, and strive to do what is right for their followers, organizations, and society as a whole.
Many aspects of authentic leadership have not been empirically tested, so questions about its effectiveness remain.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 35)
There is no variation in leadership effectiveness by gender when other factors are constant.
Studies in the public relations and entrepreneurship fields have shown consistent results in this regard.
However, there is evidence that leading may vary by gender, but research is still too focused on a binary (male-female) system.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 36)
The qualities of femininity and masculinity have been given binary status in most cultures.
Men and women learn to act in ways that align with expectations or idealizations of their gender category.
Regardless of whether gender is socially learned or biologically determined, women have been found to apply greater degrees of empathy, better communication skills, and participative approaches to leadership than men.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 37)
In most cultures, nurturing, negotiation, communication, and concern for people skills are associated with idealized images of women.
Confidence, directive, competitive, and assertive skills are associated with idealized images of men.
The attribution of masculine/feminine qualities seems unreliable, and little consistent correlation has been found across studies.
Expectations of social behavior are gendered, and men and women are stereotyped and idealized in different ways in virtually all cultures.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 38)
Women were undervalued when occupying masculine leadership roles and when evaluated by men.
Women were not more likely to lead in an interpersonally-oriented manner but were more likely to lead in a participative manner.
Women's leadership style tended to be more transformational than that of men.
Mixed findings on gender differences in leadership style and effectiveness have been observed.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 39)
Women are underrepresented in top positions in business and government.
The glass ceiling metaphor implies an invisible barrier that prevents women from advancing.
A leadership labyrinth is a better metaphor, reflecting the challenging journey that some women have successfully navigated.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 40)
Removing barriers to advancement for women offers equal opportunity, fairness, and benefits society.
It benefits organizations by increasing the talent pool of candidates for leadership positions and making them more representative of society.
Diversity is likely to improve group productivity, and gender diversity is linked to better organizational financial performance.
Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness (Page 41)
Women are obtaining undergraduate and master's degrees at higher rates than men.
Women with children are more likely to work fewer hours, while men with children are likely to work more hours.
Research does not support the idea that women choose not to pursue leadership positions to focus on raising a family.
Other explanations for gender disparities in leadership positions include fewer developmental opportunities, less responsibility, limited access to mentors, and being in jobs that do not lead to top leadership positions.
Page 42: Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness
Differences in leadership style and effectiveness between men and women have not been supported by research.
Women are more likely to use transformational leadership.
Women and men show equal levels of commitment to employment.
Women with multiple roles have better mental and physical health than women with fewer roles.
Women are less likely to promote themselves for leadership positions.
Women are less likely than men to ask for what they want and negotiate.
Women may prefer not to have leadership positions or want to avoid social backlash.
Page 43: Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness
Stereotypes can lead to discrimination in the selection and promotion of women to leadership positions.
Women of color face prejudice based on both gender and ethnicity/race.
Women may be disadvantaged in male-dominated organizations due to people's tendency to give more positive evaluations to those who are similar to them.
Governments and company leaders are not actively engaged in reducing the gender gap.
Page 44: Gender: Leadership Style & Effectiveness
There have been improvements in the past 20 to 30 years in barriers for women in political and business leadership roles.
Some women have chosen to start their own ventures to have leadership positions and flexibility.
Changes in organizations and society are making it somewhat easier for women to reach top leadership positions.
More organizations value diversity at all levels.
Organizations can use career development, networking and mentoring, and work-life support programs to ensure equal opportunities for women in top leadership roles.
Society is changing, with increasing parity in the involvement of men and women in childcare and housework.