Lecture 6
Chemical Control
Herbicides
Herbicide Resistance
Overview
Topic pertains to herbicides and herbicide resistance in agricultural practices, emphasizing information provided by Saskatchewan Polytechnic.
Herbicide Classification
Types of Herbicides: - Selective herbicides - Nonselective herbicides - Contact herbicides - Translocated herbicides - Soil-applied herbicides - Foliar-applied herbicides - Pre-seed herbicides - Pre-emergence herbicides - Post-emergence herbicides
Categories include various herbicide groups based on their attributes and applications.
Selective vs Nonselective Herbicides
Selective Herbicides
Characteristics: - Target specific types of plants. - Leave other plants mostly unharmed. - Predominantly used during the agricultural growing season.
Nonselective Herbicides
Characteristics: - Affect all plant groups without discrimination. - Typically used before planting and after crop harvest. - Commonly used in non-agricultural applications such as industrial areas and residential yards. - Limited availability of nonselective herbicides. - Some selective herbicides can act nonselectively at higher application rates. - Example: - Glyphosate (Roundup) is commonly used for pre-seed burn-off to eliminate winter annual and early-emerging weeds.
Contact vs Translocated Herbicides
Contact Herbicides
Function: Kill only the parts of the plant that they come in contact with.
Mode of Action: - Absorbed by epidermal cells, causing cell membrane destruction. - Visible effects within minutes to hours of application; plants may exhibit wetness and wilting.
Requirements: Requires high water volumes for effective coverage and contact with weed.
Resistance: Less likely to develop herbicide resistance in target weeds.
Translocated Herbicides
Also known as Systemic Herbicides.
Function: Move within the plant's vascular system to attack the entire plant.
Movement: - Soil-applied variants may move upward through xylem. - Foliar-applied variants may move in both upward and downward directions through xylem and phloem.
Effects: Slower-acting, with results observable after days to weeks.
Resistance: More likely to develop resistant weeds compared to contact herbicides.
Soil-Applied Herbicides
Purpose: Target newly germinated weed seedlings, preventing crop competition.
Application: Before or after seeding but must precede weed emergence.
Incorporation Requirement: Most need to be incorporated into soil (tilled). Some are ineffective when incorporated improperly.
Use Cases: Effective against herbicide-resistant weeds with varying modes of action as compared to foliar-applied types.
Foliar-Applied Herbicides
Application Method: Sprayed directly onto leaves.
Timing: Limited effective application window before weeds become too mature.
Availability: Majority of herbicides offered in Canada are foliar-applied.
Pre-Seed Herbicides
Definition: Herbicides applied prior to planting crops, either in fall or spring.
Types: Include both soil and foliar-applied herbicides.
Common Use: Glyphosate as a burn-off often applied pre-seed.
Pre-Emergence Herbicides
Timing: Applied after crop planting but before crop emergence.
Application Mode: Can be soil or foliar-applied.
Timing Limitations: Certain products allow application within specific days after seeding, avoiding application just before crop emergence.
Post-Emergence Herbicides
Definition: Applied to the foliage of weeds once the crop has emerged (known as in-crop herbicides).
Application Concerns: Timing must correspond with the growth stages of both weeds and the crop to ensure effectiveness and minimize damage.
Challenges: Typically, some level of crop damage is expected, yet well-timed applications should yield minimal impact.
Herbicide Groups
Herbicides classified into groups by their mode of action, targeted processes for weed death, including enzyme production, mitosis, and photosynthesis.
Total Groups: 27 distinct herbicide groups exist; 17 are relevant to usage in Western Canada.
Course will cover 8 principal groups.
Herbicide Mode of Action and Site of Action
Mode of Action (MOA): Refers to how a herbicide interacts with and affects a plant.
Site of Action: Specifies the precise location in the plant where the MOA occurs, determining how the herbicide disrupts plant functions.
Group-Specific Herbicide Mechanisms
Group 1 – ACCase Inhibitors
MOA: Block the enzyme ACCase (Acetyl-CoA Carboxylase), curtailing lipid (fat and oil) formation in roots and leading to plant death.
Target Plants: Specific to grass plants, as they are the only plants containing the ACCase enzyme.
Examples: Clethodim, Clodinafop.
Group 2 – ALS/AHAS Inhibitors
MOA: Inhibit the ALS/AHAS enzyme responsible for amino acid and protein synthesis vital for plant survival.
Target Plants: Affects both grassy and broadleaf species.
Examples: Imazethapyr, Flucarbazone.
Group 3 – Microtubule Inhibitors
MOA: Disrupt cellular division during mitosis in plant roots, leading to death.
Target Plants: Impacts both grassy and broadleaf weeds.
Examples: Trifluralin, Ethalfluralin.
Group 4 – Synthetic Auxins
MOA: Mimic natural plant hormones (auxins) to disrupt growth in the plant's active growth zones.
Impact: Can cause overgrowth leading to self-destruction of the plant.
Common Usage: Among the primary applications for post-emergent scenarios, especially in broadleaf crops.
Examples: 2,4-D, Fluroxypyr, MCPA, Dicamba.
Group 5, 6, 7 – Photosynthetic Inhibitors (Photosystem II)
MOA: Compromise photosynthesis, leading to plant death.
Characteristics: Fast-acting, primarily target broadleaf weeds.
Occasional Grass Impact: Some Group 5 chemicals may impact grasses but are generally not applied in Saskatchewan.
Examples: Bromoxynil (Group 6), Bentazon (Group 6), Metribuzin (Group 5).
Group 8 – Unknown Mode of Action
Characteristics: Highlights unknown aspects of herbicide function.
Function: Some affect lipid synthesis by alternative mechanisms different from Group 1 inhibition.
Examples: Avadex (now included in Group 15).
Group 9 – EPSP Synthase Inhibitors
Definition: Glyphosate is the only herbicide in this category.
MOA: Disrupts the EPSP synthase process, leading to a buildup of toxic radicals.
Effect: Operates as a non-selective weed killer.
Example: Glyphosate (Roundup).
Group 10 – Glutamine Synthetase Inhibitors
Function: Inhibits the glutamine synthetase enzyme leading to cell membrane disruption.
Speed: Rapid effects; mortality visible hours post-application.
Example: Glufosinate (Liberty).
Group 14 – PPO Inhibitors
MOA: Block PPO enzyme, causing interference in chlorophyll and heme synthesis.
Attribute: Newer group in western Canada, crucial for tackling resistant weeds.
Impact: Mainly impacts broadleaf weeds while capable of affecting grassy weeds when coupled with other herbicide groups.
Example: Sulfentrazone, Saflufenacil.
Group 15 – Very Long Chain Fatty Acid Inhibitors (VLCFA)
Overview: Introduced in 2021 with the inclusion of Group 8 (triallate).
MOA: Systemic action primarily affecting shoots more than roots, usually requiring 12.5 mm rainfall for activation.
Target Weeds: Normally does not effectively treat deeper germinating weeds without root uptake.
Example: Pyroxasulfone.
Group 22 – Photosynthetic Inhibitors (Photosystem I)
Classification: Non-selective, foliar-only contact herbicides that cause immediate membrane disruption leading to desiccation.
Soil Interaction: Strong soil binding; becomes inert quickly.
Toxicity: Displays high mammalian toxicity.
Examples: Paraquat (Gramoxone), Diquat (Reglone).
Group 27 – HPPD Inhibitors
MOA: Known colloquially as "Bleachers"; inhibit the production of carotenoids protecting chlorophyll from photo-oxidation, leading to breakdown of chloroplasts.
Versatility: Effective against both grassy and broadleaf weeds in various crops.
Uptake and Activity: Both foliar and root uptake with notable soil activity affecting management options.
Herbicide Resistance
Introduction to Herbicide Resistance
Resistance develops when continuous use of a herbicide allows some individuals within a weed population to survive, leading to resistant populations.
First records of herbicide resistance in Saskatchewan date back to 1988, with over 13 weed species documented resistant to 7 herbicide groups.
Development Process of Herbicide Resistance
Mechanics of Resistance Development
Resistance arises when the same herbicide is excessively applied in one field, creating selection pressure. - Susceptible weeds are eliminated. - Resistant weeds reproduce, perpetuating the resistant genetic trait.
Implications of Resistance
Requiring changes in management tactics, higher weed control costs, decreased effective herbicide options, and potential yield losses.
Herbicides do not create resistance; resistant individuals already exist in the population and are favored by previous applications.
Factors Influencing Resistance Development
Repeatedly applying the same herbicide or its equivalents (same MOA) leads to an increase in resistant weed genes over time.
The herbicide ultimately becomes ineffective.
Managing Herbicide Resistance
Importance of Proactive Management
Implementing strategies before the appearance of herbicide-resistant weeds (Proactive) is far more effective than reactive strategies that occur post-confirmation.
Strategies to Combat Resistance
Utilizing a diversity of management tactics helps mitigate risk.
Mixing and rotating herbicides with distinct modes of action, combined with cultural and mechanical efforts, can deter the evolution of resistance.
Early identification of resistance and prompt manual removal of resistant weeds can limit spreading and associated costs.
Conclusions on Herbicide Management
The increase in herbicide-resistant weed species necessitates adaptive management strategies in agriculture.
Proactive management is more cost-effective and enhances crop yield protection compared to reactive approaches taken after resistance occurs.
Scouting and Assessing Herbicide Effectiveness
Factors to Consider When Weeds Persist Post-Application
Field history.
Weed biology.
Environmental factors.
Application method.
Crop cultural practices.
Potential herbicide resistance.
Scouting Checklist
Conduct scouting 7-14 days post-application near harvest.
Record identified weed species and their distribution patterns.
Analyze correlation with application patterns.
Observe plant responses to herbicide application stages.
Consider previous field history to interpret new weed occurrences.
Importance of Scouting
Scouting aids in identifying reasons for weed survival, contributing valuable insights for future applications and management tactics.
Understanding the differences between low-level and high-level herbicide resistance symptomology is critical for effective weed management strategies within agricultural systems.
Summary of Key Concepts
Herbicide resistance is a growing concern within weed management, necessitating both understanding and adaptation in strategy to ensure effective, sustainable agriculture.