Lecture 6

Chemical Control

Herbicides

Herbicide Resistance
Overview
  • Topic pertains to herbicides and herbicide resistance in agricultural practices, emphasizing information provided by Saskatchewan Polytechnic.

Herbicide Classification

  • Types of Herbicides:   - Selective herbicides   - Nonselective herbicides   - Contact herbicides   - Translocated herbicides   - Soil-applied herbicides   - Foliar-applied herbicides   - Pre-seed herbicides   - Pre-emergence herbicides   - Post-emergence herbicides

  • Categories include various herbicide groups based on their attributes and applications.

Selective vs Nonselective Herbicides

Selective Herbicides
  • Characteristics:   - Target specific types of plants.   - Leave other plants mostly unharmed.   - Predominantly used during the agricultural growing season.

Nonselective Herbicides
  • Characteristics:   - Affect all plant groups without discrimination.   - Typically used before planting and after crop harvest.   - Commonly used in non-agricultural applications such as industrial areas and residential yards.   - Limited availability of nonselective herbicides.   - Some selective herbicides can act nonselectively at higher application rates.   - Example:     - Glyphosate (Roundup) is commonly used for pre-seed burn-off to eliminate winter annual and early-emerging weeds.

Contact vs Translocated Herbicides

Contact Herbicides
  • Function: Kill only the parts of the plant that they come in contact with.

  • Mode of Action:   - Absorbed by epidermal cells, causing cell membrane destruction.   - Visible effects within minutes to hours of application; plants may exhibit wetness and wilting.

  • Requirements: Requires high water volumes for effective coverage and contact with weed.

  • Resistance: Less likely to develop herbicide resistance in target weeds.

Translocated Herbicides
  • Also known as Systemic Herbicides.

  • Function: Move within the plant's vascular system to attack the entire plant.

  • Movement:   - Soil-applied variants may move upward through xylem.   - Foliar-applied variants may move in both upward and downward directions through xylem and phloem.

  • Effects: Slower-acting, with results observable after days to weeks.

  • Resistance: More likely to develop resistant weeds compared to contact herbicides.

Soil-Applied Herbicides

  • Purpose: Target newly germinated weed seedlings, preventing crop competition.

  • Application: Before or after seeding but must precede weed emergence.

  • Incorporation Requirement: Most need to be incorporated into soil (tilled). Some are ineffective when incorporated improperly.

  • Use Cases: Effective against herbicide-resistant weeds with varying modes of action as compared to foliar-applied types.

Foliar-Applied Herbicides

  • Application Method: Sprayed directly onto leaves.

  • Timing: Limited effective application window before weeds become too mature.

  • Availability: Majority of herbicides offered in Canada are foliar-applied.

Pre-Seed Herbicides

  • Definition: Herbicides applied prior to planting crops, either in fall or spring.

  • Types: Include both soil and foliar-applied herbicides.

  • Common Use: Glyphosate as a burn-off often applied pre-seed.

Pre-Emergence Herbicides

  • Timing: Applied after crop planting but before crop emergence.

  • Application Mode: Can be soil or foliar-applied.

  • Timing Limitations: Certain products allow application within specific days after seeding, avoiding application just before crop emergence.

Post-Emergence Herbicides

  • Definition: Applied to the foliage of weeds once the crop has emerged (known as in-crop herbicides).

  • Application Concerns: Timing must correspond with the growth stages of both weeds and the crop to ensure effectiveness and minimize damage.

  • Challenges: Typically, some level of crop damage is expected, yet well-timed applications should yield minimal impact.

Herbicide Groups

  • Herbicides classified into groups by their mode of action, targeted processes for weed death, including enzyme production, mitosis, and photosynthesis.

  • Total Groups: 27 distinct herbicide groups exist; 17 are relevant to usage in Western Canada.

  • Course will cover 8 principal groups.

Herbicide Mode of Action and Site of Action

  • Mode of Action (MOA): Refers to how a herbicide interacts with and affects a plant.

  • Site of Action: Specifies the precise location in the plant where the MOA occurs, determining how the herbicide disrupts plant functions.

Group-Specific Herbicide Mechanisms

Group 1 – ACCase Inhibitors

  • MOA: Block the enzyme ACCase (Acetyl-CoA Carboxylase), curtailing lipid (fat and oil) formation in roots and leading to plant death.

  • Target Plants: Specific to grass plants, as they are the only plants containing the ACCase enzyme.

  • Examples: Clethodim, Clodinafop.

Group 2 – ALS/AHAS Inhibitors

  • MOA: Inhibit the ALS/AHAS enzyme responsible for amino acid and protein synthesis vital for plant survival.

  • Target Plants: Affects both grassy and broadleaf species.

  • Examples: Imazethapyr, Flucarbazone.

Group 3 – Microtubule Inhibitors

  • MOA: Disrupt cellular division during mitosis in plant roots, leading to death.

  • Target Plants: Impacts both grassy and broadleaf weeds.

  • Examples: Trifluralin, Ethalfluralin.

Group 4 – Synthetic Auxins

  • MOA: Mimic natural plant hormones (auxins) to disrupt growth in the plant's active growth zones.

  • Impact: Can cause overgrowth leading to self-destruction of the plant.

  • Common Usage: Among the primary applications for post-emergent scenarios, especially in broadleaf crops.

  • Examples: 2,4-D, Fluroxypyr, MCPA, Dicamba.

Group 5, 6, 7 – Photosynthetic Inhibitors (Photosystem II)

  • MOA: Compromise photosynthesis, leading to plant death.

  • Characteristics: Fast-acting, primarily target broadleaf weeds.

  • Occasional Grass Impact: Some Group 5 chemicals may impact grasses but are generally not applied in Saskatchewan.

  • Examples: Bromoxynil (Group 6), Bentazon (Group 6), Metribuzin (Group 5).

Group 8 – Unknown Mode of Action

  • Characteristics: Highlights unknown aspects of herbicide function.

  • Function: Some affect lipid synthesis by alternative mechanisms different from Group 1 inhibition.

  • Examples: Avadex (now included in Group 15).

Group 9 – EPSP Synthase Inhibitors

  • Definition: Glyphosate is the only herbicide in this category.

  • MOA: Disrupts the EPSP synthase process, leading to a buildup of toxic radicals.

  • Effect: Operates as a non-selective weed killer.

  • Example: Glyphosate (Roundup).

Group 10 – Glutamine Synthetase Inhibitors

  • Function: Inhibits the glutamine synthetase enzyme leading to cell membrane disruption.

  • Speed: Rapid effects; mortality visible hours post-application.

  • Example: Glufosinate (Liberty).

Group 14 – PPO Inhibitors

  • MOA: Block PPO enzyme, causing interference in chlorophyll and heme synthesis.

  • Attribute: Newer group in western Canada, crucial for tackling resistant weeds.

  • Impact: Mainly impacts broadleaf weeds while capable of affecting grassy weeds when coupled with other herbicide groups.

  • Example: Sulfentrazone, Saflufenacil.

Group 15 – Very Long Chain Fatty Acid Inhibitors (VLCFA)

  • Overview: Introduced in 2021 with the inclusion of Group 8 (triallate).

  • MOA: Systemic action primarily affecting shoots more than roots, usually requiring 12.5 mm rainfall for activation.

  • Target Weeds: Normally does not effectively treat deeper germinating weeds without root uptake.

  • Example: Pyroxasulfone.

Group 22 – Photosynthetic Inhibitors (Photosystem I)

  • Classification: Non-selective, foliar-only contact herbicides that cause immediate membrane disruption leading to desiccation.

  • Soil Interaction: Strong soil binding; becomes inert quickly.

  • Toxicity: Displays high mammalian toxicity.

  • Examples: Paraquat (Gramoxone), Diquat (Reglone).

Group 27 – HPPD Inhibitors

  • MOA: Known colloquially as "Bleachers"; inhibit the production of carotenoids protecting chlorophyll from photo-oxidation, leading to breakdown of chloroplasts.

  • Versatility: Effective against both grassy and broadleaf weeds in various crops.

  • Uptake and Activity: Both foliar and root uptake with notable soil activity affecting management options.

Herbicide Resistance

Introduction to Herbicide Resistance

  • Resistance develops when continuous use of a herbicide allows some individuals within a weed population to survive, leading to resistant populations.

  • First records of herbicide resistance in Saskatchewan date back to 1988, with over 13 weed species documented resistant to 7 herbicide groups.

Development Process of Herbicide Resistance

Mechanics of Resistance Development
  • Resistance arises when the same herbicide is excessively applied in one field, creating selection pressure.   - Susceptible weeds are eliminated.   - Resistant weeds reproduce, perpetuating the resistant genetic trait.

Implications of Resistance
  • Requiring changes in management tactics, higher weed control costs, decreased effective herbicide options, and potential yield losses.

  • Herbicides do not create resistance; resistant individuals already exist in the population and are favored by previous applications.

Factors Influencing Resistance Development

  • Repeatedly applying the same herbicide or its equivalents (same MOA) leads to an increase in resistant weed genes over time.

  • The herbicide ultimately becomes ineffective.

Managing Herbicide Resistance

Importance of Proactive Management

  • Implementing strategies before the appearance of herbicide-resistant weeds (Proactive) is far more effective than reactive strategies that occur post-confirmation.

Strategies to Combat Resistance

  • Utilizing a diversity of management tactics helps mitigate risk.

  • Mixing and rotating herbicides with distinct modes of action, combined with cultural and mechanical efforts, can deter the evolution of resistance.

  • Early identification of resistance and prompt manual removal of resistant weeds can limit spreading and associated costs.

Conclusions on Herbicide Management

  • The increase in herbicide-resistant weed species necessitates adaptive management strategies in agriculture.

  • Proactive management is more cost-effective and enhances crop yield protection compared to reactive approaches taken after resistance occurs.

Scouting and Assessing Herbicide Effectiveness

Factors to Consider When Weeds Persist Post-Application
  1. Field history.

  2. Weed biology.

  3. Environmental factors.

  4. Application method.

  5. Crop cultural practices.

  6. Potential herbicide resistance.

Scouting Checklist
  • Conduct scouting 7-14 days post-application near harvest.

  • Record identified weed species and their distribution patterns.

  • Analyze correlation with application patterns.

  • Observe plant responses to herbicide application stages.

  • Consider previous field history to interpret new weed occurrences.

Importance of Scouting
  • Scouting aids in identifying reasons for weed survival, contributing valuable insights for future applications and management tactics.

  • Understanding the differences between low-level and high-level herbicide resistance symptomology is critical for effective weed management strategies within agricultural systems.

Summary of Key Concepts

  • Herbicide resistance is a growing concern within weed management, necessitating both understanding and adaptation in strategy to ensure effective, sustainable agriculture.